THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS
FEBRUARY 12, 2003
THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:
74,025 ROBERT WAYNE HARRIS FROM DALLAS COUNTY
AFFIRMED–OPINION JUDGE HOLCOMB
NON-PUBLISHED OPINION
74,515 THE STATE OF TEXAS EX REL. CHARLES A. ROSENTHAL, JR., DISTRICT ATTORNEY
V. HONORABLE TED POE, JUDGE 228TH DISTRICT COURT OF HARRIS COUNTY
MANDAMUS RELIEF GRANTED–OPINION JUDGE HERVEY
(JUDGE MEYERS DISSENTS)
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE PRICE
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE COCHRAN
DISSENTING OPINION PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER
DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE KEASLER
PUBLISHED OPINION
39,062-01 EX PARTE LEONARD URESTI ROJAS FROM JOHNSON COUNTY
DISSENTING STATEMENT–JUDGE PRICE
(JUDGES JOHNSON AND HOLCOMB JOINED)
CONCURRING OPINION–PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER
(JUDGES KEASLER AND COCHRAN JOINED)
NON-PUBLISHED STATEMENT AND OPINION
HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)
74,565 EX PARTE RICHARD SHANE EMBRY FROM GREGG COUNTY
74,566 EX PARTE GERALD HOWE FROM BOWIE COUNTY
74,567 EX PARTE SIXTO ABINA FERNANDEZ FROM WISE COUNTY
74,568 EX PARTE BILLY DALE BOND FROM KERR COUNTY
74,569 EX PARTE QUINTON JERMAINE WILSON FROM HARRIS COUNTY
74,570 EX PARTE SHIRLEY ADAMS FROM JEFFERSON COUNTY
74,571 EX PARTE DARRELL POLLOCK FROM THROCKMORTON COUNTY
74,572 EX PARTE IGNACIO RODRIGUEZ FROM WEBB COUNTY
74,573 EX PARTE GEORGE L. HARTLEY FROM TARRANT COUNTY
ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:
0592-01 DENISE RITA SIPPLE HARRIS COUNTY 10-00-00233-CR
APPELLANT’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED;
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;
CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS–PER CURIAM OPINION
PUBLISHED OPINION
2475-01 HENRY BROWN SMITH COUNTY 12-00-00145-CR
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;
CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS–OPINION HERVEY
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS
(JUDGE COCHRAN JOINED)
PUBLISHED OPINION
0400-02 LINDSAY M. FAISST SMITH COUNTY 12-00-00289-CR
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;
CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS–OPINION PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER
PUBLISHED OPINION
ON STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:
0185-02 CHRISTINA MARTINEZ SMITH COUNTY 12-00-00246-CR
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;
CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS–OPINION JUDGE KEASLER
PUBLISHED OPINION
APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:
1647-02 COLLIER, BILLY EUGENE HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-0609-CR
(GRANTED ON GROUND NOS. 1 & 2 ONLY)
(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
1704-01 WILLIS, DAMIAN DEMARCUS HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-01087-CR
(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:
1539-02 SHAW, JAMES WILLIAM WALLER COUNTY 06-01-00130-CR
(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
1742-02 SANDERS, MICHAEL SMITH COUNTY 12-01-00255-CR
(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
1991-02 HAMILTON, CINDY L. COLLIN COUNTY 05-00-01849-CR
(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:
0821-02 SANTOS, LUCIO DE LOS BEXAR COUNTY 04-96-00998-CR
(JUDGE JOHNSON WOULD GRANT)
(JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)
1151-02 DELROSARIO, DENNIS VALDIVIA HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-00477-CR
1173-02 ALLEN II, RUSSELL STEPHEN HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-01078-CR
1174-02 ALLEN II, RUSSELL STEPHEN HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-01079-CR
1280-02 VILLARREAL, CELESTINO NUECES COUNTY 13-01-00100-CR
1300-02 KUGLEY, KEVIN BROOK HARRIS COUNTY 13-99-00254-CR
1363-02 MAXWELL, JODY MARTIN TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00295-CR
1364-02 MAXWELL, JODY MARTIN TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00296-CR
1562-02 LEWIS, BILLY WAYNE BELL COUNTY 03-01-00512-CR
1736-02 BREWER III, S. L. HAMILTON COUNTY 10-02-00012-CR
1740-02 CARPENTER, CHRISTOPHER NUECES COUNTY 13-01-00816-CR
1799-02 LEWIS, FRANK ALEXANDER TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00120-CR
1854-02 BENNETT, GARY DEWAYNE DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01056-CR
1909-02 VASQUEZ, LUCAS GOMEZ BEXAR COUNTY 04-01-00419-CR
1911-02 MILLER, BARRY BENTLEY BELL COUNTY 03-01-00513-CR
1921-02 ATKINSON III, WILLIAM P. DENTON COUNTY 02-01-00409-CR
1947-02 COOPER, STANLEY EARL DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01823-CR
1948-02 COOPER, STANLEY EARL DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01824-CR
1949-02 COOPER, STANLEY EARL DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01825-CR
2021-02 GONZALEZ, RAFAEL G. TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00405-CR
2060-02 CROWLEY, FRANK D. BELL COUNTY 03-02-00153-CR
2061-02 SANCHEZ, RAYMON CARRASCO MIDLAND COUNTY 08-01-00491-CR
2107-02 RANDLE, JEFFREY LEANTE HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-01090-CR
2108-02 HURST, SHAWN ALAN PALO PINTO COUNTY 11-01-00400-CR
2110-02 DIGBIE, SIDNEY ROBOTUS EL PASO COUNTY 08-01-00066-CR
2111-02 ROGERS, DARREN KEITH COLLIN COUNTY 05-01-01173-CR
2112-02 ROGERS, DARREN KEITH COLLIN COUNTY 05-01-01174-CR
2113-02 ROGERS, DARREN KEITH COLLIN COUNTY 05-01-01175-CR
0008-03 LOPEZ II, JOHN DAVID PALO PINTO COUNTY 11-02-00012-CR
0057-03 MURRAY, GRANT A. COLLIN COUNTY 05-02-00051-CR
0058-03 MURRAY, GRANT A. COLLIN COUNTY 05-02-00052-CR
STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:
1353-01 HUGHES, RODERICK POWER ECTOR COUNTY 08-99-00472-CR
1678-02 ROBERSON, STANLEY BRUCE CHAMBERS COUNTY 01-00-01420-CR
1924-02 HALL, CHRISTOPHER TOM GREEN COUNTY 03-01-00088-CR
(PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER WOULD GRANT)
1934-02 BINGHAM, DOROTHY CHEROKEE COUNTY 12-00-00242-CR
2063-02 QUISENBERRY, GEORGE THOMAS BRAZOS COUNTY 10-01-00066-CR
APPELLEE’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:
2051-02 PYBURN, BRADY YVONNE BELL COUNTY 03-02-00269-CR
(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)
APPELLANT’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DISMISSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:
0216-03 MCLAIN, JOHN STEVEN JEFFERSON COUNTY 07-02-00290-CR
0217-03 MCLAIN, JOHN STEVEN JEFFERSON COUNTY 07-02-00291-CR
0218-03 MCLAIN, JOHN STEVEN JEFFERSON COUNTY 07-02-00292-CR
0219-03 MCLAIN, JOHN STEVEN JEFFERSON COUNTY 07-02-00293-CR
APPELLANT’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW STRUCK FOR NON-COMPLIANCE WITH WRITTEN ORDER:
1688-02 JAMISON, KENDALE D. TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00308-CR
1769-02 BECKMAN, ARTHUR BECKMAN RAINS COUNTY 12-01-00155-CR
1801-02 JOHNSON, MICHAEL JOSEPH HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-01120-CR
PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER, JUDGES HERVEY AND KEASLER DISSENT TO THE ABOVE ORDERS:
STATE’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW STRUCK FOR NON-COMPLIANCE WITH WRITTEN ORDER:
1683-02 BALLARD, TESA NAVARRO COUNTY 10-01-00323-CR
1684-02 BALLARD, TESA NAVARRO COUNTY 10-01-00324-CR
PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER, JUDGES HERVEY AND KEASLER DISSENT TO THE ABOVE ORDERS:
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
11,571-10 SYNNACHIA CARL MCQUEEN HARRIS COUNTY
25,112-02 KURT WAYNE REISER TARRANT COUNTY
27,385-02 MARK EMERSON HOPKINS TARRANT COUNTY
48,589-02 WILLIAM JAMES JACKSON HARRIS COUNTY
50,607-02 KARIS F. WILLIAMS SMITH COUNTY
53,157-02 LEE THOMAS BOONE CAMERON COUNTY
54,316-02 DENNIS RAY SULLIVAN POLK COUNTY
54,388-02 RICHARD DEREK ILES HOPKINS COUNTY
54,431-01 LARRY GENE HAMMER VAN ZANDT COUNTY
54,544-01 ROBERT TYRONE LILLY TAYLOR COUNTY
54,582-01 SHELBY WAYNE FIFE CALDWELL COUNTY
54,597-01 BEJAN MATTHEW BALDWIN HARRIS COUNTY
54,612-04 REYES LARA DALLAS COUNTY
54,623-01 ERIC R DIXON LUBBOCK COUNTY
54,632-01 RONALD EDWARD JACKSON POTTER COUNTY
54,648-01 GRADY INGRAM SMITH COUNTY
54,658-01 RONNIE EUGENE BYRD DALLAS COUNTY
54,668-01 DONTE TREMAYNE PULLEY DALLAS COUNTY
54,668-02 DONTE TREMAYNE PULLEY DALLAS COUNTY
54,668-03 DONTE TREMAYNE PULLEY DALLAS COUNTY
54,697-01 LEVON LEE DENMARK HUNT COUNTY
54,711-01 LARRY DALE SMITH GREGG COUNTY
54,733-01 JAVIER DELGADO SAN PATRICIO COUNTY
54,751-01 MICHAEL W ADAMS LUBBOCK COUNTY
54,771-01 EDDIE HOWARD GASTON WHEELER COUNTY
54,780-01 JESUS MENDOZA TARRANT COUNTY
54,786-01 JACK MARVIN ROOT DENTON COUNTY
54,790-01 MICHAEL WADE CROUCH GREGG COUNTY
54,800-01 EDDIE LEE BISHOP HARRIS COUNTY
54,830-01 FRANCISCO H RAMIREZ HARRIS COUNTY
54,839-01 RICKY STEVE MOORE UPSHUR COUNTY
54,857-01 RONNIE DEAN GILLAM CAMERON COUNTY
54,865-01 CLARENCE L TURNER GUADALUPE COUNTY
54,903-01 CASEY GENE DODSON CASS COUNTY
54,948-01 RICHARD JR DELEON POTTER COUNTY
54,948-02 RICHARD JR DELEON POTTER COUNTY
54,948-03 RICHARD JR DELEON POTTER COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)
32,300-02 STEVEN LEE CLINE HARRIS COUNTY
32,493-02 ANTHONY BELAFONTE KEIL JEFFERSON COUNTY
35,988-04 JEFFERY O. BROUSSARD HARRIS COUNTY
45,128-02 JOHN TARRANIA PERRY MONTGOMERY COUNTY
46,220-02 HERMAN JR. BROWN BOWIE COUNTY
47,921-02 RICHARD DON WELLER DENTON COUNTY
47,921-03 RICHARD DON WELLER DENTON COUNTY
50,257-05 RICHARD JAMES JOHNSON ANGELINA COUNTY
54,106-02 CHARLES CERF HARRIS COUNTY
54,305-02 STEPHEN WYNN TIPPING DALLAS COUNTY
54,427-01 JEFFERY TILDON FINNEY HARRIS COUNTY
54,571-01 SHEILA YARBROUGH MONTGOMERY COUNTY
54,579-01 RONALD MAX VERNON HARRIS COUNTY
54,612-01 REYES LARA DALLAS COUNTY
54,612-02 REYES LARA DALLAS COUNTY
54,612-03 REYES LARA DALLAS COUNTY
54,629-01 AMADOR CASAS CHARLES NUECES COUNTY
54,664-01 DAVID PHYLLEP ANDREWS BEXAR COUNTY
54,682-01 PERKIN THIBODEAUX JEFFERSON COUNTY
54,728-01 PHILIP JAKE COX EL PASO COUNTY
54,752-01 JOHN CHARLES DOSS HARRIS COUNTY
54,798-01 MATIAS MATT III ESPINOZA HARRIS COUNTY
54,799-01 MARK O'NEIL BRADSHAW WILLIAMSON COUNTY
54,807-01 ROBERT GEORGE FLECK MONTGOMERY COUNTY
54,822-01 FRED JR TROUTT HARRIS COUNTY
54,859-01 LLOYD BARKER ELLIS COUNTY
54,874-01 KEVIN ALEXANDER JONES DALLAS COUNTY
54,878-01 DAVID HEHIR DALLAS COUNTY
54,878-02 DAVID HEHIR DALLAS COUNTY
54,890-01 BARBARA G HOLDER GALVESTON COUNTY
54,896-01 RICKEY JOHNSON BEXAR COUNTY
54,902-01 KEITH D BARBOUR TARRANT COUNTY
54,902-02 KEITH D BARBOUR TARRANT COUNTY
54,970-01 JULIAN CARL HUTTO HARRIS COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITH HEARING)
49,173-01 RANDOLPH SCOTT BELLARD HARRIS COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
48,488-02 MARTY GARCIA BEXAR COUNTY
50,533-06 LUCAS BERMEA CONSTANCIO HALE COUNTY
54,545-01 CURTIS LEE GREEN PARKER COUNTY
54,545-02 CURTIS LEE GREEN PARKER COUNTY
54,545-03 CURTIS LEE GREEN PARKER COUNTY
54,545-04 CURTIS LEE GREEN PARKER COUNTY
54,726-01 FRANCISCO OCHOA EL PASO COUNTY
54,862-01 NORBERTO GARCIA BEXAR COUNTY
54,879-01 JESUS JAVIER MARTINEZ TARRANT COUNTY
54,949-01 TERRY ROY ROEMER LEE COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)
54,750-01 JESUOROBO ISAAC RUSHER TARRANT COUNTY
54,837-01 JACOB HENRY NORRIS HARRIS COUNTY
54,848-01 KEVIN TYRONE LEWIS DELTA COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)
15,395-12 MARION RAY MOSLEY DALLAS COUNTY
22,756-16 L. J. JACKSON POTTER COUNTY
31,097-05 LILLIE MICHAELINE JENKA BEXAR COUNTY
42,059-02 BYRON HARVEY INGRAM TARRANT COUNTY
45,352-04 LARRY CORMIER FAYETTE COUNTY
45,651-03 SCOTT ALLEN SAMFORD JR. DALLAS COUNTY
48,114-04 NORRIS HOUSE ANGELINA COUNTY
52,405-03 GENARO RAMIREZ JACKSON COUNTY
6,714-14 RAUL GOMEZ VILLALOBOS CAMERON COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER
(TEX. GOV'T CODE SEC. 501.0081 (b) )
40,692-02 RICHARD CHARLES GILBERT TAYLOR COUNTY
40,692-03 RICHARD CHARLES GILBERT TAYLOR COUNTY
54,459-01 DONNIE HAYNES JONES COUNTY
54,486-01 RICHARD ORLANDO LUCIO HARRIS COUNTY
54,486-02 RICHARD ORLANDO LUCIO HARRIS COUNTY
54,756-01 JONATHAN A DONALDSON HARRIS COUNTY
54,791-01 PAMELA DENISE DOUGLAS TARRANT COUNTY
54,816-01 TERRY EUGENE ROSS HARRIS COUNTY
54,818-01 ROBERT CRAIG OBANNON DALLAS COUNTY
54,901-01 BILLY WAYNE JR SIMMONS RANDALL COUNTY
54,905-01 RAYMUNDO RENDON EL PASO COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:
38,213-02 DYROL T. STUBBS TARRANT COUNTY
43,313-02 MARIO ARRENDONDO IBARRA WILBARGER COUNTY
53,482-01 STEVE RANDALE KING TARRANT COUNTY
54,592-01 KENNETH WAYNE BELL HARRIS COUNTY
54,630-01 AURELIO VILLEGAS GONZALES HOPKINS COUNTY
54,637-01 JESSE AREBALO TARRANT COUNTY
54,787-01 DEBORA LYNN STANTON MATAGORDA COUNTY
ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:
54,340-01 LUIS SALAZAR BEXAR COUNTY
(JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:
49,854-02 SHIRLEY ADAMS JEFFERSON COUNTY
52,379-02 RICHARD SHAYNE EMBRY GREGG COUNTY
53,013-01 SIXTO ABINA FERNANDEZ WISE COUNTY
53,520-01 DARRELL WADE POLLOCK THROCKMORTON COUNTY
53,621-01 GEORGE L. HARTLEY TARRANT COUNTY
54,015-01 BILLY DALE BOND KERR COUNTY
54,693-01 GERALD HOWE BOWIE COUNTY
54,814-01 IGNACIO RODRIGUEZ WEBB COUNTY
54,826-01 QUINTON JERMAINE WILSON HARRIS COUNTY
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE
AND RESPONDENT IS ORDERED TO FILE ANSWER:
26,047-07 LARRY GENE STRHAN DALLAS COUNTY
38,247-02 MARCUS TAYLOR TRAVIS COUNTY
54,942-01 MICHAEL RUNTRAIL RICHARDS HARRIS COUNTY
54,955-01 LOUIS ORTA HARRIS COUNTY
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT
WRITTEN ORDER:
25,260-02 LEONARD RAY CROOMS HARRIS COUNTY
25,869-54 RONALD DWAYNE WHITFIELD HARRIS COUNTY
25,934-02 FREDDIE DEE JR BROWN DALLAS COUNTY
26,047-06 LARRY GENE STRHAN COUNTY
35,988-03 JEFFERY O. BROUSSARD HARRIS COUNTY
42,422-02 WARDELL MOORE FAYETTE COUNTY
45,807-02 ELEAZAR DE LA ROSA COUNTY
50,188-02 LACONCHA SOWETO MCASHON HARRIS COUNTY
51,219-02 LEE ANTHONY FLORES HARRIS COUNTY
51,525-04 JUAN CARLOS SIERRA COMAL COUNTY
51,808-02 KENNETH RAY DERRICK DALLAS COUNTY
53,319-01 JIMMY PANTOJA COUNTY
54,106-01 CHARLES CERF HARRIS COUNTY
54,305-01 STEPHEN WYNN TIPPING DALLAS COUNTY
54,316-01 DENNIS RAY SULLIVAN COUNTY
54,872-01 DONALD O ZALESKI BEXAR COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS STRUCK FOR NON-COMPLIANCE WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
08,774-18 ARTHUR WAYNE CARSON TARRANT COUNTY
52,683-02 LUCIA GOMEZ GUADARRAMA BEXAR COUNTY
54,870-01 RODOLFO T. MOLANO BEXAR COUNTY
54,884-01 JEFFREY LYNN BONNER NAVARRO COUNTY
54,897-01 TERESA KYLE BEXAR COUNTY
54,973-01 JAMES WILFORD MOORE, II ANDERSON COUNTY
54,983-01 QUINTEN TAVARIS ADAMS DALLAS COUNTY
54,983-02 QUINTEN TAVARIS ADAMS DALLAS COUNTY
55,011-01 ARNOLD RAY LAMOTTE, JR. TRAVIS COUNTY
55,025-01 RODNEY LAMAR FOBBS LAMAR COUNTY
55,028-01 LANCE WILLIAM TISDALE TRAVIS COUNTY