THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS


NOVEMBER 24, 1999


THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:



HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)

73,622 EX PARTE JACKIE ARNWINE FROM HUNT COUNTY

73,623 EX PARTE KENNY LEE EDWARDS FROM BELL COUNTY

73,624 EX PARTE DANIEL LEE HOGAN FROM TARRANT COUNTY

73,625 EX PARTE MARK HODGES FROM JEFFERSON COUNTY

73,626 EX PARTE IGNACIO MOROLES, JR. FROM TERRY COUNTY

73,627 EX PARTE IGNACIO MOROLES, JR. FROM TERRY COUNTY

73,628 EX PARTE ANTHONY ESTES FROM DALLAS COUNTY

73,629 EX PARTE CARLOS RICO FROM NUECES COUNTY

73,630 EX PARTE KEVIN WADE LAFLEUR FROM JACKSON COUNTY

73,631 EX PARTE CECIL CLAY BROWN FROM WARD COUNTY



APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING DENIED:

73,163 MICHAEL F. ROSALES FROM LUBBOCK COUNTY



ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:

0073-98 EX PARTE EDIE DIONE MARTIN FROM CALDWELL COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

DISSENTING OPINION PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK

(JUDGES MANSFIELD, KELLER AND KEASLER JOIN)

PUBLISHED OPINION





0530-99 SUZANNE KAY DOUBRAVA FROM HARRIS COUNTY

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED;

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--PER CURIAM OPINION

PUBLISHED OPINION



ON STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:

1325-99 ROLAND CHARLES GRABOWSKI FROM ROCKWALL COUNTY

STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED; (SPA'S)

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--PER CURIAM OPINION

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION



APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING ON APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DENIED:

1110-99 TRAVIS RAMON BROOKS FROM HARRIS COUNTY

1111-99 TRAVIS RAMON BROOKS FROM HARRIS COUNTY

1285-99 DANIEL MALDONADO FROM TARRANT COUNTY



STATE'S MOTION FOR REHEARING ON APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DENIED: (SPA'S)

0628-98 DAVID WALTER HUGHES FROM HOOD COUNTY



APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

0981-99 GONZALES, ARTURO ESTRADA HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-00399-CR

1246-99 FRANK, ALONZO PAUL HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00555-CR

1247-99 FRANK, ALONZO PAUL HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00559-CR

1262-99 GARCIA, FRANK JR. FORT BEND COUNTY 01-98-00439-CR

1410-99 GONZALEZ, MARIO ALBERTO HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00282-CR

1473-99 WRIGHT, BRIAN KEITH HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00360-CR

1575-99 ZOZAYA, GUILLERMO EL PASO COUNTY 08-96-00450-CR

1597-99 SARGENT, MICHAEL FLOYD GRAYSON COUNTY 05-96-00992-CR

1602-99 AVILA, ANGEL HIDALGO COUNTY 13-98-00242-CR

1605-99 HAYNES, WALTER ERIC DALLAS COUNTY 08-97-00616-CR

1606-99 ORNELAS, FELIX, JR. REEVES COUNTY 08-98-00191-CR

1608-99 PANDO, ADOLFO CARRASCO WINKLER COUNTY 08-97-00447-CR

1609-99 PANDO, ADOLFO CARRASCO WINKLER COUNTY 08-97-00448-CR

1610-99 PANDO, ADOLFO CARRASCO WINKLER COUNTY 08-97-00449-CR

1611-99 WILLS, KEVION RAMON DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-01586-CR

1614-99 DAVIS, KENDRICK RISHARD DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-00913-CR

1615-99 DAVIS, KENDRICK RISHARD DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-00914-CR

1619-99 BEALS, JAMES EDWARD HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00689-CR

1620-99 ESPARZA, EDWARD HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00440-CR

1622-99 PRICE, ANTHONY WAYNE HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-00982-CR

1623-99 CABELLO, RAMIRO HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-00793-CR

1624-99 EVANS, D'ETTE HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01011-CR

1625-99 EVANS, D'ETTE HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01012-CR

1628-99 LEWIS, JERRY ANTHONY HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00194-CR

1629-99 ECHOLS, DONALL MICHAEL JEFFERSON COUNTY 09-99-00015-CR

1631-99 JENKINS, KENZIE GORDON DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-00766-CR

1632-99 BROWN, STEPHEN JEROME DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-01012-CR

1633-99 BROWN, STEPHEN JEROME DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-01013-CR

1636-99 WARFIELD, ERICA LATRESE DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-00063-CR

1638-99 RODRIGUEZ, MODESTO TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00146-CR

1640-99 PILE III, EMMIT WRIGHT HIDALGO COUNTY 13-99-00035-CR

1645-99 RADKE, CHRISTOPHER ARIC DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-01978-CR

1652-99 LEBRON, HECTOR JAUARIZ BEXAR COUNTY 04-97-00787-CR

1653-99 LUBBECKE, JORG MARIO KERR COUNTY 04-97-01019-CR

1655-99 ORTNER, CATHY BEXAR COUNTY 04-98-00470-CR

1656-99 ORTNER, CATHY BEXAR COUNTY 04-98-00471-CR

1657-99 GARCIA, LYON DANIEL BEXAR COUNTY 04-98-00541-CR

1658-99 VASQUEZ, JOSE ANTONIO FORT BEND COUNTY 04-98-00097-CR

1659-99 VASQUEZ, JOSE ANTONIO FORT BEND COUNTY 04-98-00098-CR

1783-99 DUCKETT, OLLIE T. TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00202-CR

1825-99 JENKINS, KENZIE GORDON DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-00767-CR

STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

0815-99 WHEELER, DENNIS (SPA'S #2) HARDIN COUNTY 09-96-00382-CR

1354-99 MARGRAVES, ROSS D., JR. BRAZOS COUNTY 14-97-00271-CR

(SPA'S #2)

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:

0000-00 VAUGHN, ROBERT WAYNE GRAYSON COUNTY 05-97-01210-CR

0000-00 VAUGHN, ROBERT WAYNE GRAYSON COUNTY 05-97-01211-CR

0000-00 VAUGHN, ROBERT WAYNE GRAYSON COUNTY 05-97-01212-CR

0000-00 VAUGHN, ROBERT WAYNE GRAYSON COUNTY 05-97-01213-CR

0000-00 PRINCE, GEORGE HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-01263-CR

(REFUSED NOVEMBER 18, 1999)

0000-00 UNDRE LAMAR RASHAW DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-02041-CR

(REFUSED 11-22-99)



APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:

1090-99 JOHNNY SILVA JIMENEZ (PDR #1) HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-00187-CR

(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

1475-99 LARRY DEAN FREEMAN GREGG COUNTY 06-98-00227-CR

(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

1476-99 LARRY DEAN FREEMAN GREGG COUNTY 06-98-00228-CR

(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)





STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:

0815-99 DENNIS WHEELER HARDIN COUNTY 09-96-00382-CR

(GRANTED ON GROUNDS NO. 1 & 2 ONLY)

(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

(PDR # 1, ASSIST. ATTORNEY GENERAL)

1090-99 JOHNNY SILVA JIMENEZ (DA'S #2) HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-00187-CR

(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

1354-99 ROSS D. MARGRAVES, JR (DA'S #1)BRAZOS COUNTY 14-97-00271-CR

(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)



APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

21,255-04 GILBERT TREVINO HIDALGO COUNTY

23,476-02 ROGER LYNN HILL TRAVIS COUNTY

26,037-17 JOHNNY DWAYNE STATEN TARRANT COUNTY

29,340-05 JOHN MICHAEL PETERSON TARRANT COUNTY

3,579-05 DONALD CHRISTOPHER JACKSON JEFFERSON COUNTY

31,915-02 ALVIN RAY COOPER LUBBOCK COUNTY

34,467-10 CHRISTOPHER KEITH HANDY HARRIS COUNTY

39,432-02 GEORGE BARKER TARRANT COUNTY

39,609-03 LEVI WOODERTS JR. DALLAS COUNTY

40,319-02 EULOGIO CARLOS NAVA KLEBERG COUNTY

40,511-01 STANLEY DEBOSE MILAM COUNTY

41,351-03 VICTOR MANUEL HERNANDEZ CAMERON COUNTY

41,351-04 VICTOR MANUEL HERNANDEZ CAMERON COUNTY

42,373-02 DAVID KEITH TATE HARRIS COUNTY

42,716-02 CAROLYN DOTHEA SAMPSON HARRIS COUNTY

42,841-02 SONYA CHAPMAN DALLAS COUNTY

42,862-01 MICHAEL LEE BARKER BELL COUNTY

42,880-03 MICHAEL FLORES WILLIAMSON COUNTY

(JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

43,255-01 BRIAN TRAVIS MACE WILLIAMSON COUNTY

(JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

43,489-02 KEVIN LEE MCCARROLL BAYLOR COUNTY

43,499-01 HERBERT SHERRIL WASHINGTON HARRIS COUNTY

43,525-01 VONCIL PRESTON SMITH COUNTY

43,536-01 JAMES CALVIN LEWIS COMAL COUNTY

43,553-01 MICHAEL LEE CRAIN MEDINA COUNTY

43,557-01 JOSE LUPE SOTO DENTON COUNTY

43,593-01 CARLOS LYNN BYRD WICHITA COUNTY

43,597-01 JERRY HICKMAN DALLAS COUNTY

43,607-01 DANNIE LEE DARBY CHAMBERS COUNTY

43,621-01 WILLIAM DANIEL JONES JR. FORT BEND COUNTY

43,628-01 PHILLIP ANTHONY WILLIAMS TARRANT COUNTY

43,629-01 TERRY LANE WILSON DENTON COUNTY

43,634-01 MARIO L. TURNER TARRANT COUNTY

43,640-01 BELINDA FAYE PRUITT SMITH COUNTY

43,642-01 CHARLES KENNETH ROSS SMITH COUNTY

43,653-01 JAMES ROBERT CROSBY WARD COUNTY

43,655-01 RAFAEL ALVARO PRIETO TARRANT COUNTY

43,656-01 RANDY E. WILLIAMS GREGG COUNTY

43,676-01 HERMAN MAYNES EL PASO COUNTY

7,856-03 MARLON DESORMEAUX JEFFERSON COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)

10,726-02 CLIFFORD S. CHILDS BEXAR COUNTY

10,913-03 ALVIN COLEMAN GREGG COUNTY

26,469-03 JOSEPH BERNARD COOPER LIBERTY COUNTY

29,730-02 LARRY WAYNE WHITE BOWIE COUNTY

31,640-02 RICHARD LEE ROBINSON LAMAR COUNTY

31,975-01 JOHN GERALD PARTLOW SHELBY COUNTY

31,975-02 JOHN GERALD PARTLOW SHELBY COUNTY

37,132-02 JAMES BARRY HOLDEN BELL COUNTY

37,169-03 VINCENT D. COLBERT VI BEXAR COUNTY

37,169-04 VINCENT D. COLBERT VI BEXAR COUNTY

38,202-04 JOE WILLIE TUCKER BEXAR COUNTY

41,380-06 ARTURO SOLIS BEXAR COUNTY

41,512-01 STEVEN BERNARD NASH HARRIS COUNTY

41,593-01 MIKE A. GUTIERREZ JEFFERSON COUNTY

41,840-01 ALEJANDRO DE LA ROSA CAMERON COUNTY

42,245-01 JUAN ALVAREZ DALLAS COUNTY

43,289-01 JOE LOUIS BEARD TARRANT COUNTY

43,387-01 DOLORES MARKEE BEXAR COUNTY

43,397-01 MARK ANTHONY TUTT TAYLOR COUNTY

43,397-02 MARK ANTHONY TUTT TAYLOR COUNTY

43,453-01 RANDY ALLEN TIDMORE GREGG COUNTY

43,513-01 LARRY J. HUNT BEXAR COUNTY

43,574-01 EDWARD JAMES LAWSON SMITH COUNTY

43,576-01 PERRY ANTHONY PARKER DALLAS COUNTY

43,585-01 TRACY MURRELLYN KEMP HARRIS COUNTY

43,585-02 TRACY MURRELLYN KEMP HARRIS COUNTY

43,603-01 TONY TERRELL HARDY HARRIS COUNTY

43,612-01 RUBEN JASSO HARRIS COUNTY

43,623-01 RONALD TITUS TOM GREEN COUNTY

43,631-01 DUDLEY MARTIN JR. GALVESTON COUNTY

43,633-01 ROGER BENTANCUR FORT BEND COUNTY

43,635-01 RASHAD LEE BENNETT TAYLOR COUNTY

43,641-01 JOSE RIVERA BEXAR COUNTY

43,643-01 ALFREDO VALDEZ VALLE HARRIS COUNTY

43,644-01 LUIS ORDONEZ RIASCOS HARRIS COUNTY

43,647-01 AMIL RAY STIMAC LIBERTY COUNTY

43,672-01 GLEN DALE RANDALL JR. TOM GREEN COUNTY

9,349-04 HOWARD CHARLES THOMAS HARRIS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

16,270-02 WILLIAM KINCAIDE JR. HARRIS COUNTY

28,481-04 GREGORY LAWRENCE HENDERSON DALLAS COUNTY

33,741-02 CARL RAY HARRIS JEFFERSON COUNTY

43,317-01 GRAYLIN WAYNE CALHOUN BELL COUNTY

43,563-01 RICHARD WALTER RADAY HARRIS COUNTY

43,598-01 TIMOTHY JOE LATHROP HARRIS COUNTY

43,599-01 DANIEL SALDANA GARCIA NUECES COUNTY

43,638-01 ROSALIO NAJERA EL PASO COUNTY

43,638-02 ROSALIO NAJERA EL PASO COUNTY

43,669-01 KENNETH J. VAN DOOZER BEXAR COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)

43,594-01 OMARI BARNES BRAZOS COUNTY

43,594-02 OMARI BARNES BRAZOS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)

12,024-02 BILLIE G. MARTIN JEFFERSON COUNTY

25,456-02 DARRELL W. WILTZ JEFFERSON COUNTY

26,996-02 EDWARD PEKAR LAVACA COUNTY

31,780-02 BILLY TROY MARTIN LAMAR COUNTY

35,758-05 REGINALD O'MAR ANDERS MIDLAND COUNTY

35,758-06 REGINALD O'MAR ANDERS MIDLAND COUNTY

36,243-05 CARL E. DETWEILER, II JEFFERSON COUNTY

37,781-02 GARY CHARLES WARREN CHEROKEE COUNTY

38,337-02 ROBERT LEE MCKAMY COOKE COUNTY

41,666-02 JAMES MICHAEL DAVIS TARRANT COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:

38,114-02 RUSSELL DAVIS TARRANT COUNTY

41,461-02 OLIE MITCHELL ANGELINA COUNTY

42,873-02 JOSE HERNANDEZ HARRIS COUNTY

43,345-01 JUAN MANUEL ENRIQUEZ DALLAS COUNTY

43,394-01 CORY LANE PADEGIMAS COLLIN COUNTY

(JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

43,421-01 MICHAEL DEWAYNE BESS HARRIS COUNTY

43,445-01 PAUL ERVIN WILLIAMS III LUBBOCK COUNTY

43,491-01 ROBERT DOUGLAS WOOD BEXAR COUNTY

43,558-01 JOSEPH JOHN JACKSON POTTER COUNTY



APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:

39,513-02 ANTHONY ESTES DALLAS COUNTY

41,055-01 KEVIN WADE LAFLEUR JACKSON COUNTY

42,722-01 SANTIAGO MARGARITO R VARELAS GALVESTON COUNTY

(FILED ON GROUNDS J, K & L)

42,825-01 MARK HODGES JEFFERSON COUNTY

42,949-01 DANIEL LEE HOGAN TARRANT COUNTY

43,224-01 IGNACIO MOROLES JR. TERRY COUNTY

43,224-02 IGNACIO MOROLES JR. TERRY COUNTY

43,227-01 CARLOS RICO NUECES COUNTY

43,260-01 CECIL CLAY BROWN WARD COUNTY

43,358-01 KENNY LEE EDWARDS BELL COUNTY

43,486-01 JACKIE ARNWINE HUNT COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT

WRITTEN ORDER:

16,885-04 JOSEPH BERRY JEFFERSON COUNTY

21,466-06 KENNETH BERNARD GIVENS TARRANT COUNTY

37,169-02 VINCENT D. COLBERT VI BEXAR COUNTY

38,131-03 JEWELL BLASINGAME DALLAS COUNTY

42,389-01 JOE ANTHONY VALDEZ JR BEXAR COUNTY

42,841-01 SONYA CHAPMAN DALLAS COUNTY

43,428-01 SIE JOE LANN COUNTY

43,674-01 REGINALD KEITH WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

42,780-01 WILLIAM WESLEY CHAPPELL TARRANT COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE

34,692-02 DELVIN LYNN ROSS HARRIS COUNTY

43,565-01 JAMES K. MASON DALLAS COUNTY

43,664-01 THERRELL D. FELDER GALVESTON COUNTY

43,675-01 JIMMY LEE CAMPBELL POTTER COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

41,673-01 TED CALVIN COLE TOM GREEN COUNTY

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

(JUDGE PRICE JOINS)

(JUDGE MEYERS NOT PARTICIPATING)