THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS





OCTOBER 9, 2002









THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:


73,455         JERMAINE HERRON FROM REFUGIO COUNTY

                    AFFIRMED-OPINION JUDGE HOLCOMB

                    DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

                    (JUDGE JOHNSON JOINED)

                    PUBLISHED OPINION



HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)

 

74,449         EX PARTE JULIAN HERNANDEZ FROM GUADALUPE COUNTY

74,450         EX PARTE CHARLES WILLIAM THOMASON FROM EL PASO COUNTY



ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:


0471-00         DANIEL RAHIM SEXTON BEXAR COUNTY 04-98-00598-CR

                       JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

                       CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS-OPINION JUDGE PRICE

                       (JUDGES WOMACK AND KEASLER CONCURRED)

                       (JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)

                       PUBLISHED OPINION



0827-01         CLYDE T. HUTCHINSON, JR. HARRISON COUNTY 06-00-00044-CR

                       JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED-OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

                       (PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER AND JUDGE HERVEY CONCURRED IN THE RESULT0

                       PUBLISHED OPINION





1079-01         KNOWEL BEEMAN, JR. MIDLAND COUNTY 08-00-00390-CR

                       JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED-OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

                       (JUDGE PRICE CONCURRED IN THE RESULT)

                       CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

                       DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

                       PUBLISHED OPINION



1220-01         EX PARTE BRENDA SUE BAILEY HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01179-CR

                       JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED-OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

                       (JUDGES WOMACK AND COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)

                       DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

                       (JUDGE JOHNSON JOINED)

                       PUBLISHED OPINION



1221-01         EX PARTE JOHN BABIN HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01180-CR

                       JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED-OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

                       (JUDGES WOMACK AND COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)

                       DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

                       (JUDGE JOHNSON JOINED)

                       PUBLISHED OPINION



1222-01         EX PARTE JAMES SCHNUR HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01181-CR

                       JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED-OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

                       (JUDGES WOMACK AND COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)

                       DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

                       (JUDGE JOHNSON JOINED)

                       PUBLISHED OPINION



1223-01         EX PARTE RALPH SCHNUR HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01182-CR

                       JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED-OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

                       (JUDGES WOMACK AND COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)

                       DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

                       (JUDGE JOHNSON JOINED)

                       PUBLISHED OPINION



1224-01         EX PARTE CHARLES COLEMAN HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01183-CR

                       JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED-OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

                       (JUDGES WOMACK AND COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)

                       DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

                       (JUDGE JOHNSON JOINED)

                       PUBLISHED OPINION



1225-01         JOHN BABIN HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01381-CR

                       DISMISSED-OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

                       (JUDGES WOMACK AND COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)

                       DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

                       (JUDGE JOHNSON JOINED)

                       PUBLISHED OPINION



1226-01         CHARLES FRANCIS COLEMAN HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01382-CR

                       DISMISSED-OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

                       (JUDGES WOMACK AND COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)

                       DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

                       (JUDGE JOHNSON JOINED)

                       PUBLISHED OPINION



1227-01         RALPH SCHNUR HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01383-CR

                       DISMISSED-OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

                       (JUDGES WOMACK AND COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)

                       DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

                       (JUDGE JOHNSON JOINED)

                       PUBLISHED OPINION



1228-01         JAMES ARNOLD SCHNUR HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01384-CR

                       DISMISSED-OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

                       (JUDGES WOMACK AND COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)

                       DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

                       (JUDGE JOHNSON JOINED)

                       PUBLISHED OPINION



1229-01         BRENDA SUE BAILEY HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01385-CR

                       DISMISSED-OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

                       (JUDGES WOMACK AND COCHRAN NOT PARTICIPATING)

                       DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

                       (JUDGE JOHNSON JOINED)

                       PUBLISHED OPINION



ON STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:


0045-01         ALBERT SALAZAR NUECES COUNTY 13-99-00656-CR

                       JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

                       JUDGMENT OF TRIAL COURT AFFIRMED-OPINION JUDGE COCHRAN

                       (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

                       PUBLISHED OPINION

 

STATE'S MOTION FOR REHEARING ON STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DENIED:



0337-01         MARIE LISETTE GARCIA VEGA HIDALGO COUNTY 13-98-00044-CR

                       PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER AND JUDGE KEASLER WOULD GRANT)

 

 

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

 

0670-02         RICHARDSON, NEIL EDWARD HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-00483-CR

0914-02         CRENSHAW, ROBERT L. TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00482-CR

0918-02         WISHERT, EDWIN DOYLE BROWN COUNTY 11-01-00072-CR

0985-02         MUSGROVE, JAMES BEXAR COUNTY 04-01-00017-CR

                       (JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)

0992-02         JOHNSON, ROBERT GRIMES COUNTY 01-99-01414-CR

1033-02         PIZANA, RAFAEL MADISON COUNTY 10-00-00353-CR

1081-02         JARAMILLO, GUILLERMO EL PASO COUNTY 08-01-00168-CR

1152-02         TORRES, JOEL HIDALGO COUNTY 13-00-00473-CR

1334-02         JARAMILLO, ELISEO EL PASO COUNTY 08-00-00489-CR

1338-02         MORIN, EMELIO DAVID HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-00986-CR

1340-02         MCADAMS, CODY ALAN JASPER COUNTY 13-01-00245-CR

1344-02         PSENSIK, MARK STEPHEN TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00427-CR

1345-02         WHITLOCK, JOHN D. HARRIS COUNTY 04-01-00444-CR

1351-02         PHILLIPS, ROBBIE WAYNE DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01114-CR

1352-02         MUNGIA, RUBEN T. LUBBOCK COUNTY 07-99-00359-CR

1357-02         JONES, MICHAEL DAVID EL PASO COUNTY 08-01-00056-CR

1358-02         LOWE, ROBERT WILLIAM TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00252-CR

1360-02         WILLIAMS, DOUGLAS DEASEAN BEXAR COUNTY 04-00-00552-CR

1534-02         STONE, ALFRED T. LUBBOCK COUNTY 07-02-00273-CR

 

STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

 

0795-02         BREWER, JAMES DAVID DALLAS COUNTY 08-00-00424-CR

0796-02         BREWER, JAMES DAVID DALLAS COUNTY 08-00-00425-CR

 

APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:

 

1730-02         HICKSON, LARRY WAYNE TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00332-CR

1759-02         VAN, THETAUS ROBERT HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-01158-CR

1760-02         VAN, THETAUS ROBERT HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-01159-CR

 

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW ORDERED STRUCK FOR NON-COMPLIANCE WITH WRITTEN ORDER:



0910-02         CHAVEZ, SAMUEL ELLIS COUNTY 10-00-00241-CR

1427-02         GONZALEZ, MARIN SMITH COUNTY 12-01-00178-CR

1547-02         PADEN, JOSEPH MARTIN DALLAS COUNTY 08-99-00363-CR

1575-02         SIMS, GARY EUGENE DALLAS COUNTY 08-01-00121-CR

1603-02         RABADI, ROUBA WILLIAMSON COUNTY 03-02-00102-CR



PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER, JUDGES KEASLER AND HERVEY DISSENT TO ALL THE ABOVE ORDERS



APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:



2,385-02           PAT WAYNE GILLILAND TARRANT COUNTY

26,390-02         ROBERT N. ROUNSAVALL BRAZORIA COUNTY

27,037-03         STEVE DOUGLAS MCNEAL LUBBOCK COUNTY

28,145-03         MICHAEL ANTHONY MCGOWEN LIBERTY COUNTY

3,898-11           PAUL MARTINEZ DALLAS COUNTY

3,898-12           PAUL MARTINEZ DALLAS COUNTY

36,860-08         TERRY RENARD FISHER TRAVIS COUNTY

41,713-04         MICHAEL THOMAS FLORES EL PASO COUNTY

48,310-02         OMAR RAMIREZ EL PASO COUNTY

48,310-03         OMAR RAMIREZ EL PASO COUNTY

48,310-04         OMAR RAMIREZ EL PASO COUNTY

48,310-05         OMAR RAMIREZ EL PASO COUNTY

48,310-06         OMAR RAMIREZ EL PASO COUNTY

48,310-07         OMAR RAMIREZ EL PASO COUNTY

51,854-03         ROSS EDWARD MCCOY TARRANT COUNTY

51,854-04         ROSS EDWARD MCCOY TARRANT COUNTY

51,936-03         ROBERT JR. BATES JOHNSON COUNTY

52,806-02         ALVARO PRETEL GOMEZ HARRIS COUNTY

52,830-01         WILLIAM JERMAINE HIBLER DENTON COUNTY

53,180-01         KENNETH HENSON ANDERSON COUNTY

53,321-01         ERIC LYNN ROGERS ROCKWALL COUNTY

53,418-01         FRANK GLENN THOMAS HARRIS COUNTY

53,418-02         FRANK GLENN THOMAS HARRIS COUNTY

53,483-01         DERRICK DENSON TARRANT COUNTY

53,491-01         JASON FRANK WELLS COLLIN COUNTY

53,493-01         RUSSELL STEPHEN MUSSLEWHITE ORANGE COUNTY

53,501-01         JERRELL D. DAVIS COLORADO COUNTY

53,522-01         DONALD JACKSON MORRIS COUNTY

53,523-01         DAVID BRYAN DAVIS DALLAS COUNTY

53,525-01         DAVID WAYNE BROCKWAY LAMAR COUNTY

53,543-01         EARL MILTON PAYTON VICTORIA COUNTY

53,556-01         BOBBY RAY FORD VICTORIA COUNTY

53,566-01         COLONEL LEE TRADER EL PASO COUNTY

53,585-01         CRUZ HERNANDEZ MAVERICK COUNTY

53,633-01         JOHN EDWARD PAUL TARRANT COUNTY

53,640-01         THOMAS MELVIN PETERSON GRAY COUNTY

53,645-01         LEON WILBURN JR. TARRANT COUNTY

53,645-02         LEON WILBURN JR. TARRANT COUNTY

53,652-01         TIMETEO H. HERRERA JR BEXAR COUNTY

53,654-01         RONALD HARDING TARRANT COUNTY

53,655-01         ALEXIS RASHAAD FAVORS TARRANT COUNTY

53,661-01         ROBERT LOUIS ANGORA TARRANT COUNTY

53,661-02         ROBERT LOUIS ANGORA TARRANT COUNTY

53,672-01         JESSE SCOTT DAVIS GREGG COUNTY

53,697-01         PHILLIP JR. FALCON NEWTON COUNTY

53,725-01         PHILLIP EARL POTTS DALLAS COUNTY

53,740-01         TORIBIO GONZALEZ JR. HARRIS COUNTY

53,752-01         DAVID GONZALES ORTIZ COMAL COUNTY

53,754-01         KENNETH LEE MAYER HARDEMAN COUNTY

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)

 

20,358-03         RAY GLOVER BOWIE COUNTY

39,216-02         BILLY EDWARD JR. TEMPLE HARRIS COUNTY

39,224-02         RICHARD DANIEL GILBERT HARRIS COUNTY

45,956-03         JOE LAWRENCE HOWELL JR. MIDLAND COUNTY

49,574-02         MICHAEL ALLEN BITER DALLAS COUNTY

49,574-03         MICHAEL ALLEN BITER DALLAS COUNTY

51,936-02         ROBERT JR. BATES JOHNSON COUNTY

52,012-03         MILTON ALEXANDER THOMAS SR. EL PASO COUNTY

52,061-03         DANNY RAY GUTTERY TARRANT COUNTY

52,175-02         JOE HECTOR GUTIERREZ HARRIS COUNTY

52,730-01         EDWARD MCCLELLAN TARRANT COUNTY

52,769-01         PAUL MARTON SHEPHERD HOOD COUNTY

52,993-02         LAWRENCE GENE PAGE DALLAS COUNTY

52,996-02         JAVIER FELIX HARRIS COUNTY

52,996-03         JAVIER FELIX HARRIS COUNTY

52,997-01         LEE ANDREW FOSTER BELL COUNTY

53,322-02         LAWYER HENRY JR. ANGELINA COUNTY

53,478-01         TEMISOCLES CONRAD CORTES HARRIS COUNTY

53,481-01         TORIN ALEXANDER TARRANT COUNTY

53,562-01         BOBBY SHOFNER DALLAS COUNTY

53,564-01         LAWRENCE GENE QUINTON MCLENNAN COUNTY

53,564-02         LAWRENCE GENE QUINTON MCLENNAN COUNTY

53,566-02         COLONEL LEE TRADER EL PASO COUNTY

53,566-03         COLONEL LEE TRADER EL PASO COUNTY

53,572-01         DANIEL GARZA DALLAS COUNTY

53,619-01         LEROY JONES TRAVIS COUNTY

53,625-01         AUBREY LEE BRENT FORT BEND COUNTY

53,636-01         JAMES DUANE NEWSOM GRAYSON COUNTY

53,636-02         JAMES DUANE NEWSOM GRAYSON COUNTY

53,659-01         BRANDON EUGENE COX DALLAS COUNTY

53,659-02         BRANDON EUGENE COX DALLAS COUNTY

53,659-03         BRANDON EUGENE COX DALLAS COUNTY

53,659-04         BRANDON EUGENE COX DALLAS COUNTY

53,669-01         TAUREAN JAMAAL ROBINSON HARRIS COUNTY

53,669-02         TAUREAN JAMAAL ROBINSON HARRIS COUNTY

53,692-01         DELIVENCE ANDRE SIMS HARRIS COUNTY

53,699-01         ERIC JEROME JOHNSON DALLAS COUNTY

53,708-01         SONNY PEREZ HARRIS COUNTY

53,709-01         RICKY JR. MCZEAL HARRIS COUNTY

53,711-01         WAYNE DEAN WHITNEY BRAZORIA COUNTY

53,733-02         KEITH LEANELL BROWN DALLAS COUNTY

53,745-01         BENNY ODEM JR. BEXAR COUNTY

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

 

26,965-04         JOE EMILIO DELGADO TRAVIS COUNTY

26,965-05         JOE EMILIO DELGADO TRAVIS COUNTY

35,917-02         DON HOLST BEXAR COUNTY

35,917-03         DON HOLST BEXAR COUNTY

35,917-04         DON HOLST BEXAR COUNTY

35,917-05         DON HOLST BEXAR COUNTY

35,917-06         DON HOLST BEXAR COUNTY

48,174-01         DAMON SHAUN ANDERSON HARRIS COUNTY

48,174-02         DAMON SHAUN ANDERSON HARRIS COUNTY

52,691-01         JOE CURTIS O'CAIN EL PASO COUNTY

53,363-01         JAMES BUFORD BRADBERY DALLAS COUNTY

53,429-01         RODNEY K. THOMAS TARRANT COUNTY

53,484-01         MARK ANTHONY CUMMINGS NUECES COUNTY

53,524-01         DARREN RAY BURKE FORT BEND COUNTY

53,642-01         MICHAEL PATTERSON DALLAS COUNTY

53,642-02         MICHAEL PATTERSON DALLAS COUNTY

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)

 

53,421-01          JUAN LOPEZ HARRIS COUNTY

53,599-01         SHANNON S. LEWELLYN DALLAS COUNTY

53,721-01         OLIVER JAMAUL CRUISE HARRIS COUNTY

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)

 

19,721-14         CALVIN RAY HYDER DALLAS COUNTY

22,589-04         WILLIAM SPANG TRAVIS COUNTY

28,764-04         HARRY LEROY JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY

30,187-11         DONALD PENCE PRUITT DALLAS COUNTY

33,766-03         JAKE ARNOLD ALLEN HARRIS COUNTY

34,056-03         MARVIN GAY PAGE DALLAS COUNTY

41,363-05         DONALD PAYNE EDWARDS STEPHENS COUNTY

7,213-13         DAVID WAYNE SHEPPARD MIDLAND COUNTY

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER

(TEX. GOV'T CODE SEC. 501.0081 (b) )

 

51,529-02         WILLIE RAY SINGLETARY HARRIS COUNTY

53,533-01         GERALD KETTELKAMP TARRANT COUNTY

53,573-01         EVARISTO GAYTAN EL PASO COUNTY

53,623-01         JERROLD STEPHEN BRUCH WILLIAMSON COUNTY

53,627-01         WAYNE LEE BELCHER MIDLAND COUNTY

53,706-01         TIMOTHY DELEON LAWS HARRIS COUNTY

53,733-01         KEITH LEANELL BROWN DALLAS COUNTY

 

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE

AND RESPONDENT IS ORDERED TO FILE ANSWER:

 

34,426-04         STEVEN RANDALL BROWN VICTORIA COUNTY

46,577-02         JOSEPH JOE HANDY HARRIS COUNTY

50,189-01         LARRY DOUGLAS DALLAS COUNTY

                         (PRIOR ORDER WITHDRAWN)

53,662-01         MARCUS JAMES DYKSTRA HARRIS COUNTY

53,664-01         ALBERTO GONZALEZ CASTELAN HIDALGO COUNTY

53,702-01         TOMMY RICHARD HARRIS BEXAR COUNTY

53,710-01         LEONARD NOBLES TRAVIS COUNTY

 

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT

WRITTEN ORDER:

 

25,869-52         RONALD DWAYNE WHITFIELD HARRIS COUNTY

28,764-03         HARRY LEROY JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY

39,601-02         COURTNEY EARL CRUMBY DALLAS COUNTY

41,363-04         DONALD PAYNE EDWARDS STEPHENS COUNTY

43,919-08         DONALD R. BURR TARRANT COUNTY

50,739-02         ALFIE KAREEM MCCRIGHT DALLAS COUNTY

51,469-02         ERIC THOMPSON HARRIS COUNTY

51,529-01         WILLIE RAY SINGLETARY HARRIS COUNTY

52,012-02         MILTON ALEXANDER THOMAS SR. EL PASO COUNTY

52,806-01         ALVARO PRETEL GOMEZ HARRIS COUNTY

52,993-03         LAWRENCE GENE PAGE DALLAS COUNTY

53,292-01         MARK ANTHONY REYNA HARRIS COUNTY

53,490-01         CARL WILLIAMS BEXAR COUNTY

53,492-01         MICHAEL W. WASHINGTON HARRIS COUNTY

53,591-01         ROBERT HOLINESS DALLAS COUNTY

53,712-01         LACEY BARBER TARRANT COUNTY

53,756-01         DWAYNE CORONA BEXAR COUNTY

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:

 

23,704-04         LUCIAN LEE SPANN, JR. DALLAS COUNTY

52,684-01         MARK ADRIAN GLASGOW DALLAS COUNTY

53,571-01         EMZY LORENZO MILLER TRAVIS COUNTY

53,571-02         EMZY LORENZO MILLER TRAVIS COUNTY

53,571-03         EMZY LORENZO MILLER TRAVIS COUNTY

53,621-01         GEORGE L. HARTLEY TARRANT COUNTY

 

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

 

52,801-01         GILBERTO GUADALUPE REYES BAILEY COUNTY

53,499-01         LARRY EDGAR ESTRADA HARRIS COUNTY

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:

 

46,618-01         CHARLES WILLIAM THOMASON EL PASO COUNTY

52,918-01         JULIAN HERNANDEZ GUADALUPE COUNTY







MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE ORIGINAL APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:



52,240-02         PERCY WAYNE FROMAN SMITH COUNTY



APPLICATION FOR WRITS OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN OPINION AFTER HEARING:



51,597-02         WILLIAM WELDON JONES GALVESTON COUNTY

53,476-01         MICKEY LYNN LITTLE SMITH COUNTY