THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS



OCTOBER 31, 2001



THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:









HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)

74,202         EX PARTE JAMES MONROE LIPSCOMB, JR. FROM COLLIN COUNTY

74,203         EX PARTE RICKY D. HUCKABEY FROM LUBBOCK COUNTY

74,204         EX PARTE JIMMY CLAY FROM BOWIE COUNTY

74,205         EX PARTE JAMES MONROE LIPSCOMB, JR. FROM COLLIN COUNTY

74,206         EX PARTE JAMES MONROE LIPSCOMB, JR. FROM COLLIN COUNTY

74,207         EX PARTE JAMES MONROE LIPSCOMB, JR. FROM COLLIN COUNTY



ON STATE'S MOTION FOR REHEARING:



74,189         EX PARTE ANTHONY TODD ROBINSON FROM HARRIS COUNTY

STATE'S MOTION FOR REHEARING GRANTED;

APPLICATION DISMISSED-PER CURIAM OPINION

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION



ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:



1780-00         ARTURO SANTANA EL PASO COUNTY 08-99-00154-CR

  JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED-OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

  PUBLISHED OPINION



ON STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:



0778-99         JACK KROHN STANDEFER MIDLAND COUNTY 08-97-00641-CR

                      JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

                      CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS-OPINION PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER

                      CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

                      (JUDGE WOMACK JOINED)

                      DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE PRICE

                      DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

                      (JUDGES MEYERS, PRICE AND HOLCOMB JOINED)

                      PUBLISHED OPINION



APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:



1220-01         BRENDA SUE BAILEY HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01179-CR

  (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

  (JUDGE COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)



1221-01         EX PARTE JOHN BABIN HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01180-CR

                      (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

                      (JUDGE COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)



1222-01         EX PARTE JAMES SCHNUR HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01181-CR

                      (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

                      (JUDGE COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)



1223-01         EX PARTE RALPH SCHNUR HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01182-CR

                      (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

                      (JUDGE COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)



1224-01         EX PARTE CHARLES COLEMAN HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01183-CR

                      (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

                      (JUDGE COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)



1225-01         JOHN A. BABIN HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01381-CR

                      (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

                      (JUDGE COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)



1226-01         CHARLES F. COLEMAN HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01382-CR

                      (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

                      (JUDGE COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)



1227-01         RALPH SCHNUR HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01383-CR

                      (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

                      (JUDGE COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)



1228-01         JAMES A. SCHNUR HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01384-CR

                      (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

                      (JUDGE COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)



1229-01         BRENDA L. BAILEY HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01385-CR

                      (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

                      (JUDGE COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)



1243-01         VICTOR ABIMBOLA IDOWU DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-00168-CR

                      (GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 3 ONLY)

                      (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)







1244-01         VICTOR ABIMBOLA IDOWU DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-00169-CR

                      (GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 3 ONLY)

                      (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)



STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:



652-00         EX PARTE PHILIP DANIEL TAYLOR(SPA'S) BRAZOS COUNTY 14-99-00399-CR

                     (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)



1464-01         LETICIA M. RAMIREZ(SPA'S) SMITH COUNTY 12-00-00220-CR

                      (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)



APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:



0755-01         THOMAS, DESHUN D. HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00949-CR

0797-01         TROSTLE, TIM EDWARD HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00843-CR

0871-01         HENSON, ROY NEAL, JR. DALLAS COUNTY 05-99-01349-CR

0936-01         KAN, SHU GOU BEXAR COUNTY 04-98-00082-CR

                       (JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)

0937-01         DYKSTRA, MARCUS HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-01009-CR

0945-01         SALAS, REYNALDO HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-01319-CR

0959-01         SMITH, HERMAN HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-00295-CR

1016-01         MICHAEL, GREGORY WAYNE AKA JEFFERSON COUNTY 09-99-00412-CR

                      MICHAEL, GREGORY WADE

1018-01         WARE, STEVEN DWIGHT DALLAS COUNTY 05-99-00096-CR

1019-01         WARE, STEVEN DWIGHT DALLAS COUNTY 05-99-00097-CR

1033-01         CRAWFORD, EMERY LEE HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-01131-CR

1068-01         BOLANOS, YORDIN GAINZA HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00842-CR

1105-01         MORSE, CLAYTON EDWARD, JR. JEFFERSON COUNTY 09-00-00058-CR

1106-01         GONZALEZ, NESTOR JESUS BRAZORIA COUNTY 01-00-00486-CR

1107-01         GONZALEZ, NESTOR JESUS BRAZORIA COUNTY 01-00-00487-CR

1110-01         ROBLERO, RICKY TRAVIS COUNTY 03-00-00245-CR

1114-01         CONTRERAS, JOSE GERARDO HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-00634-CR

1115-01         KIMBERLING, GLENN MITCHELL HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00272-CR

1123-01         BOYD, LLOYD WAYNE HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-00795-CR

1156-01         GARRETT, TONY BURTEL MILAM COUNTY 03-98-00282-CR

1158-01         ALLEN, OTIS LOUIS HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00395-CR

1181-01         SHIRLEY CLARK LABLANCHE HARRIS COUNTY 01-95-01363-CR

1205-01         BOOZER, SEDERICK LEON TARRANT COUNTY 02-99-00177-CR

1208-01         BELTRAN, PAUL BEXAR COUNTY 04-99-00379-CR

                      (JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)

1209-01         BELTRAN, PAUL BEXAR COUNTY 04-99-00380-CR

                      (JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)

1239-01         CONTRERAS, MARK BEXAR COUNTY 04-99-00935-CR

                       (JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)

1264-01         NICHOLSON, DONALD RAY DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01401-CR

1265-01         NICHOLSON, DONALD RAY DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01402-CR

1271-01         CASTELLANO, ROLANDO JACKSON COUNTY 13-99-00643-CR

1292-01         HARPER, PATRICK LYNN HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-00796-CR

1293-01         HARPER, PATRICK LYNN HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-00797-CR

1302-01         ARNOLD, BRUCE ALLEN BURLESON COUNTY 14-00-00627-CR

1318-01         PROFFITT, TOMMY DEAN, JR. BEE COUNTY 13-00-00297-CR

1330-01         BELCHER, JAMES CLIVE GALVESTON COUNTY 14-00-01197-CR

1331-01         BELCHER, JAMES CLIVE GALVESTON COUNTY 14-00-01198-CR

1352-01         LUDINGTON, PETER MITCHELL HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-01183-CR

1367-01         ANGELES, GREGORIO MANZANO HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00593-CR

1436-01         ALLEN, LARRY DALE HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-01177-CR

1463-01         GONE, JUAN HARRIS COUNTY 06-99-00157-CR

1581-01         LOPEZ, BERNARDO NUECES COUNTY 13-00-00359-CR

1587-01         JOHNSON, BENJAMIN DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-00045-CR

1591-01         POTTS, PHILLIP EARL DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-00115-CR

1596-01         SANDOVAL, TAMBLE NACOGDOCHES COUNTY 12-00-00234-CR

1598-01         FULLER, JERRY WAYNE POLK COUNTY 06-00-00032-CR

1611-01         STREETY, JOHN KENT HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-01235-CR

1615-01         HERNANDEZ, LETICIA MARICELA BAILEY COUNTY 07-00-00374-CR

1616-01         NGUYEN, DIEN H. HARRIS COUNTY 07-00-00331-CR

1634-01         CRYER, KEITH ANTHONY HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-01297-CR

1635-01         SALAZAR, SAMMY HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-00252-CR

1636-01         GONZALEZ, MILTON A. HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-00824-CR

1649-01         LIGGENS, BRICE EVERETT TARRANT COUNTY 02-99-00529-CR

1652-01         MORRISON, ROY DOUGLAS TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00104-CR

1656-01         ANDRADE, JULIO HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00403-CR

1657-01         MEHMOOD, SALEEM HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00115-CR

1661-01         CARROLL, JEROME HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00942-CR

1849-01         NIX, THOMAS EVERETT HUNT COUNTY 05-98-01184-CR

1852-01         SPURGEON, ARTHUR LEE DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-00321-CR

1853-01         WOOTEN, JESSE JAMES, JR. DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-00112-CR

1854-01         WOOTEN, JESSE JAMES, JR. DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-00113-CR

1855-01         WOOTEN, JESSE JAMES, JR. DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-00114-CR

1861-01         MEDFORD, GREGORY BERNARD DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-00096-CR

1862-01         MEDFORD, GREGORY BERNARD DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-00097-CR

1867-01         FORD, ANTHONY HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01491-CR

1868-01         ALVARADO, JESUS HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00456-CR

1898-01         HOWARD, VINCENT EARL HARRIS COUNTY 10-01-00133-CR



STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:



0755-01         THOMAS, DESHUN D.(DA) HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00949-CR

                       DISSENTING OPINION PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER

                       (JUDGE COCHRAN JOINED)

                       PUBLISHED OPINION

 

1177-01         COVINGTON, TAMIYA SHANNAE(DA) TARRANT COUNTY 02-99-00465-CR

1543-01         COREA, JUAN CARLOS(DA) HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-01351-CR







APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

11,390-04         BENNY CHARLES GERMANY CAMERON COUNTY

24,370-04         ANTHONY LAJUAN PHEA GRAYSON COUNTY

43,363-04         CHRISTOPHER LEON WYBLE RANDALL COUNTY

43,911-02         MARTIN HEPNER DENTON COUNTY

44,681-02         VICENTE JESUS FLORES DEAF SMITH COUNTY

45,094-02         JESSE S. RODRIGUEZ BEXAR COUNTY

48,351-03         JAMES R. RICHARDSON DALLAS COUNTY

49,401-01         ALBERT RODRIGUEZ BLANCO COLLIN COUNTY

49,996-01         ROBY LEE BARBER JR. TARRANT COUNTY

50,015-01         JAMES M. ELLIS ANGELINA COUNTY

50,064-01         CARLOS REYES CORTEZ JR. HALE COUNTY

50,250-01         LARRY DON BROWNLEE COMANCHE COUNTY

50,252-01         HILTON FERNANDO MARTELLY BRAZORIA COUNTY

50,381-01         LATRONNA SHERNELL DEAVER HARRIS COUNTY

50,383-01         ALBERT DEAN WILLIAMS WASHINGTON COUNTY

50,397-01         GREGORY WILSON HUNT COUNTY

50,411-01         TOBY MONTANO HARRIS COUNTY

50,412-01         BRYAN VERNON FALCONER HARRIS COUNTY

50,412-02         BRYAN VERNON FALCONER HARRIS COUNTY

50,467-01         GUSTAVO AMARO TARRANT COUNTY

50,498-01         THOMAS LAMAR ROBERTSON MORRIS COUNTY

50,503-01         MARK WINTER KRESGE COLLIN COUNTY

50,503-02         MARK WINTER KRESGE COLLIN COUNTY

50,508-01         EDDIE LYNN BAUGH JR CALLAHAN COUNTY

50,514-01         GEORGE CAMERON POTTER COUNTY

50,514-02         GEORGE CAMERON POTTER COUNTY

50,537-01         JAMES M. DRURY GREGG COUNTY

50,544-01         JERRY LEE RAMIREZ CAMERON COUNTY

50,549-01         SHANNON DARREL LAURY DALLAS COUNTY

50,616-01         HARVEY LEE WOODSON TARRANT COUNTY

50,658-01         CLIFTON DEWAYNE YOUNG HUNT COUNTY

50,661-01         JOSEPH BRUMFIELD DALLAS COUNTY

50,696-01         MARK ALLAN HUBBARD ERATH COUNTY

50,721-01         BEN VARGAS FORT BEND COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)

24,382-03         JAMES MORITZ PESTINGER DALLAS COUNTY

24,382-04         JAMES MORITZ PESTINGER DALLAS COUNTY

33,275-02         BILLY CHARLES FRANKLIN DALLAS COUNTY

34,210-02         RAUL HECTOR GARZA HARRIS COUNTY

38,999-03         KEITHAN DUVON SCOTT TARRANT COUNTY

39,507-05         FREDDIE R. RUNNELS DALLAS COUNTY

44,229-03         ERIC MIRANDA LAMPASAS COUNTY

44,389-02         JOE NATHAN WILLIAMS MONTGOMERY COUNTY

45,214-02         RICKY VAN SMITH BEXAR COUNTY

45,651-02         SCOTT ALLEN SAMFORD JR. DALLAS COUNTY

47,521-01         TIMOTHY DARRELL JOHNSON DALLAS COUNTY

49,291-02         COSME ROUQUE MENDEZ MCLENNAN COUNTY

50,015-02         JAMES M. ELLIS ANGELINA COUNTY

50,201-01         KENNETH BERNARD WHITE HARRIS COUNTY

50,249-01         PAUL D. BRADFORD SMITH COUNTY

50,279-01         BRYAN KEITH BROWN HARRIS COUNTY

50,287-01         FERNANDO YBARRA PEREZ CONCHO COUNTY

50,304-01         ROBERT MOSS JEFFERSON COUNTY

50,304-02         ROBERT MOSS JEFFERSON COUNTY

50,402-01         DWIGHT LEE MOORE TOM GREEN COUNTY

50,402-02         DWIGHT LEE MOORE TOM GREEN COUNTY

50,407-01         MAXIMILIANO S. GUTIERREZ HARRIS COUNTY

50,420-01         DEBORAH L. HARPER BOWIE COUNTY

50,441-01         CHARLES WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY

50,446-01         JORGE RIVERA HARRIS COUNTY

50,490-01         CLEOTIS STEWART HARRIS COUNTY

50,504-01         ESTABAN A. LOZANO HARRIS COUNTY

50,511-01         JOSUAH DECOUX HARRIS COUNTY

50,521-01         RUSTY ROY TERRY MONTGOMERY COUNTY

50,521-02         RUSTY ROY TERRY MONTGOMERY COUNTY

50,545-01         ANDRES REYES BEXAR COUNTY

50,555-01         EUGENE JR. BRADSHAW TRAVIS COUNTY

50,582-01         CALVIN WILSON JEFFERSON COUNTY

50,588-01         TANYA JEAN CHRYAR HARRIS COUNTY

50,588-01         TANYA JEAN CHRYAR HARRIS COUNTY

50,588-02         TANYA JEAN CHRYAR HARRIS COUNTY

50,588-02         TANYA JEAN CHRYAR HARRIS COUNTY

50,596-01         TONY SHAWN JOHNSON FAYETTE COUNTY

50,625-01         BRIAN KEMP COOKE COUNTY

50,625-02         BRIAN KEMP COOKE COUNTY

50,625-03         BRIAN KEMP COOKE COUNTY

50,656-01         DWYANE ELLIOTT ROWLAND DALLAS COUNTY

50,694-01         CHARLES EDWARD PETERS HARRIS COUNTY

50,724-01         KWAME LUMUMBA HODGE DALLAS COUNTY

50,724-02         KWAME LUMUMBA HODGE DALLAS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

50,723-01         ELVIE LEWIS LISTER SMITH COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)

12,789-04         TIMOTHY RANDOLPH WALLACE DALLAS COUNTY

17,026-07         JOHN CAROL HILL DALLAS COUNTY

25,417-07         DAVID GLEN HARRIS TARRANT COUNTY

36,079-02         FLOYD EDWARD HENRY CHEROKEE COUNTY

37,644-02         BRANDON L. MONTGOMERY DALLAS COUNTY

42,311-02         JAMES THOMAS HARRIS COUNTY

45,777-02         DAVID DANIEL CROWDER COLLIN COUNTY

45,992-02         CLEOPHAS BUTLER HARRIS COUNTY

49,286-02         BENJAMIN JR. VALLIE HARRIS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER

(TEX. GOV'T CODE SEC. 501.0081 (b) )

16,371-05         DANIEL LEE GRANT JEFFERSON COUNTY

35,685-03         CHARLES RAY ROBINSON SMITH COUNTY

49,793-01         JORGE CARLOS FRIAS BEXAR COUNTY

50,468-01         ZANE LEE WHITE TARRANT COUNTY

50,470-01         WINSTON RAMZY TARRANT COUNTY

50,547-01         BRIAN RICHARD SAFCSAK TARRANT COUNTY

50,562-01         TAMMY FAY STIBBENS DALLAS COUNTY

50,562-02         TAMMY FAY STIBBENS DALLAS COUNTY

50,562-03         TAMMY FAY STIBBENS DALLAS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:

44,517-02         RICHARD CHRISTENSON WRIGHT ECTOR COUNTY

50,346-01         STEPHEN BRUMFIELD POLK COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT

WRITTEN ORDER:

30,757-02         BARBARA S. WILLIAMS TRAVIS COUNTY

46,301-02         MATTHEW PAUL LESLIE DALLAS COUNTY

46,301-03         MATTHEW PAUL LESLIE DALLAS COUNTY

49,796-02         LARRY LYNN AUSTIN FANNIN COUNTY

50,484-01         DAVID D. LAUER TRAVIS COUNTY

50,641-01         GLENN LACY DURHAM KLEBERG COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE

AND RESPONDENT IS ORDERED TO FILE ANSWER:

49,402-02         EDUARDO LALO HERRERO HARRIS COUNTY

50,347-01         KELVIN C. JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY

50,474-01         BART CASTRO TRAVIS COUNTY

50,494-01         JOHNNY D. THOMAS HARRIS COUNTY

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

49,591-01         JORGE VILLANUEVA HARRIS COUNTY

50,267-01         MELVIN WAYNE WHITE CROCKETT COUNTY

50,599-01         RAUL OMAR VILLAREAL HARRIS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:

48,672-01         MICHAEL R. MILLER DALLAS COUNTY

50,341-01         JIMMY CLAY BOWIE COUNTY

50,370-01         JAMES MONROE JR. LIPSCOMB COLLIN COUNTY

50,370-02         JAMES MONROE JR. LIPSCOMB COLLIN COUNTY

50,370-03         JAMES MONROE JR. LIPSCOMB COLLIN COUNTY

50,370-04         JAMES MONROE JR. LIPSCOMB COLLIN COUNTY

50,404-01         RICKY D. HUCKABEY LUBBOCK COUNTY



MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR ORIGINAL WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:



50,712-01         PAT JARRETT HELTON V. HON. LEE W. WATERS GRAY COUNTY





MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR ORIGINAL WRIT OF MANDAMUS GRANTED:



50,529-01         STATE OF TEXAS EX REL BILL HILL V. HON. KAREN GREEN DALLAS COUNTY