THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS
APRIL 9, 2003
THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:
74,095 JAMES SCOTT PORTER FROM BOWIE COUNTY
AFFIRMED–OPINION JUDGE WOMACK
NON-PUBLISHED OPINION
74,552 EX PARTE JACKIE JOHNSON FROM LAMB COUNTY
RELIEF GRANTED IN PART DENIED IN PART–OPINION JUDGE HERVEY
NON-PUBLISHED OPINION
HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)
74,614 EX PARTE MARTIN GUADALUPE MORENO FROM STARR COUNTY
74,613 EX PARTE KEVIN GOODWIN FROM BOWIE COUNTY
74,615 EX PARTE MARKOS ANTONIO MENDOZA FROM HUTCHINSON COUNTY
74,616 EX PARTE FREDERICK STONE FROM BOWIE COUNTY
74,617 EX PARTE FREDERICK STONE FROM BOWIE COUNTY
74,618 EX PARTE JAMES DARRELL PURVIS FROM TRAVIS COUNTY
74,619 EX PARTE HENRY LEE FROM ANGELINA COUNTY
74,620 EX PARTE RANDALL VALENTINO GONZALES FROM HARRIS COUNTY
74,621 EX PARTE CLEMENTINO OLMOS LOPEZ, JR., FROM DENTON COUNTY
74,622 EX PARTE BRIAN DUTCHOVER FROM EL PASO COUNTY
74,623 EX PARTE BRIAN DUTCHOVER FROM EL PASO COUNTY
74,624 EX PARTE ANTHONY C. HOGAN FROM BEXAR COUNTY
74,625 EX PARTE JOSHUA BRENT WELCH FROM HARRIS COUNTY
APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING DENIED:
73,431 CHARLES VICTOR THOMPSON FROM HARRIS COUNTY
ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:
1329-00 DARLENE HROMADKA HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00685-CR
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;
CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS–OPINION JUDGE WOMACK
(JUDGES KEASLER AND HERVEY DISSENTED)
NON-PUBLISHED OPINION
2144-02 PHILLIP RANDALL KINCHEN CHAMBERS COUNTY 14-02-00859-CR
APPELLANT’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED;
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;
CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS–PER CURIAM OPINION
NON-PUBLISHED OPINION
ON STATE’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:
1555-00 MICHAEL JOHN YEAGER TARRANT COUNTY 10-99-00105-CR
DISSENTING OPINION OF APRIL 2, 2003 WITHDRAWN;
DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS
(JUDGE PRICE JOINED)
PUBLISHED OPINION
ON STATE’S MOTION FOR REHEARING:
0646-00 JOSEPH MARBELLA, III NACOGDOCHES COUNTY 12-99-00275-CR
REHEARING OVERRULED–PER CURIAM OPINION
NON-PUBLISHED OPINION
STATE’S MOTION FOR REHEARING ON STATE’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DENIED:
2360-01 TOMMY TREVINO TARRANT COUNTY 02-99-00554-CR
(CORRECTED PAGE 3 OF ORIGINAL OPINION ISSUED ON FEBRUARY 26, 2003)
STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:
2191-02 PAGE, CHARLIE MELVIN GALVESTON COUNTY 13-00-00035-CR
(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
2192-02 PAGE, CHARLIE MELVIN GALVESTON COUNTY 13-00-00423-CR
(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:
1464-02 RAMEY, JOHN MARTIN BRAZORIA COUNTY 14-01-00723-CR
1465-02 RAMEY, JOHN MARTIN BRAZORIA COUNTY 14-01-00825-CR
1574-02 VANN, PATRICK CORNELL HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-00544-CR
1577-02 VELAZQUEZ, LUIS EL PASO COUNTY 08-01-00189-CR
1660-02 KILLIAN, EDWIN WALLACE, JR. DALLAS COUNTY 08-01-00032-CR
(JUDGE MEYERS AND HOLCOMB WOULD GRANT)
1661-02 KILLIAN, EDWIN DALLAS COUNTY 08-01-00033-CR
(JUDGES MEYERS AND HOLCOMB WOULD GRANT)
1755-02 TARLTON, THEOPHILUS DEBOER HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01410-CR
1790-02 DANDONA, NEAL RAJAT HARRIS COUNTY 10-01-00039-CR
1800-02 WARD, KENNETH JOSEPH DENTON COUNTY 02-01-00318-CR
1803-02 PORTER, HUBERT RAY, JR. HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-00177-CR
1804-02 PORTER, HUBERT RAY, JR. HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-00178-CR
1805-02 PORTER, HUBERT RAY, JR. HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-00179-CR
1870-02 TURNER, JOHN EL PASO COUNTY 08-01-00360-CR
1896-02 FALLIN, JERRY HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-00754-CR
1914-02 FARRA, ROBERT LESLIE HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-01335-CR
1941-02 LAMBERTZ II, ROBERT HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-00633-CR
1950-02 DAVALOS, PASCUAL DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01005-CR
1952-02 DAVALOS, PASCUAL DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01007-CR
1953-02 KOSHELL, PETER RICHARD DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01072-CR
1960-02 REYES, ABELINO HARRIS COUNTY 07-01-00427-CR
2005-02 SMITH, KENNETH RAY HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-00983-CR
2066-02 SERVIS, ROBERT WALTER JR. TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00532-CR
2072-02 WATSON, EDWARD STANLEY HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-00418-CR
2085-02 CHOICE, JAMIE JAMELLE DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01164-CR
2086-02 MENDOZA, AGAPITO P. JR. DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01816-CR
2147-02 BROWN, JOSEPH CELESTE HARRIS COUNTY 11-02-00027-CR
2149-02 PETERS, EDWIN JOSEPH HARRIS COUNTY 07-01-00430-CR
2211-02 JAMESON, JUNIOR EARL JR. SMITH COUNTY 12-01-00374-CR
2231-02 BUCHANAN, TIMOTHY WAYNE BORDEN COUNTY 11-00-00368-CR
0022-03 TIEDE II, BERNHARDT PANOLA COUNTY 12-99-00182-CR
0034-03 GREEN, FORREST JEROME GUADALUPE COUNTY 04-02-00221-CR
0043-03 MACKEY, DONALD EUGENE HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-00276-CR
0065-03 LEMASURIER, PHILIP KEITH TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00404-CR
0066-03 DOOLEY, SAMUEL WADE DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01914-CR
0067-03 PICKARD, DALE ALAN HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-01167-CR
0075-03 NEAGLE, WILLIAM WELDON HOOD COUNTY 02-01-00128-CR
0140-03 JONES, DINARIO SMITH COUNTY 12-01-00135-CR
0162-03 ROSS, ROY EUGENE POLK COUNTY 09-01-00517-CR
0215-03 LONG, ERIC ALEXANDER HARRIS COUNTY 11-02-00056-CR
0220-03 ROJAS, JUAN CARLOS HIDALGO COUNTY 13-97-00718-CR
0221-03 ROJAS, JUAN CARLOS HIDALGO COUNTY 13-97-00719-CR
0222-03 ROJAS, JUAN CARLOS HIDALGO COUNTY 13-97-00720-CR
0255-03 SCHLANKER, KENNETH NEIL, JR. WASHINGTON COUNTY 01-02-00056-CR
0256-03 VINCENT, JEFFREY DAVID DENTON COUNTY 02-02-00035-CR
0257-03 EVERETT, BILLY JOE TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00507-CR
0258-03 HART, CRAIG ANTHONY ARANSAS COUNTY 13-01-00856-CR
0260-03 UKPERAJ, AGIM DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-00298-CR
0270-03 STERLING, THOMAS JAMES JR. CHILDRESS COUNTY 07-02-00171-CR
0271-03 BERNAL, MARK ANTHONY HARRIS COUNTY 07-00-00490-CR
0320-03 FINK, KEVIN MATTHEW TARRANT COUNTY 03-01-00567-CR
0373-03 ISAAC, GARY DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01769-CR
0400-03 SY, BENITO SIA HARRIS COUNTY 06-02-00074-CR
APPELLEE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:
0228-03 MALDANDADO, JULIAN SAN PATRICIO COUNTY 13-01-00783-CR
APPELLANT’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW STRUCK FOR NON-COMPLIANCE WITH WRITTEN ORDER:
0114-03 HUBBERT, RONNIE DOUGLAS GREGG COUNTY 06-01-00214-CR
2067-02 MERCIER, JEREMY PHILLIP TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00088-CR
2104-02 VENTURA, JOSE ISRAEL DALLAS COUNTY 05-99-01745-CR
2105-02 VENTURA, JOSE ISRAEL DALLAS COUNTY 05-99-01746-CR
0109-03 BRITE, GUS LEE CALDWELL COUNTY 03-02-00319-CR
0264-03 STYLES, RICHARD JR. STONEWALL COUNTY 11-02-00076-CR
0372-03 DAWSON, ALFRED EARL COLLIN COUNTY 05-02-00336-CR
0450-03 DAVIS, KRISTEN KAY HARRIS COUNTY 14-02-00112-CR
PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER, JUDGES KEASLER AND HERVEY DISSENT TO THE ABOVE ORDERS:
APPELLANT’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DISMISSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:
2216-02 NORTON, DYWINO A. DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-00344-CR
2217-02 NORTON, DYWINO A. DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-00345-CR
APPELLANT’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW WITHDRAWN:
0155-03 DAVIS, DARRYL WATTS HARRIS COUNTY 01-02-00138-CR
0156-03 DAVIS, DARRYL WATTS HARRIS COUNTY 01-02-00139-CR
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
31,700-07 LOUIS EDWARD SPEARMAN DALLAS COUNTY
34,479-11 THOMAS ANDREW GOODEN HARRIS COUNTY
42,124-02 GERALD KING DALLAS COUNTY
46,232-01 DARREN EUGENE RIDING TARRANT COUNTY
48,304-03 FRANCISCO X. SOLIS CAMERON COUNTY
52,637-02 JOSE SILVINO ENRIQUEZ JOHNSON COUNTY
53,104-02 WILLIAM HENRY CORDER POTTER COUNTY
53,424-01 TAIWINDA RENNA CARTER WALKER COUNTY
53,424-02 TAIWINDA RENNA CARTER WALKER COUNTY
53,813-08 LEOPHUS JOHNSON TARRANT COUNTY
53,813-09 LEOPHUS JOHNSON TARRANT COUNTY
53,813-10 LEOPHUS JOHNSON TARRANT COUNTY
54,632-02 RONALD EDWARD JACKSON POTTER COUNTY
54,883-02 VAUGHN WADDELL HOPKINS COUNTY
54,883-03 VAUGHN WADDELL HOPKINS COUNTY
54,911-01 BILLY MIKE JONES YOUNG COUNTY
54,922-02 DERRICK TERRELL MARSHALL BELL COUNTY
55,115-01 WINDELL WARREN WATTERS HARRIS COUNTY
55,153-01 BRUCE ALLEN ARNOLD BURLESON COUNTY
55,181-01 JOHN FITZGERALD FOUNTAIN LUBBOCK COUNTY
55,199-01 DEDRIC LAVAUGHN STANLEY GREGG COUNTY
55,265-01 GEORGE WASHINGTON JR LITTLE BEXAR COUNTY
55,265-02 GEORGE WASHINGTON JR LITTLE BEXAR COUNTY
55,268-01 CRAIG JACKSON HARRIS COUNTY
55,302-01 TOBY ALLEN COLLINS MARION COUNTY
55,326-01 TROY DOUGLAS ROBERTS COLLIN COUNTY
55,326-02 TROY DOUGLAS ROBERTS COLLIN COUNTY
55,326-03 TROY DOUGLAS ROBERTS DENTON COUNTY
55,357-01 TAJDIN MODI HARRIS COUNTY
55,383-01 JACKIE VESTAL GARDNER VAN ZANDT COUNTY
55,408-01 ROBERT QUINONES EL PASO COUNTY
55,414-01 JAMES RICCARDO LIPSCOMB COLLIN COUNTY
55,419-01 JUAN ANTONIO GARCIA CAMERON COUNTY
55,437-01 CORDIS LEE GILBERT HARRIS COUNTY
55,445-01 RAUL RODRIGUEZ BELTRAN RANDALL COUNTY
55,447-01 LUTHER BERNARD DAVENPORT ECTOR COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)
15,786-03 CURTIS RAY WHITE EL PASO COUNTY
20,724-02 DAVID WOODROW SR. JONES DALLAS COUNTY
20,724-03 DAVID WOODROW SR. JONES DALLAS COUNTY
20,724-04 DAVID WOODROW SR. JONES DALLAS COUNTY
20,724-05 DAVID WOODROW SR. JONES DALLAS COUNTY
20,916-02 WILLIE JAMES FOSTER TARRANT COUNTY
22,246-02 LENNON TROY GOFFNEY HARRIS COUNTY
31,103-07 CLARENCE BROWN LUBBOCK COUNTY
33,082-03 RICHARD DEMAR ROBINSON HARRIS COUNTY
34,142-03 SCOTT JAMES ZYWICKI BELL COUNTY
39,110-03 ROY VERA BEXAR COUNTY
39,110-04 ROY VERA BEXAR COUNTY
40,218-05 ABRAHAM HICKS HARRIS COUNTY
45,320-03 HARLAND RAY BROOKS JR. DALLAS COUNTY
51,235-02 PAUL EARL SCHULTZ BRAZORIA COUNTY
52,081-03 MITCHELL DARRELL JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY
52,304-02 HENRY JR GALLON BEXAR COUNTY
53,823-02 RICHARD PAUL BARNES BEXAR COUNTY
54,061-01 DENNIS RAY FLANAGAN HARRIS COUNTY
54,081-01 NELSON L. FORD COMAL COUNTY
54,922-01 DERRICK TERRELL MARSHALL BELL COUNTY
55,012-01 JOE LEE BOWDEN HARRIS COUNTY
55,140-02 AARON KEITH MANLEY DALLAS COUNTY
55,145-01 TERRY ONEAL HUNT DALLAS COUNTY
55,146-01 ALFRED LEE GIVENS DALLAS COUNTY
55,152-02 BRIAN KEITH DUTCHOVER EL PASO COUNTY
55,178-01 RUBEN MARK CHAIREZ LUBBOCK COUNTY
55,228-01 ROCKIE EARL RASBERRY HARRIS COUNTY
55,235-01 SHAWN LEE WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY
55,270-01 MANUEL GUAJARDO KLEBERG COUNTY
55,275-01 CARL LORENZO WALKER EL PASO COUNTY
55,306-01 SAMMIE JARAMILLO BAEZA BEXAR COUNTY
55,320-01 HERBERT HASHWAY DALLAS COUNTY
55,407-01 ALEJANDRO RODRIGUEZ HARRIS COUNTY
55,418-01 VIRGIL LEE GREENWOOD HARRIS COUNTY
55,449-01 JOE A. JR. PALACIOS MCLENNAN COUNTY
55,452-01 JAMES ARTHUR SMILEY TRAVIS COUNTY
55,459-01 RAFAEL MONTES BEXAR COUNTY
55,459-02 RAFAEL MONTES BEXAR COUNTY
7,312-02 LEROY JR COLEMAN HARRIS COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
50,665-02 BRIAN LEE MCWHORTER PARKER COUNTY
55,327-01 MARTIN RUBALCABA EL PASO COUNTY
55,327-02 MARTIN RUBALCABA EL PASO COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)
43,314-02 JUAN CARLOS BOLTES HARRIS COUNTY
43,314-03 JUAN CARLOS BOLTES HARRIS COUNTY
50,219-02 GARY SALINAS NUECES COUNTY
54,965-02 DAVID RASHEED ALI LIMESTONE COUNTY
54,965-03 DAVID RASHEED ALI LIMESTONE COUNTY
54,965-04 DAVID RASHEED ALI LIMESTONE COUNTY
55,371-01 ABELARDO ARREOLA BEXAR COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)
17,675-03 RICKEY WOFFORD DALLAS COUNTY
18,129-04 BYRON ANTHONY CARR TRAVIS COUNTY
18,794-09 ISRAEL CANTU MORA TAYLOR COUNTY
28,203-04 TROY EDWARD HOLT GREGG COUNTY
31,017-02 L.T. ROBERSON HARRIS COUNTY
33,122-02 DARVIN JAMES LUCAS BOSQUE COUNTY
47,703-02 FABIAN PICAZO BEXAR COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER
(TEX. GOV'T CODE SEC. 501.0081 (b) )
15,998-07 PAUL FRANKLIN WALKER COUNTY
55,110-02 CARLOS NIETO HARRIS COUNTY
55,248-01 KENNY DEWAYNE EVINK COMAL COUNTY
55,271-01 TROY WALKER LIBERTY COUNTY
55,278-01 BOBBY JOE III MANZIEL SMITH COUNTY
55,384-01 MICHAEL BRENT RAMOS TRAVIS COUNTY
55,458-01 WILLIAM R. GIPSON VICTORIA COUNTY
55,461-01 SAMUEL VILLARREAL BEXAR COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:
47,224-04 JOE RODRIGUEZ SR CORONADO DALLAS COUNTY
50,469-02 BILLY WAYNE GENTRY TARRANT COUNTY
51,077-02 CARRELL JUNIOR CONDOR HOOD COUNTY
53,905-01 TERMAINE JONES LUBBOCK COUNTY
55,063-01 CHAD WAYNE JESTER UPSHUR COUNTY
55,073-01 RICHARD A VARGAS ECTOR COUNTY
55,121-01 RAYMUNDO SANCHEZ SOLIS MITCHELL COUNTY
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE
AND RESPONDENT IS ORDERED TO FILE ANSWER:
55,343-01 THOMAS KING GRAYSON COUNTY
55,345-01 BRIAN NOEL TARRANT COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:
35,154-02 FREDERICK STONE BOWIE COUNTY
35,154-03 FREDERICK STONE BOWIE COUNTY
37,091-02 ANTHONY CHARLES HOGAN BEXAR COUNTY
46,977-02 JOSHUA BRENT WELCH HARRIS COUNTY
54,196-01 CLEMENTINO OLMOS JR. LOPEZ DENTON COUNTY
54,846-01 HENRY LEE ANGELINA COUNTY
54,900-01 KEVIN GOODWIN BOWIE COUNTY
55,101-01 RANDALL VALENTINO GONZALES HARRIS COUNTY
55,139-01 MARTIN GUADALUPE MORENO STARR COUNTY
55,143-01 JAMES DARRELL PURVIS TRAVIS COUNTY
55,152-01 BRIAN KEITH DUTCHOVER EL PASO COUNTY
55,152-03 BRIAN KEITH DUTCHOVER EL PASO COUNTY
55,286-01 MARKOS ANTONIO MENDOZA HUTCHINSON COUNTY
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT
WRITTEN ORDER:
12,207-09 DANNY L. JONES DALLAS COUNTY
15,998-06 PAUL FRANKLIN WALKER COUNTY
21,466-08 KENNETH BERNARD GIVENS TARRANT COUNTY
26,986-15 LEO MARTINEZ LOZANO EL PASO COUNTY
28,551-04 ANTHONY JEROME FORD COUNTY
31,700-06 LOUIS EDWARD SPEARMAN DALLAS COUNTY
37,781-03 GARY CHARLES WARREN CHEROKEE COUNTY
41,267-02 MARQUIES LAQUANE JONES HUNT COUNTY
46,194-04 ROBERT F. CALDWELL SMITH COUNTY
52,081-02 MITCHELL DARRELL JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY
53,110-03 DOUGLAS WAYNE RATLIFF COLLIN COUNTY
53,905-02 TERMAINE JONES LUBBOCK COUNTY
54,755-03 GORDON C BLACK TARRANT COUNTY
54,911-02 BILLY MIKE JONES YOUNG COUNTY
55,234-01 BILLY GENE JR SUDDERTH COLLIN COUNTY
55,340-01 CISCO SALINAS GUADALUPE COUNTY
55,342-01 ROBERT PEREZ BEXAR COUNTY
55,344-01 MICHAEL MAHAN LUBBOCK COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED FOR NON-COMPLIANCE WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
19,936-13 DAVID MICHAEL STARKS DALLAS COUNTY
42,275-02 CALVIN MAURICE BRADLEY WALLER COUNTY
42,275-03 CALVIN MAURICE BRADLEY WALLER COUNTY
46,794-04 ECKZAR SALAME, JR. HOOD COUNTY
49,162-03 RALPH CARR LUBBOCK COUNTY
51,751-02 RICHARD WILLIS WATTS HARDIN COUNTY
55,216-01 ROBERT L. CLARK, JR. SMITH COUNTY
55,306-02 SAMMIE JARAMILLO BAEZA BEXAR COUNTY
55,487-01 RUDOLPH RESENDEZ HARRIS COUNTY
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE A WRIT OF CERTIORARI OR, IN THE ALTERNATIVE, FOR A WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
15,918-03 JOHNNY PAUL PENRY POLK COUNTY
STATEMENT JUDGE WOMACK
(JUDGES PRICE, JOHNSON AND COCHRAN JOINED)
NON-PUBLISHED STATEMENT