THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS
MARCH 5, 2003
THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:
HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)
74,583 EX PARTE WILLIAM ALBERT FOSTER, III FROM BELL COUNTY
74,584 EX PARTE WILLIAM ALBERT FOSTER III FROM BELL COUNTY
74,585 EX PARTE ROBERT HINOJOS FROM EL PASO COUNTY
APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING DENIED:
74,528 EX PARTE DONALD JOSEPH WEST FROM RANDALL COUNTY
74,544 EX PARTE ROGER DALE SPENCER FROM DENTON COUNTY
STATE’S MOTION FOR REHEARING DENIED:
74,548 EX PARTE JOSEPH DANIEL LAVENDER, JR. FROM COMANCHE COUNTY
APPELLANT’S MOTION FOR REHEARING ON APPELLANT’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DENIED:
1659-02 SAFETY NAT. CASUALTY CORP. EL PASO COUNTY 08-01-00323-CV
1747-02 MOTLEY, JON DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-00721-CR
1985-02 RUSSELL, STEVEN L. WALKER COUNTY 04-00-00638-CR
APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:
1691-02 GARZA, PETER ZAPATA HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-00625-CR
(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
1786-02 PARFAIT, HAL VERNON BRAZOS COUNTY 01-01-00473-CR
(GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 1 ONLY)
(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
1901-02 COSTILLA, EUSEBIO S. MONTGOMERY COUNTY 09-01-00132-CR
(GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 1 ONLY)
(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PEMITTED)
2011-02 CHAPMAN, PHILLIP ARTHUR DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-00585-CR
(GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 1 ONLY)
(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
2012-02 CHAPMAN, PHILLIP ARTHUR DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-00611-CR
(GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 1 ONLY)
(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:
1592-02 HOLLEN, GARY DON HOOD COUNTY 02-00-00157-CR
(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:
1324-02 JOHNSON, JAMES EARL DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-00295-CR
(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)
1325-02 JOHNSON, JAMES EARL DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-00296-CR
(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)
1326-02 JOHNSON, JAMES EARL DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-00297-CR
(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)
1527-02 TINCH, RODNEY WALTER COLLIN COUNTY 11-00-00242-CR
1528-02 BROWN, ROBERT ANTHONY DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01910-CR
1533-02 STRNAD, DAVID DANA HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-00387-CR
1556-02 DYER, RONALD COLUMBUS HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-00958-CR
1721-02 ANTHONY, MARK HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-01190-CR
1762-02 THETFORD, DONALD RAY TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00164-CR
1764-02 DALE, WILLIE CLARENCE BEXAR COUNTY 04-01-00475-CR
1765-02 KRUG, GARY STEVEN CROCKETT COUNTY 08-01-00210-CR
(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)
1770-02 DEAN, PATRICK LAMONT DALLAS COUNTY 11-01-00326-CR
1771-02 DEAN, PATRICK LAMONT DALLAS COUNTY 11-01-00327-CR
1772-02 DEAN, PATRICK LAMONT DALLAS COUNTY 11-01-00328-CR
1784-02 PURCHASE, SAMUEL REBEN HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00410-CR
1797-02 NURNBERG, MICHELLE ROSE TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00306-CR
1802-02 PERRY, WILLIAM KEEN HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00126-CR
1855-02 POTEET, ROWDY B. DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-00556-CR
1856-02 LUKE, DONALD EARL DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-00322-CR
1864-02 GARZA, MIKE CRUZ LAMPASAS COUNTY 03-01-00423-CR
(JUDGE MEYERS AND COCHRAN WOULD GRANT)
1865-02 GARZA, MIKE CRUZ LAMPASAS COUNTY 03-01-00424-CR
(JUDGES MEYERS AND COCHRAN WOULD GRANT)
1868-02 CEPHUS, TERRANCE RAY SHUN TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00251-CR
1889-02 THOUVENAL, KEVIN ALTON PARKER COUNTY 02-01-00425-CR
1900-02 CARRERA, CHRISTOPHER CAMERON COUNTY 13-00-00723-CR
(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)
1904-02 FLOWERS, PAUL MARTIN DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01523-CR
1939-02 DIAZ, JESUS MANUEL HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01217-CR
1943-02 HARDCASTLE, PHILLIP PAUL DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01009-CR
1944-02 HARDCASTLE, PHILLIP PAUL DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01010-CR
1945-02 HARDCASTLE, PHILLIP PAUL DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01011-CR
1946-02 HARDCASTLE, PHILLIP PAUL DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01012-CR
1963-02 LOPEZ, LEROY PARRA ECTOR COUNTY 08-00-00536-CR
1964-02 RENTERIA, DAVID SANTIAGO EL PASO COUNTY 08-02-00072-CR
1968-02 DE LA FUENTE, JOSE CAMERON COUNTY 13-00-00444-CR
1970-02 SEALE, ODIE GUINN, SR. TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00099-CR
1971-02 WILSON, DEDRIC DEMOND TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00398-CR
1996-02 RIVERS, DEDRICK EUGENE ECTOR COUNTY 08-00-00544-CR
1998-02 HAWKS, KEITH NORMAN COLLIN COUNTY 05-01-01880-CR
2001-02 FLOWERS, DAVID WAYNE DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01264-CR
2015-02 NEILL, JOHN FRANKLIN TRAVIS COUNTY 03-01-00123-CR
2020-02 STOUT, PAULA D. MCLENNAN COUNTY 10-02-00205-CR
2027-02 STEGMAN, DENNIS WARREN DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01183-CR
2028-02 FREEMAN, RUSSELL DALLAS COUNTY 11-01-00113-CR
2042-02 BAILEY, ROBERT ALVIN COLLIN COUNTY 05-01-01883-CR
2047-02 MAKINTUBEE, RAYMOND DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-00732-CR
2048-02 MAKINTUBEE, MAGDA DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-00733-CR
2050-02 MURPHY, LIONEL D. JR. TARRANT COUNTY 03-02-00171-CR
2078-02 OVERMAN, BOB SMITH COUNTY 12-01-00054-CR
2084-02 TAVERNINI, ROBERT DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01665-CR
2167-02 LEVAN, CHARLES LEE JR. PALO PINTO COUNTY 11-01-00219-CR
2203-02 HUNTER, KATHLEEN DIANE HAMILTON COUNTY 10-01-00407-CR
2225-02 ELLIS, FRANK MARTIN HARRIS COUNTY 10-01-00260-CR
2229-02 MONTGOMERY, GUY NELSON PALO PINTO COUNTY 11-00-00395-CR
2230-02 MONTGOMERY, GUY NELSON PALO PINTO COUNTY 11-00-00396-CR
0001-03 READ, RONALD DALE MONTAGUE COUNTY 02-00-00429-CR
0004-03 ROBERTS, DONOVAN CHEVILIAR HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-00799-CR
0048-03 HARRELL, TOMMY EARL, JR. GREGG COUNTY 12-00-00356-CR
0050-03 HUDSON, RONNIE DALE HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-01153-CR
0052-03 MATHEWS, DENNIE ROBERT WICHITA COUNTY 02-02-00016-CR
0053-03 ROJAS, DANIEL TARRANT COUNTY 02-02-00011-CR
0060-03 THOMAS, NORMAN ANGELINA COUNTY 09-02-00171-CR
0061-03 GREEN, GEORGE EDWARD TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00082-CR
0063-03 MCDOWELL, DAVID WAYNE COLLIN COUNTY 05-02-00542-CR
0073-03 JORDAN, MELVIN HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-01049-CR
0099-03 DOAK, BOBBY CHARLES DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01318-CR
0192-03 GRAVES, RICKIE LYNN FORT BEND COUNTY 07-02-00177-CR
0197-03 MILLS, JOSEPH BRYANT HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-00840-CR
0198-03 MILLS, JOSEPH BRYANT HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-00841-CR
0199-03 GUTIERREZ, JUAN LUIS HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-00991-CR
0200-03 GUTIERREZ, JUAN LUIS HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-00992-CR
STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:
1900-02 CARRERA, CHRISTOPHER CAMERON COUNTY 13-00-00723-CR
(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)
2013-02 STRONG, DONNA BENITA COLLIN COUNTY 05-01-00788-CR
APPELLANT’S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW STRUCK FOR NON-COMPLIANCE WITH WRITTEN ORDER:
1863-02 MARSHALL, CHARLES BEXAR COUNTY 04-01-00376-CR
1993-02 CASTANEDA, SERVANDO CESAR HIDALGO COUNTY 13-01-00144-CR
1999-02 DANIELS, JARRYL BERNARD DALLAS COUNTY 05-02-00254-CR
2069-02 MULLEN, LARRY WAYNE JR. JOHNSON COUNTY 10-01-00303-CR
2082-02 SELTZ, PETER RUDOLPH DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01339-CR
2092-02 THOMAS, DERRELL MONTEZ DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01234-CR
2093-02 THOMAS, DERRELL MONTEZ DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01235-CR
0054-03 TORRES, GABRIEL G. LUBBOCK COUNTY 07-01-00401-CR
0207-03 CARTER, JACK CLIFFORD TRAVIS COUNTY 03-01-00669-CR
PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER, JUDGES KEASLER AND HERVEY DISSENT TO THE ABOVE ORDERS:
APPELLANT’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DISMISSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:
0012-03 ROGERS, ANTHONY JAMES HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-0950-CR
0013-03 ROGERS, ANTHONY JAMES HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-0951-CR
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
12,114-06 KEVIN MICHAEL CAY HARRIS COUNTY
23,534-03 CARL LYNN JOHNSON GREGG COUNTY
26,937-03 STEVEN WAYNE SIMS DENTON COUNTY
41,326-03 GARY WAYNE CRAWFORD WASHINGTON COUNTY
51,585-02 BRIAN KEITH KINNEY CASS COUNTY
51,636-04 JOHN WAYNE CHARLESTON CASS COUNTY
54,639-01 TOMMY LEE BAGSBY DALLAS COUNTY
54,655-01 RICARDO JALOMO LOPEZ HALE COUNTY
54,767-01 ROBERT LEE TAYLOR RUSK COUNTY
54,770-01 MARVIN CHAMPION DALLAS COUNTY
54,808-01 NATHAN WAYNE GIBSON CAMERON COUNTY
54,851-02 ROY DURON HILL COUNTY
54,875-01 PAUL GARNER HAVENS DALLAS COUNTY
54,908-01 BRYAN DEAN HOSKINS GRAYSON COUNTY
54,992-01 JAMES O'NEAL LEWIS HOUSTON COUNTY
55,000-01 DONNA HELENE HIGHTOWER GRAYSON COUNTY
55,010-01 JIMMY ALLEN MCDANIEL HARRIS COUNTY
55,010-02 JIMMY ALLEN MCDANIEL HARRIS COUNTY
55,020-01 AUGUSTINE TORRES LUBBOCK COUNTY
55,053-01 ALLEN JAMES JR ROBINSON HARRIS COUNTY
55,074-01 RODERICK TROVEY DAVIS JEFFERSON COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)
47,981-02 TOMMY LOGAN TRAVIS COUNTY
5,261-05 MARSHALL W. BARNES TARRANT COUNTY
51,528-02 ANTHONY KELLEY SMITH COUNTY
53,070-02 SOTIRIOS BIRIS BEXAR COUNTY
54,633-01 ANANIAS DIXON HARRIS COUNTY
54,821-01 ALBERT LAWRENCE WOOLRIDGE HARRIS COUNTY
54,849-01 VALLON ROBERT ENGLAND BELL COUNTY
54,864-01 SHANNON WASHINGTON BEXAR COUNTY
54,979-02 DALDREN MILTON FAIN DALLAS COUNTY
54,982-05 GREGORY LYNN HENDERSON DALLAS COUNTY
55,031-01 DANIEL BRUCE GARRETT SMITH COUNTY
55,034-01 HAL THOMAS CRUNDWELL MONTGOMERY COUNTY
55,122-01 MARTIN DUANE SPILLERS TARRANT COUNTY
55,135-01 WILBERT LEE JR WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITH HEARING)
53,238-01 JUDY MAY ARNOLD BURLESON COUNTY
53,255-01 RODNEY MONDELL BAULKMAN SMITH COUNTY
53,537-02 WILLIAM III JENKINS DALLAS COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
43,833-02 GEORGE E. MOORE EL PASO COUNTY
54,547-02 WILLIAM ALBERT III FOSTER BELL COUNTY
54,547-04 WILLIAM ALBERT III FOSTER BELL COUNTY
54,599-01 JESUS CEDILLO TRAVIS COUNTY
54,801-01 TIDREAUX ALLEN BRANTLEY HARRIS COUNTY
55,166-01 DONALD KEITH EMICH ELLIS COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)
54,644-01 HOWARD KENNETH II DERMODY BELL COUNTY
54,943-01 TRACY GEORGE STEELE HILL COUNTY
54,956-02 MICHAEL R MINTON ORANGE COUNTY
55,031-02 DANIEL BRUCE GARRETT SMITH COUNTY
55,068-01 PATRICK TYSONNE WARE WICHITA COUNTY
55,118-01 JOSEPH ANTHONY WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)
20,890-06 RODNEY LADALE TURNER DALLAS COUNTY
20,890-07 RODNEY LADALE TURNER DALLAS COUNTY
20,890-08 RODNEY LADALE TURNER DALLAS COUNTY
20,890-09 RODNEY LADALE TURNER DALLAS COUNTY
20,890-10 RODNEY LADALE TURNER DALLAS COUNTY
20,890-11 RODNEY LADALE TURNER DALLAS COUNTY
20,890-12 RODNEY LADALE TURNER DALLAS COUNTY
20,890-13 RODNEY LADALE TURNER DALLAS COUNTY
20,890-14 RODNEY LADALE TURNER DALLAS COUNTY
20,890-15 RODNEY LADALE TURNER DALLAS COUNTY
20,890-16 RODNEY LADALE TURNER DALLAS COUNTY
21,165-04 JOHN F BASS BEXAR COUNTY
23,534-04 CARL LYNN JOHNSON GREGG COUNTY
23,847-07 ANTHONY WASHINGTON HARRIS COUNTY
27,046-02 ROY GARZA COLLIN COUNTY
27,046-03 ROY GARZA COLLIN COUNTY
28,002-10 FREDERICK LOUIS PUGH HARRIS COUNTY
51,996-03 JOSE LOPEZ VILLARREAL BRAZORIA COUNTY
51,996-04 JOSE LOPEZ VILLARREAL BRAZORIA COUNTY
54,044-02 C.L. NANTAMBU' TARRANT COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER
(TEX. GOV'T CODE SEC. 501.0081 (b) )
14,965-04 WILLIAM CHARLES COOPER HARRIS COUNTY
27,887-05 DAVID J. II ADAMS SMITH COUNTY
28,237-04 RONALD LEE HOGAN HARRIS COUNTY
32,271-03 RONALD LYNN WADE TARRANT COUNTY
38,795-02 DAVID JOSEPH MORRISON HARRIS COUNTY
44,463-02 EDUARDO T. TORRES TARRANT COUNTY
5,919-06 CHARLES ANTHONY WATSON EL PASO COUNTY
54,124-01 SYDNEY RANALDO ROYAL CAMP COUNTY
54,146-02 JOHN TODD VANDERHORST HOOD COUNTY
54,792-01 JACK JOSEPH BYARS HAYS COUNTY
55,051-01 GARY LEE SCOTT HOOD COUNTY
55,085-01 RODNEY EUGENE GAMBLE BURLESON COUNTY
55,110-01 CARLOS NIETO HARRIS COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:
53,555-02 JOHN WARD BLAIR DALLAS COUNTY
54,686-01 UBALDO JR. DIAZ STARR COUNTY
54,817-01 JOHN FITZGERALD RICE JEFFERSON COUNTY
54,891-01 JESUS GARCIA GONZALES HAYS COUNTY
54,917-01 GEORGE THOMAS WHITE BRAZORIA COUNTY
54,924-01 JOHN JOSEPH MINCEFF ORANGE COUNTY
54,979-01 DALDREN MILTON FAIN DALLAS COUNTY
55,030-01 JUAN MIGUEL SUAREZ FORT BEND COUNTY
55,032-01 JAMES ANDREW JR JENKINS COLLIN COUNTY
55,043-01 WILLIAM BRIAN FENNELL DALLAS COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:
38,805-04 THOMAS MATTHEW JR. NEVEU FORT BEND COUNTY
54,547-01 WILLIAM ALBERT III FOSTER BELL COUNTY
54,547-03 WILLIAM ALBERT III FOSTER BELL COUNTY
54,774-01 ROBERT HINOJOS EL PASO COUNTY
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE
AND RESPONDENT IS ORDERED TO FILE ANSWER:
54,931-01 RANDALL HASTY CHEROKEE COUNTY
55,029-01 THOMAS MITCHEL JONES GALVESTON COUNTY
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT
WRITTEN ORDER:
23,534-02 CARL LYNN JOHNSON GREGG COUNTY
40,425-03 BOBBY RAY WILLIAMS DALLAS COUNTY
52,260-03 HUBERT WARREN COUNTY
53,222-02 RONALD DENNIS MANDEVILLE DALLAS COUNTY
53,868-02 CEDRIC HOOD DALLAS COUNTY
53,884-01 DWIGHT ERIC CRAYTON TRAVIS COUNTY
54,634-04 DWIGHT DEWAYNE MCKNIGHT HOUSTON COUNTY
54,956-01 MICHAEL R MINTON ORANGE COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS STRUCK FOR NON-COMPLIANCE WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
40,169-03 LORENZO LEWIS TRAVIS COUNTY
53,947-02 BRIAN A. HOUGH RUNNELS COUNTY
54,759-03 JAMES ALEXANDER STUART TARRANT COUNTY
55,065-01 MICHAEL JOHN MCREYNOLDS ORANGE COUNTY
55,098-01 CARL GUERRA MCLENNAN COUNTY
55,128-01 ADOLPHUS JIM CARROLL, JR. MCLENNAN COUNTY
55,128-02 ADOLPHUS JIM CARROLL, JR. MCLENNAN COUNTY
55,158-01 ALBERTO JOEL GARCIA HARRIS COUNTY
ARTICLE 11/071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:
54,489-01 PATRICK HORN SMITH COUNTY
54,762-01 GEORGE H. WHITAKER, III HARRIS COUNTY
ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:
54,762-02 GEORGE H. WHITAKER, III HARRIS COUNTY