THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS



MARCH 6, 2002







THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:





73,696         BRUCE WILLIAMS FROM DALLAS COUNTY

AFFIRMED-OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION



73,826         ROBERT JEAN HUDSON FROM DALLAS COUNTY

AFFIRMED-PER CURIAM OPINION

(JUDGE JOHNSON CONCURRED IN THE JUDGMENT)

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION



74,082         EX PARTE LEON VANCE MADDING FROM UPSHUR COUNTY

RELIEF GRANTED-OPINION JUDGE COCHRAN

(PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER, JUDGES PRICE AND KEASLER CONCURRED IN THE RESULTS)

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE HOLCOMB

PUBLISHED OPINION



HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)

74,296         EX PARTE MIGUEL ANGEL MARTINEZ FROM EL PASO COUNTY

74,297         EX PARTE RICARDO PENA FROM NUECES COUNTY

74,298         EX PARTE CUTBERTO CARRENO CASTANEDA FROM DALLAS COUNTY

74,299         EX PARTE CRAIG STEPHEN ELLIS FROM MIDLAND COUNTY

74,300         EX PARTE CLARENCE SMITH FROM GUADALUPE COUNTY

74,301         EX PARTE NORRIS CAMPBELL FROM BEXAR COUNTY

74,304         EX PARTE CUTERTO CARRENO CASTANEDA FROM DALLAS COUNTY







APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING DENIED:



73,927         EX PARTE ANTHONY CHARLES GRAVES FROM BRAZORIA COUNTY

                    (JUDGE PRICE WOULD GRANT)



ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:



1660-01       ERNEST PRINCE, III HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00712-CR

APPEAL ABATED-PER CURIAM OPINION

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

ON STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:



0594-01       BOBBY ADAME HILL COUNTY 10-99-00139-CR

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

JUDGMENT OF TRIAL COURT AFFIRMED-OPINION JUDGE HERVEY

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

(JUDGE PRICE JOINED)

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

PUBLISHED OPINION



APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING ON APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DENIED:



1151-00         GRAY, RICHARD WAYNE COLLIN COUNTY 05-98-00417-CR



APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:



1718-01         RAYMOND JOSEPH ROY CAMERON COUNTY 13-00-00367-CR

                       (ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)



1808-01         DOUGLAS CHARLES GOLLIHAR HOOD COUNTY 06-98-00128-CR

                       (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)



2115-01       JOHN WATTS HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00811-CR

(GRANTED ON GROUND NOS. 2 & 3 ONLY)

(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)



STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:



1733-01         RANDY LEE DRAGOO TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00032-CR

                       (ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)



APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:



1701-01         SHELLING, ROY NEAL, JR. HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-01048-CR

1728-01         BOGANY, MICHAEL LEE HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00455-CR

1762-01         LESEC, JEAN HENRI F. HARRIS COUNTY 07-00-00310-CR

1846-01         DAVIS, LAQUITA SMITH COUNTY 12-00-00310-CR

1864-01         RODRIGUEZ, RAYMOND TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00474-CR

1952-01         HOSE, JAMES EDWARD DALLAS COUNTY 07-00-00019-CR

1955-01         HUFFMAN, JOHN ROY ECTOR COUNTY 08-98-00226-CR

1982-01         REED, BARBARA JOAN TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00144-CR

2022-01         CRUZ, DANIEL CARDONA DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-00541-CR

2023-01         CRUZ, DANIEL CARDONA DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-00542-CR

2097-01         DICKERSON, JOHN TRAVIS COUNTY 03-00-00702-CR

2103-01         TOWLES, KEITH DUANE PARKER COUNTY 02-01-00066-CR

2122-01         GUTIERREZ, DAVID M. LUBBOCK COUNTY 07-99-00212-CR

2125-01         DELGADO, GERARDO TRAVIS COUNTY 03-00-00476-CR

2143-01         BRYAN, DAVID ERATH COUNTY 11-00-00379-CR

2160-01         HAYES, SHANNON EUGENE HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-00599-CR

2170-01         SOTO, PEDRO GARCIA, JR. HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-00831-CR

2171-01         JOHNSON, ARTHUR EUGENE HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00354-CR

2173-01         NEWTON, MARCUS ANTWAN DENTON COUNTY 02-00-00463-CR

2175-01         TEEHEE, TRAVIS WAYNE TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00498-CR

2187-01         COOK, DAVID CLIFFORD DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01344-CR

2200-01         WASHINGTON, LAWRENCE TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00224-CR

2202-01         KOENIG, ANN MARIE BEXAR COUNTY 04-00-00651-CR

2245-01         SIMPSON, JOHN PAUL TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00140-CR

2248-01         FREEMAN, JOHNNY RAY COLLIN COUNTY 05-00-00680-CR

2280-01         PEREZ, GUADALUPE CAMERON COUNTY 13-01-00525-CR

2284-01         HICKS, LARRY L. DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01953-CR

2296-01         WHITE, JERRY EARL GALVESTON COUNTY 01-00-00736-CR

2308-01         OSBORNE, YON SUK DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01309-CR

2314-01         MCGEE, DENNIS EL PASO COUNTY 08-99-00386-CR

2317-01         WHITLEY, TERRY WAYNE BEXAR COUNTY 04-00-00232-CR

2318-01         WHITLEY, TERRY WAYNE BEXAR COUNTY 04-00-00233-CR

2327-01         TANKSLEY, MYRON DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01429-CR

2332-01         MEJIA, OSCAR ALFONSO HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00396-CR

2333-01         CLEMONS, TOMMY REESE HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00873-CR

2358-01         MULARI, JOHN EVERETTE TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00057-CR

2379-01         GANDY, STEVEN GLENN DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01384-CR

2424-01         EDWARDS, JASON DAVID JEFFERSON COUNTY 09-00-00306-CR

2427-01         ROBINSON, TIMOTHY DONNELL MCLENNAN COUNTY 10-99-00225-CR

2428-01         HERNANDEZ, GUADALUPE NOLAN COUNTY 11-00-00274-CR

2464-01         WADE, MARK LARUE SMITH COUNTY 12-00-00206-CR

2478-01         CHUNN, TIMIRON ARNETT DENTON COUNTY 02-00-00244-CR

2479-01         WASAFF, STEPHEN ALEXANDER HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00937-CR

2480-01         WASAFF, STEPHEN ALEXANDER HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00938-CR

2483-01         VILLARREAL, FEDERICO MARIN HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00948-CR

2485-01         CANALES, POLO, JR. LUBBOCK COUNTY 07-01-00176-CR

2499-01         RAMIREZ, JOSE ANGEL HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-01012-CR

2526-01         TURNER, JOHN ELWAYNE HALL COUNTY 07-00-00393-CR

0001-02         MOTE, ALLEN EUGENE RANDALL COUNTY 07-00-00419-CR

0002-02         STEPP, LISA MARIE NACOGDOCHES COUNTY 12-01-00264-CR

0003-02         BATES, ARTHUR FREEMAN HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-00487-CR

0004-02         GONZALES, ARTHUR HARRIS COUNTY 01-95-00795-CR

0037-02         FERGUSON, RONALD EDWARD HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-00848-CR

0046-02         CORMIER, DAVID LEE HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-00846-CR

0104-02         STRANGE, NAKIA SHARNETTE DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01832-CR

0113-02         RAMIREZ, GERARDO DEAF SMITH COUNTY 07-01-00065-CR

0136-02         OLIVER, THURMAN RAY (#1) WICHITA COUNTY 02-01-00001-CR

0154-02         OMALLY, JASON TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00517-CR

0155-02         OMALLY, JASON TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00518-CR

0159-02         GARCIA, JESUS "JESSE" MANUEL LUBBOCK COUNTY 07-01-00015-CR

0231-02         CALIXTO, SILVESTRE MARTINEZ TRAVIS COUNTY 03-01-00016-CR

0234-02         DOWNIE, MARCUS NUECES COUNTY 13-00-00488-CR

0235-02         O'QUINN, TIMOTHY DALLAS COUNTY 05-99-00851-CR

0236-02         RESENDIZ, JAIME ENRIQUE TARRANT COUNTY 11-98-00133-CR

 

 

STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

 

 

1619-01         DANIELS, JAVON DAMONTE HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00198-CR

1702-01         WINCOTT, ROBERT WILLIAMSON COUNTY 03-00-00418-CR

2222-01         MCQUARTERS, DANNY LEE DENTON COUNTY 02-00-00198-CR

2367-01         FRANCIS, JOSEPH CLAYTON TARRANT COUNTY 02-97-00068-CR

0136-02         OLIVER, THURMAN RAY (#2) WICHITA COUNTY 02-01-00001-CR

 

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DISMISSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:



0294-02         GRANADOS, HENRY SAMIR DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-00099-CR

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:



16,092-05         BILAL MUHAMMAD ALI BEXAR COUNTY

20,154-03         GUADALUPE MORENO BARAJAS WALKER COUNTY

41,497-02         JIMMY JARRELL ANDERSON COUNTY

46,209-02         MYRON KIRK HENDERSON HARRIS COUNTY

46,209-03         MYRON KIRK HENDERSON HARRIS COUNTY

46,209-04         MYRON KIRK HENDERSON HARRIS COUNTY

48,813-02         CHON PATRICK DIMAS POLK COUNTY

50,029-02         BILLY WAYNE LEWIS BELL COUNTY

50,390-02         EDWARD B, LYONS BOWIE COUNTY

51,053-01         THOMAS LUKE HIGGINS COLLIN COUNTY

51,140-01         WILLIAM FREDDIE BOOKER LAMAR COUNTY

51,216-01         ALEJANDRO AYALA JR. HARRIS COUNTY

51,229-01         LESLIE EUGENE SUMMITT TARRANT COUNTY

51,342-01         BERL O'DELL ALLBRIGHT TARRANT COUNTY

51,363-01         DEJUAN EDWARD OWENS DALLAS COUNTY

51,390-02         EDWARD B. LYON, JR. BOWIE COUNTY

51,404-01         JOHNNY R. MARTINEZ HARRIS COUNTY

51,433-01         RICHARD PENA BEE COUNTY

51,433-02         RICHARD PENA BEE COUNTY

51,522-01         KATHLYN SHELTON DALLAS COUNTY

51,523-01         MARCELLIUS POWELL TARRANT COUNTY

51,538-01         SHELBY LUTHER MANN HALE COUNTY

51,610-01         JOSEPH LOCKHART TARRANT COUNTY

51,623-01         CINDY LEE BISHOP TARRANT COUNTY

51,623-02         CINDY LEE BISHOP TARRANT COUNTY

51,635-01         CHRISTOPHER DON MATTHEWS DALLAS COUNTY

51,635-02         CHRISTOPHER DON MATTHEWS DALLAS COUNTY

51,635-03         CHRISTOPHER DON MATTHEWS DALLAS COUNTY

51,635-04         CHRISTOPHER DON MATTHEWS DALLAS COUNTY

51,663-01         MATEO VALLES MARTIN COUNTY

51,666-01         ROBERT LOUIS HOYLE JR., JEFFERSON COUNTY

51,671-01         DENNY LEE COLBURN BRAZOS COUNTY

51,692-01         MITCHELL T. SHELTON NUECES COUNTY

51,692-02         MITCHELL T. SHELTON NUECES COUNTY

51,701-01         ERNESTO JR. GONZALES TERRY COUNTY

51,702-01         THOMAS LESLIE BARTH DENTON COUNTY

51,706-01         LARKUS D. MILLS TARRANT COUNTY

51,756-01         TERRY LEON RANDLE HARRIS COUNTY

51,815-01         EMANUEL VASQUEZ MURRAY HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)

 

 

28,025-03         BOBBY JOE MURPHY COLLIN COUNTY

30,442-02         ALFONSO PINA NUECES COUNTY

31,061-04         FLOYD WILLIS WILEY HARRIS COUNTY

37,441-03         GREGORY DONNELL COLEMAN NAVARRO COUNTY

39,902-02         IRVING MADARIS SHAW WILLIAMSON COUNTY

45,356-02         ANTHONY GERARD THORPE EL PASO COUNTY

48,770-02         WILLIAM RANDOLPH SCHNIZER MCLENNAN COUNTY

49,108-02         BOBBY W. BULLOCK HARRIS COUNTY

51,007-01         CONRAD VICTOR DESOUZA BELL COUNTY

51,007-02         CONRAD VICTOR DESOUZA BELL COUNTY

51,127-01         FELIX MARIA GENAO HARRIS COUNTY

51,310-01         JUAN SALVADOR TORRES WILLIAMSON COUNTY

51,351-01         RONNIE EUGENE WATSON GRAYSON COUNTY

51,396-01         BRYAN NEAL SEYMOUR HARRIS COUNTY

51,415-01         JESSE WILLARD ROBINSON GREGG COUNTY

51,420-01         JAMES EDWARD SIMMONS SMITH COUNTY

51,435-01         ALLEN JEFFERY SAPENTER BEXAR COUNTY

51,501-01         JASON FROELICH HARRIS COUNTY

51,514-01         VINCENT P. MACRI JR. BEXAR COUNTY

51,564-01         SHELDON DESHONE BROWN DALLAS COUNTY

51,656-01         JOE JR. BANDA ELLIS COUNTY

51,665-01         ROGER ESPARZA BEXAR COUNTY

51,669-01         RAY RAYMOND VALDEZ BEXAR COUNTY

51,707-01         LONNIE CHARLES PUNCH JR. HARRIS COUNTY

51,780-01         ROBIN LYNN COOPER HARRIS COUNTY

51,800-01         DAVID GALAN HARRIS COUNTY



APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

 

 

51,313-01         CHRISTOPHER SHAWN LOGAN HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

 

 

43,990-03         BOBBY JOE JACKSON TAYLOR COUNTY

47,652-03         WILLIAM SCHULTZ BEXAR COUNTY

51,266-02         ENRIQUE JACQUEZ EL PASO COUNTY

51,626-01         IVAN WILLIAM ENSMINGER COOKE COUNTY

51,729-01         STEPHANIE ANDREWS HARRIS COUNTY

51,802-01         DANA LEA DAVIS HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)

 

51,457-01         JOHN EDWARD MAPP, JR. HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)

 

 

24,990-04         ABDUL HAKEEM MUHAMMAD HARRIS COUNTY

37,582-07         ROLAND VALLE BEXAR COUNTY

38,370-04         JUAN ERNESTO CASTRO BEXAR COUNTY

41,198-02         JESUS LINERES MARTINEZ DALLAS COUNTY

41,198-03         JESUS LINERES MARTINEZ DALLAS COUNTY

46,663-02         RONALD EUGENE WILKINSON TARRANT COUNTY

49,259-02         VERNON E. LAMB DALLAS COUNTY

49,337-02         WILLIAM PAUL OWEN BEXAR COUNTY

50,386-05         KEVIN KELLY THOMAS-WRIGHT COLLIN COUNTY

50,386-06         KEVIN KELLY THOMAS-WRIGHT COLLIN COUNTY

50,386-07         KEVIN KELLY THOMAS-WRIGHT COLLIN COUNTY

50,386-08         KEVIN KELLY THOMAS-WRIGHT COLLIN COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER

(TEX. GOV'T CODE SEC. 501.0081 (b) )

 

16,520-06         KENNETH WAYNE WATSON DALLAS COUNTY

23,722-02         MARK JAMES MCKEE DALLAS COUNTY

49,825-02         TREA SHONNE HAYNES BRAZOS COUNTY

49,825-03         TREA SHONNE HAYNES BRAZOS COUNTY

51,259-01         DAVID KELLY TRAVIS COUNTY

51,369-01         ERNEST GOMEZ TRAVIS COUNTY

51,480-01         REGINALD EUGENE DEMPS TRAVIS COUNTY

51,545-01         ROBERT JOHN KRISTOF ATASCOSA COUNTY

51,556-01         VAN HAWKINS SMITH COUNTY

51,572-01         ALTON MICHAEL LOOSIER NAVARRO COUNTY

51,584-01         CLAYTON ALVIN KETCHERSIDE ELLIS COUNTY

51,596-01         PATRICK RYAN DOYLE BEXAR COUNTY

51,673-01         JOSE ARGUELLES CAVAZOS HARRIS COUNTY

51,763-01         JAMES CORNELIUS ALLEN HALE COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:

 

 

51,336-01         DAVID GONZALES TRAVIS COUNTY

51,517-01         CRYSTAL LYNN MARCUM POLK COUNTY

51,547-01         CARLENE COLEMAN WILLIS HALE COUNTY

51,629-01         THOMAS ALLEN HARRIS FANNIN COUNTY

 

 

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE

AND RESPONDENT IS ORDERED TO FILE ANSWER:

 

 

27,467-06         WILBERT CECIL JOHNSON DALLAS COUNTY

42,023-02         RUBEN MARTINEZ RAMOS HARRIS COUNTY

44,454-02         VERNIE WANE MCDANIEL DALLAS COUNTY

45,181-01         RITCHIE DION WARREN CHEROKEE COUNTY

48,424-03         FERDINAND COOK JR. DALLAS COUNTY

49,467-03         GUS WASHINGTON JR. HARRIS COUNTY

51,450-01         TERRY BLANKENSHIP HUDSPETH COUNTY

51,715-01         DAVID URIBE TRAVIS COUNTY

51,723-01         OSCAR DORIA HAYS COUNTY

9,241-02         VIRTIS GIBSON DAWSON COUNTY

 

 

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT

WRITTEN ORDER:

 

 

31,322-04         MILTON LEE PATTERSON FANNIN COUNTY

36,290-03         JERRARD J. MCGARY BOWIE COUNTY

48,560-03         EDUARDO TREVINO BEXAR COUNTY

49,113-03         HEATH PRICE LIMESTONE COUNTY

50,390-01         ROBERTO GONZALEZ JR. CAMERON COUNTY

51,636-01         JOHN WAYNE CHARLESTON CASS COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:

 

 

29,240-04         CRAIG STEPHEN ELLIS MIDLAND COUNTY

33,606-02         MIGUEL ANGEL MARTINEZ EL PASO COUNTY

50,163-01         RICARDO PENA NUECES COUNTY

50,538-01         NORRIS CAMPBELL BEXAR COUNTY

51,326-01         CUTBERTO CARRENO CASTANEDA DALLAS COUNTY

51,326-02         CUTBERTO CARRENO CASTANEDA DALLAS COUNTY

51,550-01         CLARENCE SMITH GUADALUPE COUNTY

 

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

 

 

49,984-01         CATHY LYNN HENDERSON TRAVIS COUNTY

50,823-01         KENNETH EUGENE FOSTER, JR. BEXAR COUNTY

                          (JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)

50,825-01         DAVID MARTINEZ TRAVIS COUNTY

51,612-01         VIRGILIO R. MALDONADO HARRIS COUNTY



ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:



50,360-01         KIMBERLY LAGAYLE MCCARTHY DALLAS COUNTY

                         (JUDGE KEASLER NOT PARTICIPATING)