THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS



MAY 2, 2001



THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:





73,939         EX PARTE VICTOR MANUEL LOZADA-MENDOZA FROM JACKSON COUNTY

                    RELIEF DENIED--OPINION JUDGE PRICE

                    (JUDGE HOLCOMB DISSENTED)

                     PUBLISHED OPINION

 

HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)



74,076         EX PARTE VICENTE MUNOZ FROM EL PASO COUNTY

74,083         EX PARTE MICHAEL KEITH DOUGLAS FROM BEXAR COUNTY

74,084         EX PARTE ANTHONY L. MILLER FROM HARRIS COUNTY

74,086         EX PARTE TONY BURTEL GARRETT FROM MILAM COUNTY

74,087         EX PARTE SHU GUO KAN FROM BEXAR COUNTY



ON STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:



0085-00         MORRIS LOUIS LOFTON FROM BELL COUNTY

                       JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

                       JUDGMENT OF TRIAL COURT AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE HOLLAND

                       DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

                       PUBLISHED OPINION



STATE'S MOTION FOR REHEARING ON APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DENIED:



1254-99         BENJAMIN LEON BLUE HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-00771-CR

                       (PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER, JUDGES KEASLER & HERVEY WOULD GRANT)



APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:



0123-01         ALAN GLENN WHITE TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00400-CR

                       (GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 1 ONLY)

                       (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)1



STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:



2055-00         HERBERT HUBERT COOPER JEFFERSON COUNTY 09-00-00046-CR

                       (ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

 

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:



1916-00         GIBSON, MILLARD LEWIS COLLIN COUNTY 05-99-01309-CR

                       (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

2135-00         SIMPSON, ARTHUR LEE CHAMBERS COUNTY 14-99-00248-CR

0001-01         ESPINOSA, PATRICK ISAAC HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00464-CR

                       (JUDGE HOLCOMB WOULD GRANT)

0226-01         SPENCER, LISA ANN HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00969-CR

0227-01         SALAZAR, RUDY BRAZORIA COUNTY 14-99-00831-CR

0252-01         MORRISON, SHUREE PATRICE HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00111-CR

0254-01         VILLAREAL, MANUEL DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-00833-CR

0274-01         DOUBRAVA, SUZANNE KAY HARRIS COUNTY 11-95-00240-CR

                       (PDR NO. 1)

0276-01         PRICE, GARY LEE TARRANT COUNTY 10-99-00181-CR

0277-01         EVELAND, ZACHARY EDWIN HARRIS COUNTY 11-00-00098-CR

0278-01         HOOD, DOUGLAS WAYNE BROWN COUNTY 11-99-00154-CR

0280-01         THOMALS, CHARLES HORNELL DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-01820-CR

0282-01         SWEENEY, WAYNE JOSEPH DALLAS COUNTY 05-99-00860-CR

0285-01         MOORE, STACY TYRONE HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-01077-CR

0289-01         GUERRERO, RUBEN TRAVIS COUNTY 03-99-00759-CR

0306-01         ROBINSON, TERRELL LOUIS HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00340-CR

0307-01         DORSEY, ERIC J. HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-01121-CR

0311-01         O'BRYANT, TROY HARRIS COUNTY 12-99-00351-CR

0313-01         LEBRON, CRISTOBAL NELSON HARRIS COUNTY 06-00-00208-CR

0316-01         ST. CLERGY, MICHAEL CORY ORANGE COUNTY 06-00-00012-CR

0321-01         EDWARDS, JASON TREMAINE JEFFERSON COUNTY 06-00-00140-CR

0322-01         EDWARDS, JASON TREMAINE JEFFERSON COUNTY 06-00-00141-CR

0323-01         VARGAS, MARIANO OROZCO HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-01127-CR

0326-01         BEARDEN, ALFIE ALBERT GREGG COUNTY 06-00-00045-CR

0327-01         BEARDEN, ALFIE ALBERT GREGG COUNTY 06-00-00112-CR

0328-01         PEREZ, JULIO, JR. HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00132-CR

0330-01         ARCENEAUX, LARRY MICHAEL LIBERTY COUNTY 06-00-00127-CR

0333-01         SATTERWHITE, WILLIAM E., JR. HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-00955-CR

0343-01         ANGUIANO, ANTONIO WICHITA COUNTY 02-00-00052-CR

0346-01         GIRDLEY, ROBERT FRED, III DENTON COUNTY 02-98-00090-CR

0349-01         SMITH, GLENN FLOYD GALVESTON COUNTY 14-98-01106-CR

0350-01         SMITH, GLENN FLOYD GALVESTON COUNTY 14-98-01107-CR

0351-01         SMITH, GLENN FLOYD GALVESTON COUNTY 14-98-01108-CR

0352-01         SMITH, GLENN FLOYD GALVESTON COUNTY 14-98-01109-CR

0353-01         JETTER, SHAWN TALBERT EL PASO COUNTY 08-98-00307-CR

0355-01         SUAREZ, EFRAIN, JR. ECTOR COUNTY 08-97-00388-CR

0356-01         SEDA, CAROL ANN TARRANT COUNTY 02-99-00565-CR

0357-01         GREEN, KWASI ANTOINNE BEE COUNTY 13-00-00237-CR

0362-01         GASKIN, KIRT LEE HARRIS COUNTY 11-00-00027-CR

0363-01         GASKIN, KIRT LEE HARRIS COUNTY 11-00-00028-CR

0364-01         BROWN, JOHNNY CURTIS BEXAR COUNTY 04-99-00434-CR

                       (JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)

0366-01         SPARKMAN, GUY E. SMITH COUNTY 04-00-00727-CR

0368-01         GONZALEZ, MIGUEL ANGEL EL PASO COUNTY 08-98-00178-CR

0369-01         SEWELL, ROBERT CARROLL HOPKINS COUNTY 12-99-00184-CR

0370-01         THOMAS, ROBERT ANNAMMA CAMERON COUNTY 13-99-00567-CR

0371-01         GODDARD, RICHARD LEE ARANSAS COUNTY 13-99-00698-CR

0424-01         MORALES, OVED ALEJANDRO TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00053-CR

0425-01         MORALES, OVED ALEJANDRO TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00054-CR

0426-01         MORALES, OVED ALEJANDRO TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00055-CR

0450-01         MITCHELL, ROYCE, JR. HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01277-CR

0455-01         COOK, FERDINAND, JR. DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01199-CR

0456-01         REXROAD, JASON PATRICK COLLIN COUNTY 05-99-01991-CR

                       (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

0457-01         REXROAD, JASON PATRICK COLLIN COUNTY 05-99-02004-CR

                       (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

0459-01         CELESTINE, PAUL DOUGLAS HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00636-CR

0472-01         FLORES, ARTHUR M. BEXAR COUNTY 04-00-00156-CR

                       (JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)

0549-01         PENA, ALEXANDER TARRANT COUNTY 02-99-00449-CR

0550-01         PENA, ALEXANDER TARRANT COUNTY 02-99-00450-CR

 

 

STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

 

 

0274-01         DOUBRAVA, SUZANNE KAY HARRIS COUNTY 11-95-00240-CR

                       (PDR NO. 2)

0329-01          MCGEE, ELROY JAMES HARRIS COUNTY 06-99-00095-CR



APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DISMISSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:



0675-01         DAVID, ROBERT H. HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00666-CR



APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:



27,836-16         GEORGE W. RIECK JR. VICTORIA COUNTY

28,144-03         KELVIN DEWAYNE JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY

29,349-03         RODNEY LEE MCDOWELL HARRIS COUNTY

31,641-02         KENNETH LEE HASKELL COUNTY

34,608-02         CHARLES LARRY HUNNICUTT DALLAS COUNTY

37,128-02         JOHNATHAN WILLIAM DAY HOOD COUNTY

40,256-05         JAMES ERIC LOFTON JEFFERSON COUNTY

44,899-02         KHAI QUANG TRAN TRUONG TARRANT COUNTY

45,600-03         ROBERT LEE CURRY MCLENNAN COUNTY

48,419-01         PATRICK D. GAY DALLAS COUNTY

48,589-01         WILLIAM JAMES JACKSON HARRIS COUNTY

48,864-01         MARCUS BERNARD THOMPSON HARRIS COUNTY

48,937-01         CHARLES VAN MERCER IV DALLAS COUNTY

48,950-01         JUAN MIGUEL MARTINEZ GUADALUPE COUNTY

48,950-02         JUAN MIGUEL MARTINEZ GUADALUPE COUNTY

48,965-01         CARLOS RODRIGUEZ EL PASO COUNTY

48,986-01         JUAN BATISTA DEPENA HARRIS COUNTY

48,987-01         JESUS GALINDO EL PASO COUNTY

48,994-01         REYNALDO SANCHEZ ATASCOSA COUNTY

49,071-01         LEE-AUDREY LAMON GORDON GREGG COUNTY

49,107-01         GLEN DOUGLAS DAVIS DENTON COUNTY

49,111-01         COREY HOOD DALLAS COUNTY

49,117-01         JOSE ANTONIO OLIVAS JR. ANDREWS COUNTY

49,119-01         CHEDRICH HOWARD MILAM COUNTY

49,148-01         MICHAEL WAYNE ELLISON NOLAN COUNTY

49,160-01         BUCK MATTHEW JOHNSON UPSHUR COUNTY

49,189-01         CALVIN WRIGHT TARRANT COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)

 

18,696-03         PAUL RENE MCCLOUD HARRIS COUNTY

18,696-04         PAUL RENE MCCLOUD HARRIS COUNTY

28,908-02         CLEVELAND SNEED DALLAS COUNTY

30,977-14         JOHN FORWARD JEFFERSON COUNTY

32,399-03         JESSE LEE CAMPBELL DALLAS COUNTY

32,612-05         MOHAMMED MALEKZADEH HARRIS COUNTY

33,565-02         DWIGHT ODELL SHAW TRAVIS COUNTY

36,242-02         JOHN NAASZ DALLAS COUNTY

39,482-02         JAIME RIOS BEXAR COUNTY

44,013-01         JONATHAN DEWAYNE CAIN DENTON COUNTY

45,533-01         MARIO ABEL SALAZAR CAMERON COUNTY

45,611-02         MARIO GILBERTO CORTEZ DALLAS COUNTY

45,751-02         JOHNNY RAY LOVINGS HARRIS COUNTY

46,729-04         ROBERT PAUL CRESON DALLAS COUNTY

46,990-02         MICHAEL SHANE MCBRIDE LIBERTY COUNTY

47,651-01         BRODERICK SMITH DALLAS COUNTY

47,744-01         TYTON TERKEL HESTER FANNIN COUNTY

48,527-01         LAURY D. RIPPER HARRIS COUNTY

48,527-02         LAURY D. RIPPER HARRIS COUNTY

48,544-01         ABDEL MOHAMED RAHIM DALLAS COUNTY

48,774-06         MICHAEL BUTLER HARRIS COUNTY

48,961-01         CURTIS WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY

48,961-02         CURTIS WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY

48,980-01         JOSHUA HACKNEY TRINITY COUNTY

49,007-01         CLINTON SORRELL BEXAR COUNTY

49,020-02         ARNULFO CORTEZ JR. DAWSON COUNTY

49,021-01         RONNIE R. MIMS DALLAS COUNTY

49,053-01         MANUEL VELA MIDLAND COUNTY

49,060-01         JOHN SALAS ELLIS COUNTY

49,060-02         JOHN SALAS ELLIS COUNTY

49,061-01         ANTHONY JAMES RICHARD HARRIS COUNTY

49,066-01         JOSE ANTONIO LOPEZ CASTILLO HIDALGO COUNTY

49,094-01         ROBERT SPENCER BUCKLER JR. DALLAS COUNTY

49,095-01         TROY LYNN BISHOP DALLAS COUNTY

49,096-01         JERRY RAY SMITH DALLAS COUNTY

49,100-01         DEROYAL D. TALLEY DALLAS COUNTY

49,102-01         MICHAEL EDWARDS DALLAS COUNTY

49,121-01         ROBERTO GOMEZ JR. NUECES COUNTY

49,138-01         LARRY WAYNE HICKS LAMAR COUNTY

49,140-01         MARVIN LYNN HIGGINBOTHAM NACOGDOCHES COUNTY

49,156-01         JAVIER RIASCOS HARRIS COUNTY

49,172-01         JERRY JEROME GIBSON JR. HARRIS COUNTY

49,178-01         BOBBY GENE LEWIS DALLAS COUNTY

49,180-01         HOWARD WAYNE LEE TARRANT COUNTY

8,718-03           BILLY RAY GRANT ORANGE COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

 

 

48,662-01         MICHAEL GLEN GARZA ROCKWALL COUNTY

48,771-01         EDUARDO RUEDA EL PASO COUNTY

48,771-02         EDUARDO RUEDA EL PASO COUNTY

48,771-05         EDUARDO RUEDA EL PASO COUNTY

48,967-01         EDWARD VIDAL PEREZ DALLAS COUNTY

48,973-01         JAIME FERNANDEZ FLORES EL PASO COUNTY

48,974-01         ARMANDO VASQUEZ EL PASO COUNTY

49,020-01         ARNULFO CORTEZ JR. DAWSON COUNTY

49,109-01         JOE A. JEFFERY DALLAS COUNTY

49,147-01         JESUS HERNANDEZ EL PASO COUNTY

49,154-01         JESUS HOMERO OCHOA EL PASO COUNTY

49,184-01         JUAN HERNANDEZ EL PASO COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)

 

 

39,655-05         MICHAEL KEITH DOUGLAS BEXAR COUNTY

48,966-01         DEREK LAVERN PERRY HARRIS COUNTY

49,120-01         OSVALDO ALVAREZ JEFFERSON COUNTY

49,161-01         CARLOS CASTANEDA EL PASO COUNTY

49,188-01         HEATHER DAWN MCGARY ECTOR COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)

 

 

18,022-05         JESUS MENDEZ JR. BEE COUNTY

19,493-06         JOHN WESLEY WEBBER HARRIS COUNTY

23,953-11         MARTIN FRANCO JR. LLANO COUNTY

24,583-09         FRANK DWIGHT CARTER LUBBOCK COUNTY

25,869-42         RONALD DWAYNE WHITFIELD HARRIS COUNTY

27,527-02         CHRISTOPHER JERMAINE ALFORD DALLAS COUNTY

31,381-02         FREDERICK E. PITTMAN BRAZOS COUNTY

33,041-02         RICCARDO L. BROWN TARRANT COUNTY

39,892-02         CHARLES TERRY TIDWELL CAMERON COUNTY

39,892-03         CHARLES TERRY TIDWELL CAMERON COUNTY

42,747-02         BILLY REESE FISHER DALLAS COUNTY

43,447-03         GEORGE MONTGOMERY III DALLAS COUNTY

45,047-02         ALVIN RAY COOPER DALLAS COUNTY

7,243-16            JOHNNY AL HUNTER DENTON COUNTY

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER

(TEX. GOV'T CODE SEC. 501.0081 (b) )

 

 

37,430-03         CHARLES E. FLORES TARRANT COUNTY

48,989-01         RUBEN BUENO NUECES COUNTY

49,024-01         KEVIN O. FAULK LUBBOCK COUNTY

49,054-01         RODNEY CHARLES SWAN HARRIS COUNTY

49,084-01         JOHN DANIEL MCILVAIN MONTGOMERY COUNTY

49,088-01         NATHANIEL JONES JR. JEFFERSON COUNTY

49,088-02         NATHANIEL JONES JR. JEFFERSON COUNTY

49,124-01         JAMES DEE BENEFIELD HOOD COUNTY

49,181-01         LONNIE D. BURTS ECTOR COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:

 

 

36,384-02         LAWRENCE PERNEL HEARLD HARRIS COUNTY

48,120-02         BRIAN L. JOHNSON FRANKLIN COUNTY

48,771-03         EDUARDO RUEDA EL PASO COUNTY

48,771-04         EDUARDO RUEDA EL PASO COUNTY

48,788-01         GABRIEL AGUILAR HARRIS COUNTY

48,894-01         PAUL LAWRENCE GRELEN BRAZOS COUNTY

49,074-01         ROBERT J. STEWART TARRANT COUNTY

 

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

 

 

36,466-02         JUSTIN CHAZ FULLER SMITH COUNTY

 

 

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE

AND RESPONDENT IS ORDERED TO FILE ANSWER:

 

 

11,228-08         CARL ULYSSES MCAFEE HARRIS COUNTY

42,412-02         MICHAEL E. SMITH HARRIS COUNTY

45,281-02         RANDY LEE EL PASO COUNTY

48,981-01         LARRY PAUL MACY HARRIS COUNTY

49,183-01         FRANCISCO GAONA HIDALGO COUNTY

 

 

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT

WRITTEN ORDER:

 

23,091-22         KURBY GERALD DECKER WICHITA COUNTY

25,165-03         HORACE DEMAR HARRIS COUNTY

25,869-41         RONALD DWAYNE WHITFIELD HARRIS COUNTY

28,354-12         IMARI ABYBAKARI OBADELE HARRIS COUNTY

30,977-15         JOHN FORWARD COUNTY

34,705-03         DAVID WAYNE SMITH HARRIS COUNTY

36,973-02         JAMES WILLIE HILL LAMAR COUNTY

38,541-02         LONNIE HENRY RECTOR JR. HARRIS COUNTY

39,655-06         MICHAEL KEITH DOUGLAS BEXAR COUNTY

40,268-04         ERVIN EUGENE WALKER HARRIS COUNTY

46,206-03         ROGER MARTINEZ, JR. BEXAR COUNTY

46,729-03         ROBERT PAUL CRESON DALLAS COUNTY

47,047-03         MAURICE JOHNSON BOWIE COUNTY

47,396-01         LORENZO D. WASHINGTON HARRIS COUNTY

48,120-01         BRIAN L. JOHNSON FRANKLIN COUNTY

48,417-02         LARRY SEAN JORDON DALLAS COUNTY

48,977-01         RONALD LEE NEIGHBORS DALLAS COUNTY

49,062-01         GEORGE L. WILLIAMS DALLAS COUNTY

49,095-02         TROY LYNN BISHOP COUNTY

49,113-01         HEATH PRICE LIMESTONE COUNTY

49,139-01         CALVIN WOODKINS COUNTY

49,190-01         ADAM T. TERRELL COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:

 

 

39,655-07         MICHAEL KEITH DOUGLAS BEXAR COUNTY

47,201-01         WOODROW WILSON SHOOK JR. YOUNG COUNTY

47,556-01         VICENTE MUNOZ EL PASO COUNTY

49,091-01         ANTHONY MILLER HARRIS COUNTY



MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE ORIGINAL APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:



23,387-03         MARK WILLIAM IRVING HARDIN COUNTY