THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS
APRIL 16, 2003
THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:
71,487 JOHN AVALOS ALBA FROM COLLIN COUNTY
AFFIRMED–OPINION JUDGE MEYERS
NON-PUBLISHED OPINION
HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)
74,627 EX PARTE ROLANDO PRICE FROM EL PASO COUNTY
74,628 EX PARTE JAMES EVERETT DICKEY FROM LAMAR COUNTY
74,629 EX PARTE JAMES EVERETT DICKEY FROM LAMAR COUNTY
74,630 EX PARTE WILLIE EARL LIPSCOMB FROM DALLAS COUNTY
(JUDGE KEASLER NOT PARTICIPATING)
74,631 EX PARTE WILLIE EARL LIPSCOMB FROM DALLAS COUNTY
(JUDGE KEASLER NOT PARTICIPATING)
74,632 EX PARTE RODSHEA DEVON JONES FROM WALLER COUNTY
74,633 EX PARTE JOSEPH MICHAEL BARKER FROM WOOD COUNTY
74,634 EX PARTE JOSEPH MICHAEL BARKER FROM WOOD COUNTY
74,635 EX PARTE JOSEPH MICHAEL BARKER FROM WOOD COUNTY
ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:
0421-02 JOHNNY WELDON CATES, II HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-01152-CR
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED IN PART;
JUDGMENT OF TRIAL COURT REFORMED–OPINION JUDGE KEASLER
(PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER CONCURRED IN THE RESULT)
(JUDGE WOMACK DISSENTED)
PUBLISHED OPINION
APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:
1857-02 MERRITT, RUSSELL EDWARD HARRIS COUNTY 01-93-01009-CR
2043-02 CARTER, BOBBY LEE DALLAS COUNTY 05-02-00257-CR
2071-02 ISAAC, RAYMOND C. JR. HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00951-CR
2088-02 DABBS, HARRELL DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01765-CR
2137-02 GONZALEZ, KERWINK EDWIN TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00340-CR
2160-02 KEY, MARK ALLEN WALLER COUNTY 01-01-01051-CR
2166-02 REYNOLDS, JEFF BRAZORIA COUNTY 01-01-00407-CR
2198-02 ESTRADA, KENNETH ISAAC HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-00893-CR
2199-02 NEWBURN, BARRY OBOLENSKY TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00408-CR
2205-02 GUARDADO, ROGELIO ALBERTO HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-01142-CR
2207-02 GORE, JUSTIN DAMIEN HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-01135-CR
2232-02 SEALS, JESSE GENE TAYLOR COUNTY 11-02-00087-CR
0031-03 GAINES, LAWRENCE EDWARD COLLIN COUNTY 05-02-00328-CR
0044-03 ODOM, BRANDON WALKER COUNTY 01-01-00730-CR
0071-03 GONZALEZ, KERWINK EDWIN TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00339-CR
0098-03 GREEN, LATOYA TITUS COUNTY 06-01-00226-CR
0263-03 CUNIGAN, MARLIN LAMONT DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01571-CR
0267-03 GRAHAM, CLIFFORD WILLIAM GREGG COUNTY 06-02-00095-CR
0268-03 GRAHAM, CLIFFORD WILLIAM GREGG COUNTY 06-02-00096-CR
0269-03 BISHOP, RICHARD DALE NEWTON COUNTY 09-02-00189-CR
0272-03 LIRA, RAMON MOORE COUNTY 07-01-00450-CR
0273-03 CRAVIN, DONALD RAY HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-01166-CR
0274-03 EVERSOLE, TERRY P. HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-01081-CR
0279-03 KOLB, CAROLYN C. HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-01079-CR
0280-03 VASQUEZ, JESUS HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-01059-CR
0281-03 MORALES, RUBEN LOYA HARRIS COUNTY 01-02-00308-CR
0282-03 HARGROVE, RONALD ERVIN HARRIS COUNTY 01-02-00301-CR
0284-03 GUNDRUM, DAVID MILTON . TARRANT COUNTY 02-02-00056-CR
0285-03 GUNDRUM, DAVID MILTON . TARRANT COUNTY 02-02-00057-CR
0286-03 GUNDRUM, DAVID MILTON . TARRANT COUNTY 02-02-00058-CR
0287-03 ALLISON, KENNETH RICHARD HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-00383-CR
0288-03 ALLISON, KENNETH RICHARD HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-00384-CR
0289-03 ALLISON, KENNETH RICHARD HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-00385-CR
0290-03 ALLISON, KENNETH RICHARD HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-00386-CR
0291-03 JOHNSON, KELVIN CHARLES HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-01043-CR
0294-03 CAMPOS, AURELIO HARRIS COUNTY 01-02-00040-CR
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
0,0979-04 CURTIS RAY ROBERTS ANGELINA COUNTY
17,583-09 FREDDIE LEE WALKER CALDWELL COUNTY
17,583-10 FREDDIE LEE WALKER GONZALES COUNTY
24,564-05 GERALD C. ZULIANI TRAVIS COUNTY
32,742-08 GILBERTO HERNANDEZ JR. HOUSTON COUNTY
32,866-04 RAYMOND III GARCIA HARRIS COUNTY
33,927-02 SYLVIA LEE ROY DENTON COUNTY
35,913-03 TY MICHAEL BROWN HARRIS COUNTY
36,427-02 STEPHEN STROUD NUECES COUNTY
41,974-02 ALTON LEE KESSLER SR. VAN ZANDT COUNTY
42,776-12 DONALD FOSTER ORANGE COUNTY
42,776-13 DONALD FOSTER ORANGE COUNTY
44,300-05 RANDY GLENN CLARY RUSK COUNTY
45,383-02 DELMIRO LICHTENBERGER JIM WELLS COUNTY
46,056-03 BRUCE EDWARD DAVIS WALKER COUNTY
47,241-02 GUADALUPE GUTIERREZ GALVESTON COUNTY
51,571-05 DANIEL MORALES DALLAS COUNTY
51,608-02 KENNETH EDWARD JR CRAWFORD HARRIS COUNTY
52,102-02 WILLIAM IVEY JR. FOSHEE SMITH COUNTY
52,249-02 FREDDIE LEE JOHNSON MONTGOMERY COUNTY
52,328-02 CESAR E. GUERRA EL PASO COUNTY
53,191-01 SCOTT PAUL SCHNEIDER DENTON COUNTY
53,457-01 MILARS MAYS DALLAS COUNTY
54,212-02 JUAN PABLO LOVO DALLAS COUNTY
54,760-02 CHARLES MULLIS TARRANT COUNTY
54,796-01 DANA JOHN ALEXANDER BELL COUNTY
54,796-02 DANA JOHN ALEXANDER BELL COUNTY
54,796-03 DANA JOHN ALEXANDER BELL COUNTY
54,796-04 DANA JOHN ALEXANDER BELL COUNTY
55,225-01 JEFFREY KYLE MARTIN TAYLOR COUNTY
55,225-02 JEFFREY KYLE MARTIN TAYLOR COUNTY
55,226-01 W J MARTIN LYNN COUNTY
55,240-01 HOWARD BERNARD JEFFERY HOPKINS COUNTY
55,241-01 ROBERT CURTIS JR WILLIAMS JEFFERSON COUNTY
55,245-01 RONNIE HERNANDEZ DALLAS COUNTY
55,246-01 KRIS DALE JOHNSON DALLAS COUNTY
55,246-02 KRIS DALE JOHNSON DALLAS COUNTY
55,251-01 RAMIRO JULIAN JR MUNOZ DENTON COUNTY
55,258-01 RONALD SMITH TARRANT COUNTY
55,258-02 RONALD SMITH TARRANT COUNTY
55,323-01 BRANDON CLYDE BOOTH GALVESTON COUNTY
55,347-01 WILLIAM CHRISTOPHER DALLAS COUNTY
55,376-01 MICHEAL RAY WELLS DALLAS COUNTY
55,403-01 JORGE RIVERA SALMERON HARRIS COUNTY
55,405-01 STACY LEE MOCK POTTER COUNTY
55,405-02 STACY LEE MOCK POTTER COUNTY
55,412-01 DON MICHAEL MALINKA HARRIS COUNTY
55,421-01 JEFFERY FRANK ALLEN POTTER COUNTY
55,425-01 GREGORY FENTROY EVANS WHARTON COUNTY
55,425-02 GREGORY FENTROY EVANS WHARTON COUNTY
55,425-03 GREGORY FENTROY EVANS WHARTON COUNTY
55,425-04 GREGORY FENTROY EVANS WHARTON COUNTY
55,425-05 GREGORY FENTROY EVANS WHARTON COUNTY
55,425-06 GREGORY FENTROY EVANS WHARTON COUNTY
55,476-01 AMANDA KAY MOON PANOLA COUNTY
55,480-01 SHAWN ALLEN DEAN ORANGE COUNTY
55,481-01 JAMES EARL SR. BELCHER ECTOR COUNTY
55,482-01 MARTIN ANTHONY ETUGBO TRAVIS COUNTY
55,483-01 CORWIN ARMELL BROWN HARRIS COUNTY
55,485-01 JEFFERY J. PATTERSON DENTON COUNTY
55,485-02 JEFFERY J. PATTERSON DENTON COUNTY
55,485-03 JEFFERY J. PATTERSON DENTON COUNTY
55,525-01 FREDERICK LAMON SR. GRAYSON BELL COUNTY
55,533-01 ROBERT EARL ROBERSON HARRIS COUNTY
55,580-01 GARY MICHAEL JR. RODGERS HARRIS COUNTY
55,654-01 JAMAL LANCE ADAIR HARRIS COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)
11,832-02 DAVID ROBIN PICKLE MIDLAND COUNTY
43,815-04 CHARLES F. NELSON DALLAS COUNTY
46,599-03 GREG JOHNSON TARRANT COUNTY
52,861-01 EARNEST LEE MCFAIL DALLAS COUNTY
52,861-02 EARNEST LEE MCFAIL DALLAS COUNTY
53,308-01 JONATHAN DALE MASON ECTOR COUNTY
53,329-02 JOSEPH HILL CARTIER POTTER COUNTY
54,123-02 SAMUEL EUGENE RUCKER JACKSON COUNTY
54,442-02 CHARLES A. HILL III TRAVIS COUNTY
54,595-01 YOLANDA NECOLE COOKS HARRIS COUNTY
54,942-02 MICHAEL RUNTRAIL RICHARDS HARRIS COUNTY
55,011-03 ARNOLD RAY JR LAMOTTE TRAVIS COUNTY
55,061-01 JAMES EDWARD JR BLEDSOE MCLENNAN COUNTY
55,061-02 JAMES EDWARD JR BLEDSOE MCLENNAN COUNTY
55,061-03 JAMES EDWARD JR BLEDSOE MCLENNAN COUNTY
55,195-01 CHRISTOPHER LYNN BOEN HARRIS COUNTY
55,239-01 LONNIE EDWARD CROSBY DALLAS COUNTY
55,259-01 OLEN MICHAEL SR SMITH TARRANT COUNTY
55,264-01 JOE ROBERT BANDA BEXAR COUNTY
55,312-01 TEDDY EARL DAVIS HARRIS COUNTY
55,318-01 RAMON EUGENE GIBBS HARRIS COUNTY
55,319-01 FRANK ANTHONY HUNTER DALLAS COUNTY
55,355-01 IGNACIO GONZALES LINARES BEXAR COUNTY
55,366-01 STEVEN J RUSENKO HARRIS COUNTY
55,401-01 ARMANDO VIDAURE BEXAR COUNTY
55,402-01 MICHAEL WADE SR. SNELL BEXAR COUNTY
55,406-01 FRANK LUIS JR. QUIJANO HARRIS COUNTY
55,411-01 CHARLES A. NEILL MCLENNAN COUNTY
55,426-01 ANDREW ONEAL CAMPBELL HARRIS COUNTY
55,434-01 FEDERICO JR DIAZ EL PASO COUNTY
55,471-01 JOSE ANTONIO CHICUA-NAVARRO ELLIS COUNTY
55,474-01 DARRELL DAJUAN DANIELS BOWIE COUNTY
55,489-01 GILBERT JULIAN VELEZ HARRIS COUNTY
55,512-01 SAMUEL FRANK MCCREARY JEFFERSON COUNTY
55,514-01 DAVID O. VILLAREAL BEXAR COUNTY
55,520-01 KENNETH WEST HARRIS COUNTY
55,523-01 KEITH ROBERT SAUER MONTGOMERY COUNTY
55,534-01 DAVID KEITH WYLUPEK EL PASO COUNTY
55,574-01 VERNON R. JACKSON JEFFERSON COUNTY
55,590-01 JAMES RAY HAMPTON JEFFERSON COUNTY
55,594-01 WILLIAM JAMES JR. MORRIS BEXAR COUNTY
7,922-05 ROBERT JR. DE LA GARZA BEXAR COUNTY
7,922-06 ROBERT JR. DE LA GARZA BEXAR COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITH HEARING)
55,157-01 JAMES MORRIS ABEL HARRIS COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
19,683-08 RODNEY THOMAS ROGERS BELL COUNTY
25,790-03 BOOKER T. LEWIS SMITH COUNTY
53,941-01 STEVEN HAGBERG BOWIE COUNTY
54,627-01 ROBERT BOYD KNOWLES ATASCOSA COUNTY
55,223-02 EDWARD EARL MASSINGILL HARRIS COUNTY
55,233-01 SHAMON JEROME WOODS TARRANT COUNTY
55,277-01 RENE MODESTO MORENO CAMERON COUNTY
55,354-01 BILLY GENE FOSTER BEXAR COUNTY
55,354-02 BILLY GENE FOSTER BEXAR COUNTY
55,463-01 STEPHEN SMITH SMITH COUNTY
55,551-01 MARK ANTHONY GARZA BEXAR COUNTY
55,582-01 GARELD DUANE JR. ROLLINS BEXAR COUNTY
55,582-02 GARELD DUANE JR. ROLLINS BEXAR COUNTY
55,595-01 MARIO JR. RAMOS WEBB COUNTY
55,595-02 MARIO JR. RAMOS WEBB COUNTY
55,604-01 ROBERTO GONZALES TRAVIS COUNTY
55,645-01 RICHARD DELGADO EL PASO COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)
15,089-05 JACK WAYLON CHISUM BEXAR COUNTY
55,222-01 RONALD PATRICK KLENTZ HARRIS COUNTY
55,238-01 DEREK BATTLE BEXAR COUNTY
55,603-01 BILLY RAY FORBES GRAYSON COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)
13,887-04 ROGER DALE GODBEHERE DALLAS COUNTY
13,887-05 ROGER DALE GODBEHERE DALLAS COUNTY
22,438-04 HERMAN LEON HARRIS DALLAS COUNTY
24,665-03 MARION BOOTH JR. HOLMESLY MATAGORDA COUNTY
25,545-02 TERRY DALE SPRUNGER HARRIS COUNTY
25,899-02 KENNETH DOUGLAS CHAPMAN DALLAS COUNTY
26,708-06 KENT ANTHONY KRUEGER COMAL COUNTY
28,115-03 GUZMAN SAMBRANO FRIO COUNTY
29,660-02 JIMMY DEVON WILTZ HARRIS COUNTY
33,924-02 ROBERT ALLEN TAYLOR TARRANT COUNTY
40,245-03 WILLIE LEE JOHNSON LUBBOCK COUNTY
41,150-02 FREDRICK DEWAYNE SMITH DALLAS COUNTY
42,433-05 JOE LUIS GUIA BEXAR COUNTY
42,433-06 JOE LUIS GUIA BEXAR COUNTY
49,192-03 DANIEL ELLIS TAYLOR HOPKINS COUNTY
51,571-04 DANIEL MORALES DALLAS COUNTY
52,561-04 WESLEY WESTBROOK HIDALGO COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER
(TEX. GOV'T CODE SEC. 501.0081 (b) )
26,361-02 LARRY EDWARD WALTON TARRANT COUNTY
38,247-03 MARCUS TAYLOR TRAVIS COUNTY
48,767-03 TONY DEAN WATSON TARRANT COUNTY
48,767-04 TONY DEAN WATSON TARRANT COUNTY
55,370-01 ABEL LUIS CARREON BEXAR COUNTY
55,381-01 KEVIN HUNTER BEXAR COUNTY
55,381-02 KEVIN HUNTER BEXAR COUNTY
55,484-01 GUSTAVO ALVAREZ HARRIS COUNTY
55,527-01 JOHN ERIC ADAWAY JEFFERSON COUNTY
55,592-01 RONALD LAARTHUR JR. CHASE SMITH COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:
55,092-01 HUGH LEE BURTON HARRIS COUNTY
55,194-01 DARRYL ALMEIDA COLORADO COUNTY
55,204-01 TORRE RAMIREZ BRAZORIA COUNTY
55,221-01 JUAN ISMAEL LOPEZ LIMESTONE COUNTY
55,272-01 DOUGLAS SCOTT STILLMAN MADISON COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:
2,564-09 WILLIE EARL LIPSCOMB DALLAS COUNTY
2,564-10 WILLIE EARL LIPSCOMB DALLAS COUNTY
52,774-01 JAMES EVERETT DICKEY LAMAR COUNTY
52,774-02 JAMES EVERETT DICKEY LAMAR COUNTY
53,504-02 ROLANDO PRICE EL PASO COUNTY
54,254-01 JOSEPH MICHAEL BARKER WOOD COUNTY
54,254-02 JOSEPH MICHAEL BARKER WOOD COUNTY
54,254-03 JOSEPH MICHAEL BARKER WOOD COUNTY
55,441-01 RODSHEA JONES WALLER COUNTY
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE
AND RESPONDENT IS ORDERED TO FILE ANSWER:
0,0979-05 CURTIS RAY ROBERTS ANGELINA COUNTY
32,685-04 EUGENE J. WINTERS TARRANT COUNTY
38,598-02 WILLIAM FLOYD KENT HARRIS COUNTY
50,440-03 JAMES CAROL SHEPHERD MONTGOMERY COUNTY
55,276-01 FELIPE III SANDOVAL EL PASO COUNTY
55,341-01 REGINALD NOBLE DALLAS COUNTY
55,498-01 ROOSEVELT BEAVERS HARRIS COUNTY
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT
WRITTEN ORDER:
17,070-09 KIRBY GARDNER HARRIS COUNTY
18,948-06 LEONARD WAYNE KITT HARRIS COUNTY
23,953-18 MARTIN FRANCO JR. LLANO COUNTY
26,047-07 LARRY GENE STRHAN DALLAS COUNTY
27,698-05 JOHNNIE O'NEAL DOGGINS COOKE COUNTY
36,290-05 JERRARD J. MCGARY BOWIE COUNTY
36,291-04 ALEXANDER LAMONT GUNTER BELL COUNTY
38,247-02 MARCUS TAYLOR TRAVIS COUNTY
42,347-04 MICHAEL WAYNE HARRIS HARRIS COUNTY
51,571-03 DANIEL MORALES DALLAS COUNTY
52,561-03 WESLEY WESTBROOK HIDALGO COUNTY
52,861-03 EARNEST LEE MCFAIL DALLAS COUNTY
53,425-02 FRANK FERNLEY BROWNING HARRIS COUNTY
53,570-04 JOSEPH LARRY PORTER HARRIS COUNTY
54,442-01 CHARLES A. HILL III TRAVIS COUNTY
55,011-02 ARNOLD RAY JR LAMOTTE TRAVIS COUNTY
55,056-01 GREGORY L NED EL PASO COUNTY
55,157-02 JAMES MORRIS ABEL HARRIS COUNTY
55,223-01 EDWARD EARL MASSINGILL HARRIS COUNTY
55,226-02 W J MARTIN LYNN COUNTY
55,492-01 BRYAN HOLBERT JEFFERSON COUNTY
7,922-03 ROBERT JR. DE LA GARZA BEXAR COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED FOR NON-COMPLIANCE WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
15,132-06 LUCILLE ANNETTE GELABERT HARRIS COUNTY
15,132-07 LUCILLE ANNETTE GELABERT HARRIS COUNTY
18,912-03 MACKIE JO BUSH HANCOCK JOHNSON COUNTY
39,176-03 RODNEY K. BURTON HARRIS COUNTY
49,768-02 GILBERTO REZA CAMERON COUNTY
53,570-02 JOSEPH LARRY PORTER HARRIS COUNTY
53,570-03 JOSEPH LARRY PORTER HARRIS COUNTY
54,365-02 PATRICK OWEN CUNNINGHAM DALLAS COUNTY
54,535-02 JAMES B. AUSTIN NACOGDOCHES COUNTY
54,535-03 JAMES B. AUSTIN NACOGDOCHES COUNTY
54,535-04 JAMES B. AUSTIN NACOGDOCHES COUNTY
54,535-05 JAMES B. AUSTIN NACOGDOCHES COUNTY
54,535-06 JAMES B. AUSTIN NACOGDOCHES COUNTY
54,701-02 HARRY CHAMBERS GALVESTON COUNTY
55,159-02 RICKY L. BROWN TARRANT COUNTY
55,316-01 CHARLES ARNOLD TRAVIS COUNTY
55,360-01 RICHARD O’GORMAN GRAY COUNTY
55,554-01 TOMAS MORENO, JR. FREESTONE COUNTY
55,565-01 JAMES MARSHALL TYLER COUNTY
55,565-02 JAMES MARSHALL TYLER COUNTY
55,598-01 EUGENE BROWN, III HARRIS COUNTY
55,599-01 DAVID ESCOBAR WEBB COUNTY
55,600-01 JOSE LUIS ESCOBAR, SR. WEBB COUNTY
55,602-01 DARREN TODD OLIVER COLORADO COUNTY
ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:
43,550-02 KENNETH WAYNE MORRIS HARRIS COUNTY
REQUEST FOR STAY OF EXECUTION DENIED
(DENIED APRIL 14, 2003)