THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS


OCTOBER 20, 1999




THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:



72,640 JOHN CURTIS DEWBERRY FROM JEFFERSON COUNTY

AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE HOLLAND

(JUDGE PRICE CONCURS IN THE RESULT)

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

(JUDGE JOHNSON JOINS)

PUBLISHED OPINION

72,974 RAMIRO RUBI IBARRA FROM MCLENNAN COUNTY

AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

PUBLISHED OPINION

73,251 EX PARTE KENNETH DEWAYNE THOMAS FROM DALLAS COUNTY

RELIEF DENIED--PER CURIAM OPINION

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE PRICE

(JUDGE JOHNSON JOINS)

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)

73,568 EX PARTE GILBERT FLORES ARGUMANIZ FROM DALLAS COUNTY

73,569 EX PARTE JOSHUA FINCHER FROM TAYLOR COUNTY

73,570 EX PARTE RICKY STROBLE FROM ARCHER COUNTY

73,571 EX PARTE THOMAS M. NORVELL FROM EL PASO COUNTY

73,572 EX PARTE WILLIAM JOSEPH NOBLES FROM HARRIS COUNTY

73,573 EX PARTE TODD WAYNE PIERRE FROM JEFFERSON COUNTY

73,574 EX PARTE HARVEY ROLLINS FROM DALLAS COUNTY







ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:

0840-98 RICHARD ALLEN KELLEY FROM TARRANT COUNTY

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED ON GROUNDS

FOUR AND SIX;

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--PER CURIAM OPINION

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

1699-98 RONNIE RAY MIMS FROM DALLAS COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--OPINION JUDGE KELLER

PUBLISHED OPINION

1936-98 BERNHARDT TIEDE, II FROM PANOLA COUNTY

DISMISSED--OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

(JUDGE JOHNSON CONCURS IN THE RESULT)

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

1937-98 BERNHARDT TIEDE, II FROM PANOLA COUNTY

DISMISSED--OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

(JUDGE JOHNSON CONCURS IN THE RESULT)

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

ON STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:

1089-98 KIM ALLEN MILBURN FROM HARRIS COUNTY

STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED; (DA'S, PDR NO. 1)

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--PER CURIAM OPINION

PUBLISHED OPINION

1089-98 KIM ALLEN MILBURN FROM HARRIS COUNTY

STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 2;

(SPA'S, PDR NO. 2)

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--PER CURIAM OPINION

PUBLISHED OPINION

1458-97 RONALD NEIL BROADDUS FROM BRAZORIA COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

(JUDGE MEYERS CONCURS IN THE RESULT)

PUBLISHED OPINION

1459-97 RONALD NEIL BROADDUS FROM BRAZORIA COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

(JUDGE MEYERS CONCURS IN THE RESULT)

PUBLISHED OPINION

1460-97 RONALD NEIL BROADDUS FROM BRAZORIA COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

(JUDGE MEYERS CONCURS IN THE RESULT)

PUBLISHED OPINION

1461-97 RONALD NEIL BROADDUS FROM BRAZORIA COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

(JUDGE MEYERS CONCURS IN THE RESULT)

PUBLISHED OPINION

1462-97 RONALD NEIL BROADDUS FROM BRAZORIA COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

(JUDGE MEYERS CONCURS IN THE RESULT)

PUBLISHED OPINION

APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING ON APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DENIED:

0613-99 BOBBY WAYNE BULLOCK FROM HARRIS COUNTY

0860-99 BRIAN STAFFORD FROM BEXAR COUNTY

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

1089-98 MILBURN, KIM ALLEN (PDR NO.3) HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-00260-CR

0528-99 JOHNSON, RAYMOND T. BEE COUNTY 13-96-00560-CR

0782-99 MARTINEZ, JUAN DENTON COUNTY 02-97-00654-CR

0801-99 GOOLEY, EDMOND CHARLES DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-00960-CR

0875-99 HUGHES, CHRISTOPHER D. TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00338-CR

(JUDGE JOHNSON WOULD GRANT)

0894-99 TECCI, STEPHEN EDWARD TARRANT COUNTY 10-97-00404-CR

0924-99 SANCHEZ, HECTOR PAUL HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-01159-CR

0975-99 JONES, JAMES CEDRIC HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00154-CR

1009-99 PALERMO, THOMAS HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00339-CR

1021-99 O'LEARY, JAMES EDWIN BRAZORIA COUNTY 01-98-00285-CR

1027-99 GALVAN, JOSE ALFREDO HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00261-CR

1043-99 LEWIS, COREY RASHAAM HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-00410-CR

1052-99 DERROW, AARON DEMON HARRIS COUNTY 14-95-01410-CR

1069-99 VEGA, JUAN MATIAS FRIO COUNTY 04-98-00459-CR

1075-99 SULLIVAN, PAUL MILES BELL COUNTY 03-98-00151-CR

1107-99 BOADA, ARTURO MERENDONI HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-01044-CR

1142-99 LAWRENCE, SALLY HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01535-CR

1261-99 CANADA, ROBERT HAROLD HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-01440-CR

1265-99 NGUYEN, TAN DUY HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00256-CR

1269-99 GUILORY, REGINALD WAYNE HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00909-CR

1289-99 HERNANDEZ, MELVIN HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01566-CR

1292-99 TAWATER, DONNA SUE DENTON COUNTY 02-98-00102-CR

1299-99 MEDRANO, FERNANDO DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-01233-CR

1300-99 MEDRANO, FERNANDO DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-01234-CR

1301-99 ALTAEE, BASSIM EFAN HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00241-CR

1308-99 FLANNERY, KEITH EARL, JR. BRAZORIA COUNTY 01-97-01104-CR

1310-99 CHATMAN, GILBERT LACY NACOGDOCHES COUNTY 12-97-00257-CR

1344-99 DAUGHERTY, SAMUEL MILTON DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-00332-CR

1345-99 DAUGHERTY, SAMUEL MILTON DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-00333-CR

1346-99 DAUGHERTY, SAMUEL MILTON DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-00334-CR

1347-99 DAUGHERTY, SAMUEL MILTON DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-00335-CR

1351-99 HARRIS, RONEALD EUGENE TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00361-CR

1357-99 HAWKINS, HARVEY EDWARD HARRIS COUNTY 11-97-00064-CR

1376-99 ANGENEY, RICHARD TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00383-CR

1377-99 ANGENEY, RICHARD TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00384-CR

1378-99 KNIGHT, ROY EDWARD JEFFERSON COUNTY 09-98-00135-CR

1379-99 STEWART, STANLEY JEFFERSON COUNTY 09-98-00362-CR

1381-99 JORDAN, CHRISTELLA MAE JEFFERSON COUNTY 09-98-00504-CR

1382-99 LOLLAR, MICHAEL CRAIG SMITH COUNTY 12-98-00123-CR

1383-99 BROWN, REGINALD D. SMITH COUNTY 12-97-00332-CR

1384-99 BROWN, DAVE DEWEY VAN ZANDT COUNTY 12-97-00425-CR

1390-99 LINDLEY, WILLIAM JOSEPH HARRIS COUNTY 10-98-00158-CR

1399-99 VASQUEZ, NORMA DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-01372-CR

1400-99 ESTEVANE, MARIA OTILIA DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-01373-CR

1401-99 SHERRAD, CHARLES LAWRENCE GRAYSON COUNTY 05-99-00188-CR

1422-99 CROSS, GREGORY DEAN TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00487-CR

1477-99 RHODES, PHILLIP CASS COUNTY 06-98-00234-CR

1590-99 HOWARD, ROBERT EARL SOMERVELL COUNTY 10-98-00356-CR

1591-99 MCCRAY, HAROLD DAMMON DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-01106-CR

1592-99 PARISH, CECIL LOUIS DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-01700-CR

1594-99 YOUNG, JOE PITTMAN TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00250-CR

1595-99 WELCH, BILLY RAY SAN AUGUSTINE COUNTY 12-98-00267-CR

APPELLEE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

1064-99 MERCADO, LUIS ROBERTO EL PASO COUNTY 08-96-00008-CR

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:

0665-99 HAROLD LEE MATZ TARRANT COUNTY 02-97-00613-CR

(GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 2 ONLY)

(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

1199-99 RUDOLPH MENDIOLA BEXAR COUNTY 04-97-00813-CR

(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

1353-99 SAMUEL LOVERT JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY 14-95-00860-CR

(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)





STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:

0412-99 PHILLIP GEORGE O'HARA (SPA'S) JIM WELLS COUNTY 04-98-00342-CR

(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

0761-99 WILLIAM TRAVIS LIGHT WILLIAMSON COUNTY 03-98-0043-CR

(GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 2 ONLY)

(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

1010-99 ERIC LENARD SMITH HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00371-CR

(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

10,635-06 LORENZO HALL DALLAS COUNTY

10,899-09 MICHAEL ANGELO JEFFERSON EL PASO COUNTY

10,899-10 MICHAEL ANGELO JEFFERSON EL PASO COUNTY

31,523-02 EARLANDO WILLIAMS DALLAS COUNTY

35,344-04 ART LEE WISE COUNTY

35,587-02 DARRYL GLENN WALLACE TARRANT COUNTY

42,291-02 JOHN MARSHALL TARRANT COUNTY

42,752-01 JIMMIE T. TAYLOR HARRISON COUNTY

42,870-01 JOHNNY EDWARD VALDERAS PARKER COUNTY

42,872-02 DAVID NORMAN SYLVA EL PASO COUNTY

42,932-01 JIMMY PAUL ATCHLEY VICTORIA COUNTY

43,040-01 SHERMAN RAY JONES BASTROP COUNTY

43,078-01 REGINALD WATSON MADISON COUNTY

43,109-01 RICHARD TERRY FRUZIA DENTON COUNTY

43,114-01 HERBERT JUNIOR YOUNG SMITH COUNTY

43,139-01 MITCHELL NELSON ECTOR COUNTY

43,147-01 FRANCISCO GARCIA CALDWELL COUNTY

43,190-01 STEPHEN LEE BEVEL TARRANT COUNTY

43,201-01 ANDRE WEBB TRAVIS COUNTY

43,246-01 ANTONIO ASCENCIO LEE COUNTY

43,254-01 WARREN BERNARD LINCECUM LEE COUNTY

43,257-01 MICHAEL SOLOMON BEE COUNTY

43,259-01 MARK ANTHONY BARNETT TARRANT COUNTY

43,273-01 MARVIN SHIPMAN ATASCOSA COUNTY

43,276-01 JOHN BRYON DIMOND II COLLIN COUNTY

(JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

43,281-01 LARRY WYATT ANGELINA COUNTY

43,301-01 GARY NICHOLS GREGG COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)

12,342-11 TOMMY RAY STEWART BRAZOS COUNTY

18,294-03 JOHN LEE SHUTE HARRIS COUNTY

21,273-02 WARREN D. FRANSAW ANGELINA COUNTY

35,732-03 JOHN H. CLOUD DALLAS COUNTY

38,986-02 CORNELL HARRISON II WILLIAMSON COUNTY

(JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

39,159-02 ARTURO GALVAN TARRANT COUNTY

39,939-01 LAWRENCE WRIGHT JR. TRAVIS COUNTY

40,265-01 ROBERT JOSEPH SWAINSTON DENTON COUNTY

41,377-01 ELIZABETH ATCHISON HARRIS COUNTY

41,377-02 ELIZABETH ATCHISON HARRIS COUNTY

42,582-01 RICKY ROMON JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY

42,593-01 ANDREW LITTLE HENDERSON COUNTY

42,670-01 MICHAEL MILLER TARRANT COUNTY

42,710-01 TYRONE POWELL MCFARLIN HARRIS COUNTY

42,717-01 PEDRO SANCHEZ-AVILES NAVARRO COUNTY

42,743-01 FARRON DEWAYNE DAVIS HOPKINS COUNTY

42,744-01 DERRICK SHAW TARRANT COUNTY

42,819-01 RONDELL JONES BELL COUNTY

42,824-01 RICKY STRIBLING DALLAS COUNTY

42,836-02 THOMAS M. NORVELL EL PASO COUNTY

42,845-01 LONNIE ALVIN EDWARDS HARRIS COUNTY

42,857-01 EUFEMIO SANCHEZ JR. WILLIAMSON COUNTY

(JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

42,903-01 DANIEL RANDOLPH JR. MIDLAND COUNTY

42,979-01 LEROY ECBY HARRIS COUNTY

43,000-01 ATHONY EUGENE MCINTRYE DALLAS COUNTY

43,026-01 DEVON HENRY BELL COUNTY

43,033-01 MARION LEE PITTMAN BEXAR COUNTY

43,033-02 MARION LEE PITTMAN BEXAR COUNTY

43,033-03 MARION LEE PITTMAN BEXAR COUNTY

43,037-01 FRANZ SUAZO HARRIS COUNTY

43,055-01 RICKY RAMSEY HARRIS COUNTY

43,055-02 RICKY RAMSEY HARRIS COUNTY

43,086-01 ALFRED DARRON LUCAS DALLAS COUNTY

43,105-01 HENRY BUI DALLAS COUNTY

43,154-01 MARCO ANTONIO LOPEZ WILLIAMSON COUNTY

(JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

43,164-01 JOSE GARCIA VENEGAS LUBBOCK COUNTY

43,170-01 JOSEPH HUMPHREY WILLIAMSON COUNTY

(JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

43,207-01 MICHAEL DON MOORE ERATH COUNTY

43,210-01 MARK G. BERRYHILL OLDHAM COUNTY

43,219-01 JAMES RICHARD GAYFORD DALLAS COUNTY

43,220-01 ALLEN C. GOODLOW BEXAR COUNTY

43,220-02 ALLEN C. GOODLOW BEXAR COUNTY

43,223-01 WILLIE FRANK MARSHALL JOHNSON COUNTY

43,299-01 JAVIER GAITAN BEXAR COUNTY

43,299-02 JAVIER GAITAN BEXAR COUNTY

43,299-03 JAVIER GAITAN BEXAR COUNTY



APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

43,005-01 CHRISTOPHER CANTU BELL COUNTY

43,147-02 FRANCISCO GARCIA CALDWELL COUNTY

43,229-01 ADAM SLEDGE BEXAR COUNTY

43,229-02 ADAM SLEDGE BEXAR COUNTY

43,229-03 ADAM SLEDGE BEXAR COUNTY

43,254-02 WARREN BERNARD LINCECUM LEE COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)

15,835-02 JOE LEE MACKEY LUBBOCK COUNTY

15,835-03 JOE LEE MACKEY LUBBOCK COUNTY

15,835-04 JOE LEE MACKEY LUBBOCK COUNTY

15,835-05 JOE LEE MACKEY LUBBOCK COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)

15,993-04 CARLOS LAVERNIA TRAVIS COUNTY

25,869-27 RONALD DEWAYNE WHITFIELD HARRIS COUNTY

25,869-28 RONALD DEWAYNE WHITFIELD HARRIS COUNTY

33,669-03 NEHEMIAH STEELE, JR. SMITH COUNTY

40,891-03 BRUCE SCOTT GARRETT TARRANT COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:

38,233-03 WADE BARRET DRISKILL STEPHENS COUNTY

41,112-01 WAYLAND RENARD GRANT DALLAS COUNTY

42,814-01 JOHNNY RAY GOODEN ROCKWALL COUNTY

42,892-01 MICHAEL WADE AKIN TARRANT COUNTY

42,899-01 LAWRENCE R. KIRKMAN JEFFERSON COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:

11,381-02 GILBERT FLORES ARGUMANIZ DALLAS COUNTY

40,953-02 RICKY STROBLE ARCHER COUNTY

42,489-01 JOSHUA FINCHER TAYLOR COUNTY

42,676-01 HARVEY ROLLINS DALLAS COUNTY

42,765-01 TODD WAYNE PIERRE JEFFERSON COUNTY

42,836-03 THOMAS NORVELL EL PASO COUNTY

42,944-01 WILLIAM JOSEPH NOBLES HARRIS COUNTY







MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT

WRITTEN ORDER:

18,018-09 SHANE MCCLAIN CAIN COUNTY

29,049-05 TIMOTHY LEE HUTTASH CHEROKEE COUNTY

30,743-02 RICKY LEE BROWN DALLAS COUNTY

32,671-03 TROY BRIDGES DALLAS COUNTY

33,222-09 MICHAEL LEE WILSON DENTON COUNTY

35,732-04 JOHN H. CLOUD COUNTY

37,615-03 GILBERTO MELCHOR RUIZ BEXAR COUNTY

37,640-03 WILLIE GENE EDWARDS NUECES COUNTY

42,872-01 DAVID NORMAN SYLVA EL PASO COUNTY

43,185-01 PATRICK A. SMOTHERS DALLAS COUNTY

43,200-01 DERRICK LAMAR SAM HARRIS COUNTY

43,212-01 ARTHUR ROY FREEMAN HARRIS COUNTY

43,257-01 MICHAEL SOLOMON BEE COUNTY

42,836-01 THOMAS M. NORVELL EL PASO COUNTY

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

24,976-02 ALLEN WAYNE JANECKA HARRIS COUNTY

41,743-01 HUMBERTO LEAL JR. BEXAR COUNTY

42,831-01 REX WARREN MAYS HARRIS COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE:

32,311-03 STEVEN WASHINGTON TRAVIS COUNTY