THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS


APRIL 12, 2000






THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:




73,058         CHUONG DUONG TONG FROM HARRIS COUNTY

JUDGMENT AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

(JUDGES MANSFIELD AND WOMACK JOIN)

PUBLISHED OPINION



73,065         VINCENT GUTIERREZ FROM BEXAR COUNTY

JUDGMENT AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

73,129         TOMMIE COLLINS HUGHES FROM DALLAS COUNTY

JUDGMENT AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE MANSFIELD

(JUDGE MEYERS CONCURS WITH NOTE)

(JUDGE JOHNSON CONCURRED IN THE RESULT)

PUBLISHED OPINION

73,280         FELIX ROCHA FROM HARRIS COUNTY

JUDGMENT AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE KELLER

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE HOLLAND

(JUDGES MEYERS, PRICE AND JOHNSON JOINED)

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

PUBLISHED OPINION







HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)

73,767         EX PARTE BILLY RAY WASHINGTON FROM BASTROP COUNTY

73,768         EX PARTE TRACY LAIMONT BUSTER FROM DALLAS COUNTY

73,769         EX PARTE CRAIG BOWSER FROM TRAVIS COUNTY

73,770         EX PARTE ROGER ANTHONY HARRIS FROM DALLAS COUNTY

73,771         EX PARTE GEOFF T. COLE FROM WILLIAMSON COUNTY

                    (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

73,772         EX PARTE WAYLAND RENARD GRANT FROM DALLAS COUNTY

73,773         EX PARTE JAMES RONALD WOLFE FROM COOKE COUNTY

73,774         EX PARTE ANTHONY RAY GUINN FROM SMITH COUNTY

ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:

1352-99       MICHAEL DEAN GRUBBS FROM TARRANT COUNTY

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED;

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--PER CURIAM OPINION

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION



1701-99       DONTAE ROBINSON FROM BEXAR COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE MANSFIELD

PUBLISHED OPINION

ON STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:

0168-98       DAVID ALLEN LEE FROM COLLIN COUNTY (SPA'S NO. 1)

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

TRIAL COURT'S ORDER DISMISSING INDICTMENT IS SET ASIDE;

OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

(PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK AND JUDGE KELLER JOINED)

(JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

PUBLISHED OPINION

0168-98       DAVID ALLEN LEE FROM COLLIN COUNTY (DA'S NO. 2)

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

TRIAL COURT'S ORDER DISMISSING INDICTMENT IS SET ASIDE;

OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

(PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK AND JUDGE KELLER JOINED)

(JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

PUBLISHED OPINION







APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING ON APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DENIED:

0201-00         KAREEM JABBAR WILSON HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00112-CR

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

0002-00         JOHNSON, JAMES HOWARD (#2) HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01170-CR

0003-00         JOHNSON, JAMES HOWARD (#2) HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01171-CR

0005-00         MCNASPY, ROBERT PAUL HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01317-CR

0063-00         BENITEZ, TOMAS, JR. LUBBOCK COUNTY 07-98-00405-CR

0091-00         MOSS, DARRON TRAY FALLS COUNTY 10-98-00001-CR

0206-00         RUELAS, ARTHUR EL PASO COUNTY 08-98-00098-CR

0214-00         WINKLEMANN, CHARLES WAYNE HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00607-CR

0215-00         WINKLEMANN, CHARLES WAYNE HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00608-CR

0217-00         BELCHER, CHARLES BART GREGG COUNTY 12-99-00318-CR

0263-00         MARTINEZ, CARLOS ALBERTO HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00854-CR

0265-00         MIRANDA, MICHAEL CRUZ HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00910-CR

0273-00         HALL, TONY TRENT GALVESTON COUNTY 10-98-00162-CR

0287-00         RIOS, JAIME G. BEXAR COUNTY 04-99-00062-CR

0289-00         VIGIL, JESSE BEXAR COUNTY 04-98-00921-CR

1551-98         POOLE, MYERL ANTONIO WILLIAMSON COUNTY 03-97-00047-CR

                       (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

1552-98         POOLE, MYERL ANTONIO WILLIAMSON COUNTY 03-97-00048-CR

                       (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

1713-98         EWING, KENNETH JAMES MONTGOMERY COUNTY 09-97-00216-CR

1498-99         COLLINS, ODIS J. HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00438-CR

1717-99         DUONG, CO QUY HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00387-CR

1718-99         DUONG, CO QUY HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00390-CR

1719-99         DUONG, CO QUY HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00392-CR

1782-99         MORGAN, BILLY CLYDE, JR. TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00273-CR

2036-99         BURNS, WESLEY THEODORE GRAYSON COUNTY 08-97-00524-CR

2037-99         BURNS, WESLEY THEODORE GRAYSON COUNTY 08-97-00525-CR

2038-99         BURNS, WESLEY THEODORE GRAYSON COUNTY 08-97-00526-CR

2039-99         BURNS, WESLEY THEODORE GRAYSON COUNTY 08-97-00527-CR

2064-99         GRAHAM, DAVID CHRISTOPHER TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00483-CR

2093-99         WRIGHT, CALVIN TARRANT COUNTY 02-99-00151-CR

2125-99         PRICE, MARCUS EUGENE HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00895-CR

STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

0002-00         JOHNSON, JAMES HOWARD (#1) HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01170-CR

0003-00         JOHNSON, JAMES HOWARD (#1) HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01171-CR

0018-00         LARWAY, JOHN DONALD HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00136-CR

0628-99         DICKSON, EDDIE MAURICE TARRANT COUNTY 10-97-00338-CR

1955-99         MASSEY, JERRY W. (SPA) BEXAR COUNTY 04-99-00040-CR

2019-99         WILSON, DICKIE BRUCE DALLAS COUNTY 10-97-00090-CR

                       (JUDGE MANSFIELD WOULD GRANT)

APPELLEE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

1959-99         ADAN SALAS EL PASO COUNTY 08-98-00101-CR

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:

0695-00         ELIAS ANTHONY FRANCO ECTOR COUNTY 08-98-00008-CR

                       (RULE 9.1(C) EIGHTH COURT OF APPEALS LOCAL RULES)

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:

0246-00         MICHAEL WAYNE POTTER HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-01067-CR

                       (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:


2055-99         DANIEL RIOS, JR. (DA'S #1) HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-00627-CR

                       (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

2055-99         DANIEL RIOS, JR. (SPA'S #2) HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-00627-CR

                       (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

0083-00         MICHAEL JOEL MORALES HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00457-CR

                       (ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:


32,786-03         MORRIS WAYNE MYERS BRAZOS COUNTY

34,095-07         ANTONIO SEPEDA DE WITT COUNTY

34,095-08         ANTONIO SEPEDA DE WITT COUNTY

37,972-02         DAVID WESLEY KREGER STEPHENS COUNTY

39,863-03         TIMOTHY MORROW TAYLOR COUNTY

44,136-01         KAREEM MUHAMMAD SMITH COUNTY

44,161-01         RAUL GUERRERO ROSILLO JR. HIDALGO COUNTY

44,465-01         RONALD JOE WATERS DENTON COUNTY

44,747-01         DAVID STRINGER JR. DENTON COUNTY

44,779-01         JERRY MACK GENTRY NOLAN COUNTY

44,886-01         RAY ANTHONY THOMPSON TRAVIS COUNTY

44,886-02         RAY ANTHONY THOMPSON TRAVIS COUNTY

44,920-01         DAVID ALLEN HAFERKAMP WASHINGTON COUNTY

44,920-02         DAVID ALLEN HAFERKAMP WASHINGTON COUNTY

44,926-01         WALTER EUGENE AXLEY JR. COLLIN COUNTY

                           (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

44,940-01         DANIEL LEE HARRELL PARKER COUNTY

45,017-01         ARVIL M. TALAMANTEZ REEVES COUNTY

45,018-02         GENE AUTRY LEE TARRANT COUNTY

45,024-01         LEON CALLENDER JR. MONTAGUE COUNTY

45,030-01         MICHAEL MCCORMICK TARRANT COUNTY

45,037-01         GREGORY RODRIGUEZ KARNES COUNTY

45,037-02         GREGORY RODRIGUEZ KARNES COUNTY

45,038-01         PEDRO RENTERIA EL PASO COUNTY

45,043-01         CEDRIC STEED MCINTOSH JR. POTTER COUNTY

45,080-01         ROBERT D. MILLER DALLAS COUNTY

45,091-01         TONY SEAN BOONE GALVESTON COUNTY

45,093-01         BRUCE ALLEN HUDSON HARDIN COUNTY

45,099-01         GREGORY MITCHELL SARKISSIAN BRAZOS COUNTY

45,110-01         ROBERT EUGENE KAPPLE COLLIN COUNTY

                          (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)

19,305-02         JACKIE RAE YOUNGBLOOD DALLAS COUNTY

29,909-02         JOHNNIE GONZALES BRAZOS COUNTY

29,909-03         JOHNNIE GONZALES BRAZOS COUNTY

33,661-02         OLIVER ANTHONY DECAMBRE DALLAS COUNTY

34,792-02         RALPH ANTHONY WASHINGTON HARRIS COUNTY

37,916-02         KENNETH TAYLOR CASS COUNTY

40,136-06         PAUL STURGEON HARRIS COUNTY

42,091-01         ELLIS LYNN FRANKLIN JR. HENDERSON COUNTY

43,436-02         ERNEST L. MAY JR. MONTGOMERY COUNTY

44,217-01         OSCAR WAYNE NAVARRO BELL COUNTY

44,395-01         KENNETH HONEYCUTT DALLAS COUNTY

44,396-01         KENNY DEWAYNE HOWARD DALLAS COUNTY

44,599-02         JERRY OWEN LUBBOCK COUNTY

44,709-01         PHILLIP LARRY NEW DALLAS COUNTY

44,748-01         KING WALTER WALTHALL DALLAS COUNTY

44,787-01         CHARLES EUGENE CLARK TARRANT COUNTY

44,793-01         JAMES EDWARD NEALY BELL COUNTY

44,807-01         RODNEY JERMAINE JOHNSON BELL COUNTY

44,965-01         GREGORY L. THOMAS TRAVIS COUNTY

44,970-01         RAYMOND CRAWFORD BEXAR COUNTY

44,977-01         BILL MOORE JR. TYLER COUNTY

44,983-01         GERALD BRUCE WILSON MONTGOMERY COUNTY

44,987-01         TRACY ANTHONY COLVIN SCURRY COUNTY

45,002-01         JOSE AGUILAR EL PASO COUNTY

45,006-01         ARTHUR MARTIN STYLES DALLAS COUNTY

45,008-01         LUIS ORELLANO SORTO DALLAS COUNTY

45,013-01         GERALD RAY FRITZ BELL COUNTY

45,023-01         CHARLES WAYNE FRANKLIN COLLIN COUNTY

                           (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

45,041-01         BRIAN WEESE EL PASO COUNTY

45,058-01         ROGER PEREZ BEXAR COUNTY

45,078-01         BOBBY J. MCCOY TARRANT COUNTY

45,081-01         LEE MARION LOCKETT DALLAS COUNTY

45,086-01         KENNETH WAYNE BIGGINS ELLIS COUNTY

45,107-01         RICHARD HUNT DALLAS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

10,751-03         POLICARPIO CASTRO LOPEZ JR. TAYLOR COUNTY

16,970-06         ROBERT GENE DAVIS TARRANT COUNTY

20,399-08         TOMMY LEE JACKSON BELL COUNTY

25,863-07         WILLIAM L. KISSAM SMITH COUNTY

34,095-06         ANTONIO SEPEDA DE WITT COUNTY

34,095-09         ANTONIO SEPEDA DE WITT COUNTY

34,095-10         ANTONIO SEPEDA DE WITT COUNTY

42,534-02         TRAVIS CHRIS GRAY TARRANT COUNTY

43,229-04         ADAM SLEDGE BEXAR COUNTY

43,304-03         ALFRED YOUNG JR. LUBBOCK COUNTY

43,304-04         ALFRED YOUNG JR. LUBBOCK COUNTY

44,659-01         TAMARA RACHELLE JOHNSON SMITH COUNTY

44,729-02         DEXTER JENKINS DALLAS COUNTY

44,741-01         JOHN GUERRERO LUBBOCK COUNTY

44,768-01         RICKY DALE MINOR HOOD COUNTY

44,802-01         DAVID SAMEO DROUIN TRAVIS COUNTY

44,809-01         JOHN FELIX LOPEZ TOM GREEN COUNTY

44,916-01         ANTHONY GERALD JOHNSON ELLIS COUNTY

44,958-01         EDUARDO CRUZ TARRANT COUNTY

44,958-02         EDUARDO CRUZ TARRANT COUNTY

44,971-01         BRYANT LEE COLEMAN GREGG COUNTY

45,020-01         ARTHUR DON STEPHENS ECTOR COUNTY

45,021-01         RAY COHEE WICHITA COUNTY

45,022-01         VERNON JARMON TRAVIS COUNTY

45,031-01         MICHAEL DODSON BEXAR COUNTY

45,031-02         MICHAEL DODSON BEXAR COUNTY

45,036-01         HUMBERTO LARA ECTOR COUNTY

45,036-02         HUMBERTO LARA ECTOR COUNTY

45,039-01         KRIS L. BOX MONTGOMERY COUNTY

45,045-01         ROBERT LOUIS KIRTLEY DENTON COUNTY

45,051-01         JOEL ENRIQUEZ EL PASO COUNTY

45,055-01         KENNETH W. JOHNSON TARRANT COUNTY

45,066-01         FRED WILLIAMS TRAVIS COUNTY

45,079-01         CHRISTOPHER KIMBROUGH BEXAR COUNTY

45,085-01         DALE ANDERSON TARRANT COUNTY

45,087-01         ROBERT L. ANDERSON TARRANT COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)

40,928-02         ERICK LAMPKIN DALLAS COUNTY

44,534-01         CEDRICK DEAN HADNOT DALLAS COUNTY

44,952-01         EDWARD LEE GONZALES ORANGE COUNTY

45,095-01         THOMAS DAVID WILLIAMS BEXAR COUNTY



APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)

14,688-02         GARY RANDALL SHEPPARD NEWTON COUNTY

18,041-02         DONNY RAY SHAW SMITH COUNTY

19,896-03         AARON RONALD JOURNIGAN BRAZORIA COUNTY

2,476-08           JULIAN B. RODRIQUEZ BEXAR COUNTY

22,771-02         AVERY L. FARR HARDIN COUNTY

28,175-06         PAUL JAMES KOUMIJIAN EL PASO COUNTY

28,175-07         PAUL JAMES KOUMIJIAN EL PASO COUNTY

30,137-02         EDDIE BERNARD FLETCHER DALLAS COUNTY

30,328-04         EDWARD ANTOINE WYNN DALLAS COUNTY

31,968-03         WILEY BURLESON JR. HAYS COUNTY

33,536-03         HENRY JOE PETTIGREW SMITH COUNTY

33,603-03         JUAN YRUEGAS YBARRA CROCKETT COUNTY

35,121-06         COREY THEOPLUS HILL DALLAS COUNTY

35,407-02         GARY DON BAKER LUBBOCK COUNTY

37,096-02         SHERMAN TATE FREEMAN MILAM COUNTY

38,478-02         CHRISTOPHER DEMOUCHETTE HARRIS COUNTY

38,927-02         ELBERT CARL JONES DALLAS COUNTY

41,400-03         CONRAD JOE MARTINEZ LUBBOCK COUNTY

41,447-02         GRAVIEL HERNANDEZ RODRIGUEZ HAYS COUNTY

42,029-02         DOUGLAS CRAIG FORD BELL COUNTY

42,737-02         LOUIS JONES DALLAS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:

4,634-03         DANIEL GALLEGOS HARRIS COUNTY

44,234-01         JAMES S. ADAMS BEXAR COUNTY

44,599-01         JERRY OWEN LUBBOCK COUNTY

44,607-01         BILLY JOE DIAZ JR. COLEMAN COUNTY

44,617-01         DARLA KAY SCHRIMPSHERE COLLIN COUNTY

                           (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

44,618-01         TOMMY WILLIS ANGELINA COUNTY

44,645-01         DEANNA BLAIR NICKOLS PALO PINTO COUNTY

44,803-01         ZACHARY NATHAN DUNCAN ORANGE COUNTY

44,848-01         GARY WAYNE PEPPER PANOLA COUNTY

44,992-01         BILLY DARNELL JACOBS CASS COUNTY

44,993-01         ROYCE LEETATE WHITE TARRANT COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:

40,519-01         BILLY RAY WASHINGTON BASTROP COUNTY

41,112-01         WAYLAND RENARD GRANT DALLAS COUNTY

43,251-01         GEOFF T. COLE WILLIAMSON COUNTY

                          (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

44,016-01         JAMES RONALD WOLFE COOKE COUNTY

44,178-01         ANTHONY GUINN SMITH COUNTY

44,513-02         CRAIG BOWSER TRAVIS COUNTY

44,683-01         TRACY LAIMONT BUSTER DALLAS COUNTY

44,684-01         ROGER ANTHONY HARRIS DALLAS COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT

WRITTEN ORDER:

25,869-31         RONALD DWAYNE WHITFIELD HARRIS COUNTY

35,121-05         COREY THEOPLUS HILL DALLAS COUNTY

37,972-01         DAVID WESLEY KREGER STEPHENS COUNTY

38,511-02         ERIC HARRISON COUNTY

39,033-04         JOHNNY MACK FOSTER WICHITA COUNTY

40,223-03         TONI LANETT JOHNSON DALLAS COUNTY

41,942-02         LESLIE SHANE HEFNER DALLAS COUNTY

                          (JUDGE PRICE NOT PARTICIPATING)

42,949-02         DANIEL LEE HOGAN TARRANT COUNTY

44,501-01         JAMES RAY AMBERS COUNTY

44,513-01         CRAIG BOWSER TRAVIS COUNTY

44,705-01         EDWARD SCOTT ASBERRY RANDALL COUNTY

45,018-01         GENE AUTRY LEE TARRANT COUNTY

45,065-01         JAMES WILLIAM BUSCH MONTGOMERY COUNTY

45,075-01         CLIFTON T. MCCURLEY DALLAS COUNTY

45,092-01         DEVANDRA BANSAL COUNTY

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

44,330-01         STEVE RODRIGUEZ BEXAR COUNTY

44,761-01         MICHAEL ROSALES LUBBOCK COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE

14,593-02         RICHARD P. STONE TRAVIS COUNTY

16,984-07         ARCHIE DAVID JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY

27,534-02         KENNETH S. MARTIN EL PASO COUNTY

43,832-01         RICHARD LEE HAMRICK HARRIS COUNTY

45,019-02         RODNEY GRIMSLEY HARRIS COUNTY

45,040-01         STEVE WASHINGTON HARRIS COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

45,019-01         RODNEY GRIMSLEY HARRIS COUNTY

45,060-01         DONALD EDGAR MEANOR SAN JACINTO COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR ORIGINAL WRIT OF CERTIORARI DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

45,061-01         JAY MATTHEW REAVIS