THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS
FEBRUARY 6, 2002
THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:
73,729 MANUEL VASQUEZ FROM BEXAR COUNTY
AFFIRMED–OPINION PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER
(JUDGE JOHNSON CONCURRED IN THE RESULTS)
(JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)
PUBLISHED OPINION
HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)
74,262 EX PARTE RICHARD MARTINEZ FROM BEXAR COUNTY
74,270 EX PARTE SHAWN ADAMS FROM BRAZORIA COUNTY
74,271 EX PARTE SHAWN ADAMS FROM BRAZORIA COUNTY
74,272 EX PARTE SHAWN ADAMS FROM BRAZORIA COUNTY
74,273 EX PARTE SHAWN ADAMS FROM BRAZORIA COUNTY
74,274 EX PARTE SHAWN ADAMS FROM BRAZORIA COUNTY
74,275 EX PARTE SHAWN ADAMS FROM BRAZORIA COUNTY
74,276 EX PARTE FRANK D. CROWLEY FROM BELL COUNTY
74,277 EX PARTE A. G. RADCLIFF FROM HARRIS COUNTY
APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING DENIED:
74,185 EX PARTE MAX MOUSSAZADEH FROM HARRIS COUNTY
STATE'S MOTION FOR REHEARING DENIED:
73,350 KIMBERLY LAGAYLE MCCARTHY FROM DALLAS COUNTY
(JUDGE KEASLER NOT PARTICIPATING)
ON APPELLANT’S MOTION FOR REHEARING ON STATE’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DENIED:
610-00 BOBBY RAY HAYDEN, JR. UPSHUR COUNTY 06-98-00241-CR
ON STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:
0527-99 MATTHEW MEDRANO EL PASO COUNTY 08-97-00462-CR
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;
CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS–OPINION JUDGE COCHRAN
(JUDGE MEYERS NOT PARTICIPATING)
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON
DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE WOMACK
(JUDGE PRICE JOINED)
PUBLISHED OPINION
0243-00 RONNIE FREEMAN (DA’S NO. 1) LUBBOCK COUNTY 07-97-00347-CR
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;
CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS–PER CURIAM OPINION MK
(JUDGE PRICE DISSENTED)
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS
(JUDGE HOLCOMB JOINED)
NON-PUBLISHED OPINION
0243-00 RONNIE FREEMAN (SPA’S NO. 2) LUBBOCK COUNTY 07-97-00347-CR
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;
CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS–PER CURIAM OPINION MK
(JUDGE PRICE DISSENTED)
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS
(JUDGE HOLCOMB JOINED)
NON-PUBLISHED OPINION
APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:
2012-01 OCTAVIO CASTANEDA HIDALGO COUNTY 13-99-00732-CV
2013-01 OCTAVIO CASTANEDA HIDALGO COUNTY 13-99-00733-CV
2014-01 OCTAVIO CASTANEDA HIDALGO COUNTY 13-99-00734-CV
2015-01 OCTAVIO CASTANEDA HIDALGO COUNTY 13-99-00736-CV
2016-01 OCTAVIO CASTANEDA HIDALGO COUNTY 13-99-00737-CV
(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
2116-01 JONATHAN MANZI HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-01308-CR
(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:
1742-01 RUDOLFO LOPEZ BEXAR COUNTY 04-96-00343-CR
(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
(JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)
1790-01 JONATHAN DANIEL RUSHING MCLENNAN COUNTY 10-00-00084-CR
(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
(PDR NO. 2)
1932-01 MARCUS TURNER TARRANT COUNTY 02-99-00410-CR
(GRANTED ON GROUND NOS. 2 & 3 ONLY)
(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:
0881-01 REYES, RICHARD RAY MCLENNAN COUNTY 10-99-00226-CR
1306-01 COKER, REGGIE SMITH HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00352-CR
1321-01 WILLIAMS, ANTHONY D. (#1) TARRANT COUNTY 10-99-00188-CR
1538-01 JOHNSON, WILLIAM TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00286-CR
1679-01 LEAL, ISRAEL RODRIGUEZ JACKSON COUNTY 13-99-00779-CR
1696-01 DIAZ, FERNANDO CARRASCO MITCHELL COUNTY 11-99-00327-CR
1713-01 SHORES, JIMMY RAY FANNIN COUNTY 06-00-00061-CR
1724-01 MILAM, JOHN MARSH HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-00078-CR
1741-01 LAW, RICKEY BERNARD DALLAS COUNTY 11-01-00060-CR
1768-01 WATERS, CARL LEE TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00153-CR
1790-01 RUSHING, JONATHAN DANIEL (#1) MCLENNAN COUNTY 10-00-00084-CR
1801-01 WYNN, DARRON DWAYNE TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00203-CR
1807-01 NARANJO, RENE, JR. DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01879-CR
1823-01 LENOX, DREW HAROLD FRANKLIN COUNTY 06-00-00246-CR
1869-01 GONZALES, MATTHEW ANTHONY HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00893-CR
1883-01 MOMON, ERIC CHARLES HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00260-CR
1884-01 MOMON, ERIC CHARLES HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00261-CR
1971-01 SMITH, ROLAND HAYES HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-01445-CR
2104-01 GRAHN, EMILY JEAN NUECES COUNTY 13-00-00063-CR
2150-01 WILLIAMS, MICHAEL LEE HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00036-CR
2154-01 HAMILTON, GEORGE ALVIN PALO PINTO COUNTY 11-00-00191-CR
2157-01 CROSSON, NICHOLAS HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00297-CR
2310-01 FRANKLIN, TERRENCE B. TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00196-CR
2311-01 FRANKLIN, TERRENCE B. TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00197-CR
2335-01 ANDERSON, DOROTHY LOU HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00171-CR
2336-01 ANDERSON, DOROTHY LOU HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00172-CR
2338-01 FLINT, ADRIAN CHARLES HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00954-CR
2339-01 FLINT, ADRIAN CHARLES HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00955-CR
2340-01 VU, TOMMY TAM HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00359-CR
2357-01 WALLS, TERRY N. HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00259-CR
STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:
1321-01 WILLIAMS, ANTHONY D. (#2) TARRANT COUNTY 10-99-00188-CR
2092-01 KANNEH, ABU B. HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00031-CR
APPELLANT’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DISMISSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:
1970-01 WASHINGTON, LADERRICK DEWAYNE DALLAS COUNTY 13-00-00418-CR
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
13,696-03 GREGORY L. KILLEN GREGG COUNTY
13,763-06 MICHAEL JOSEPH FUHRMAN HARRIS COUNTY
17,583-08 FREDDIE LEE WALKER BEXAR COUNTY
(JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)
20,325-02 CALVIN EUGENE NORRIS FRIO COUNTY
23,467-02 LEVESTER GARRETT, JR. WALLER COUNTY
25,885-02 BRUCE KEITH MARSHALL WILLIAMSON COUNTY
26,825-05 DAVID CHASE BOYD KNOX COUNTY
27,711-04 CHANEY OSWALD GUMPERT DALLAS COUNTY
28,666-02 JAMES ANTHONY GAREAU TARRANT COUNTY
29,516-04 MARK DAVID GODFREY BRAZORIA COUNTY
29,516-05 MARK DAVID GODFREY BRAZORIA COUNTY
3,212-06 WILSON WALKER, JR. DALLAS COUNTY
30,187-09 DONALD PENCE PRUITT DALLAS COUNTY
33,036-04 GENTRY STEPHEN LEONARD DALLAS COUNTY
33,036-05 GENTRY STEPHEN LEONARD DALLAS COUNTY
38,541-04 LONNIE HENRY RECTOR JR. HARRIS COUNTY
39,054-06 PATRICK E. SANDERS TARRANT COUNTY
39,622-04 THOMAS C. RETZLAFF BELL COUNTY
41,186-02 KENNETH GREVE CAMERON COUNTY
43,445-02 PAUL ERVIN WILLIAMS III LUBBOCK COUNTY
45,591-02 YURI A. TOWNSEND LUBBOCK COUNTY
45,591-03 YURI A. TOWNSEND LUBBOCK COUNTY
47,132-03 JIMMY CLYDE DARUGHTERY DALLAS COUNTY
49,666-02 JAMES WILBON GRAY COUNTY
50,257-02 RICHARD JAMES JOHNSON ANDERSON COUNTY
50,572-01 ANDRE DUPREE STEPTOE HALL COUNTY
51,075-01 WILLIAM DAVID MORRIS IV DALLAS COUNTY
51,130-01 GETZELL DESHEA MURRELL TARRANT COUNTY
51,131-01 GARY DONAS LUTTRELL TARRANT COUNTY
51,131-02 GARY DONAS LUTTRELL TARRANT COUNTY
51,179-01 CASIMIRO GONZALEZ SALAZAR BAILEY COUNTY
51,185-01 SYLVESTER CASAREZ NUECES COUNTY
51,188-01 ROBERT LEWIS WILLICH HENDERSON COUNTY
51,189-01 BILLY WAYNE SLAYTON COLEMAN COUNTY
51,205-01 DANIEL CHAVEZ YBARRA HUNT COUNTY
51,225-01 RODIMIRO QUESADA ROBLES BEXAR COUNTY
51,228-01 TERRENCE IAN CROSBY NUECES COUNTY
51,239-01 TONY JEFF BREWER MADISON COUNTY
51,274-01 AL J. RICHARDS MILAM COUNTY
51,295-01 DAVID HEREDIA NIETO HOWARD COUNTY
51,295-02 DAVID HEREDIA NIETO HOWARD COUNTY
51,301-01 AUGUSTA ROBINSON, JR. SMITH COUNTY
51,349-01 JAMES LEE WALDO GUADALUPE COUNTY
51,360-01 EDWARD WINTON ANDERSON COUNTY
51,382-01 PETE ORANDAY III BANDERA COUNTY
51,406-01 ARMANDO GUTIERREZ POTTER COUNTY
51,429-01 JULIUS CLINTON RANDOLPH GREGG COUNTY
51,447-01 WILLIAM LEONARD CHERRY JR. HOOD COUNTY
51,449-01 KENT FALES MATAGORDA COUNTY
51,449-02 KENT FALES MATAGORDA COUNTY
51,455-01 RAUL SAUSEDA BRAZOS COUNTY
51,477-01 CORBETT LEE JONES LAMAR COUNTY
51,479-01 ROBERT CLINTON HINKLE HENDERSON COUNTY
51,489-01 CALVIN LEE MITCHELL MORRIS COUNTY
51,495-01 TONY LEE COLLIER GREGG COUNTY
51,499-01 DESMOND KITWANA BETHANY DALLAS COUNTY
51,500-01 JERRY LEE BIDDINGER JOHNSON COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)
27,028-02 WILLIAM RILEY STORMENT POTTER COUNTY
28,112-02 RICKY DION WILLIAMS DALLAS COUNTY
44,949-03 JOSE DIAZ BEXAR COUNTY
46,606-02 KIM HUTSON TAYLOR HARRIS COUNTY
49,104-02 BALMORE ESCAMILLA HARRIS COUNTY
50,217-02 EDWARD LEWIS HARRIS COUNTY
50,217-03 EDWARD LEWIS HARRIS COUNTY
50,368-01 JAMES RICHARD HARRIS DALLAS COUNTY
50,480-01 MELVIN LUTHER JORDAN DALLAS COUNTY
50,576-02 GARY ROXBURG WORRELL HARRIS COUNTY
51,014-01 HARRY LEE ROWSER BELL COUNTY
51,072-01 STEVEN TATE HARRIS COUNTY
51,078-01 MALCOLM CLARK MIDLAND COUNTY
51,151-01 THOMAS CHARLES SHARP JR. TARRANT COUNTY
51,154-01 BRANDON KINTE HATTON HARRIS COUNTY
51,199-01 EDWARD LEE COX MONTGOMERY COUNTY
51,257-01 JOHN MICHAEL POWERS TOM GREEN COUNTY
51,258-01 JUAN M. RODRIGUEZ BEXAR COUNTY
51,267-01 MICHAEL DWAYNE JONES TARRANT COUNTY
51,285-01 JACKIE WAYNE GRISHAM SMITH COUNTY
51,298-01 VICTOR CARDENAS BEXAR COUNTY
(JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)
51,304-01 JOE DE LEON QUINTERO BEXAR COUNTY
51,316-01 JAMES CRUMBLEY HARRIS COUNTY
51,318-01 OTIS BURKS JR. HARRIS COUNTY
51,385-01 KENDRICK ASHLEY SYKES DALLAS COUNTY
51,391-01 EDWARD DELAWRENCE GREEN DALLAS COUNTY
51,395-01 CHRISTOPHER RENE PENA DALLAS COUNTY
51,417-01 CHARLES RAY KELLEY MONTGOMERY COUNTY
51,423-01 MIGUEL JACKSON DALLAS COUNTY
51,427-01 AMBROSE M. WEBB HARRIS COUNTY
51,427-02 AMBROSE M. WEBB HARRIS COUNTY
51,454-01 MARY ANN HORTON HARRIS COUNTY
51,483-01 JOSEPH PRINCE AGHOLER HARRIS COUNTY
51,483-02 JOSEPH PRINCE AGHOLER HARRIS COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
11,844-08 ROY LEE SHIELDS JR. BROWN COUNTY
18,282-09 CORRIE LEE LYONS JR. HARRIS COUNTY
48,297-02 HERBERT RENTERIA MORENO HARRIS COUNTY
51,234-01 ANTHONY TYRONE O'NEAL GALVESTON COUNTY
51,321-01 BORIS DEMETRIUS GEE TAYLOR COUNTY
51,422-01 DEWAYNE ALBERT DEAVER HARRIS COUNTY
51,499-02 DESMOND KITWANA BETHANY DALLAS COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)
18,932-04 PHILLIP WAYNE KERSH HARRIS COUNTY
42,776-09 DONALD FOSTER ORANGE COUNTY
42,776-10 DONALD FOSTER ORANGE COUNTY
42,776-11 DONALD FOSTER ORANGE COUNTY
51,268-01 TU MINH TRINH HARRIS COUNTY
51,344-01 MYRON LOVINGS HARRIS COUNTY
51,393-01 SHAUN ANTHONY ROBBINS BRAZORIA COUNTY
51,394-01 CORBETT HALL, JR. WICHITA COUNTY
51,485-01 EVERADO VASQUEZ HARRIS COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)
16,779-21 KIRK WAYNE MCBRIDE COMAL COUNTY
25,904-03 BARRY ALLEN FISHER CORYELL COUNTY
33,643-11 RICKY G. MORENO TARRANT COUNTY
33,643-12 RICKY G. MORENO WHARTON COUNTY
35,146-02 LARRY DONNELL RUSK NACOGDOCHES COUNTY
39,751-02 BOBBY CHARLES STEEL HARRIS COUNTY
39,797-03 JOHN EDWARD GARRETT BEXAR COUNTY
47,700-02 DALTON JUSTIN GRAY CHEROKEE COUNTY
8,006-12 ADOLPHUS HILL TARRANT COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER
(TEX. GOV'T CODE SEC. 501.0081 (b) )
18,354-03 BILLY EARL ANDERSON ROBERTSON COUNTY
32,031-01 BOBBY J. WALLER DALLAS COUNTY
38,704-02 JAMES BURTON HURST COLLIN COUNTY
41,346-02 MANUEL P. GARCIA ANDREWS COUNTY
49,623-01 RAUL FUENTES BEXAR COUNTY
51,184-01 ABELARDO CHAPA JR. HARRIS COUNTY
51,312-01 VINCENT SAULS LAVACA COUNTY
51,312-02 VINCENT SAULS LAVACA COUNTY
51,315-01 CASSIE WALTER HOUSTON TAYLOR COUNTY
51,359-01 CHARLES R. MCCROSKEY OCHILTREE COUNTY
51,405-01 ROGER LOPEZ BEXAR COUNTY
51,478-01 TAMMY SUE HOLLAND LAMAR COUNTY
51,484-01 DAVID DIXON TARRANT COUNTY
7,355-04 MELVIN LOUIS ADAMS TARRANT COUNTY
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE
AND RESPONDENT IS ORDERED TO FILE ANSWER:
24,079-03 WILLIAM LESTER RICE HARRIS COUNTY
28,354-15 IMARI ABYBAKARI OBADELE HARRIS COUNTY
32,090-02 ROLLAND E. LAWSON TRAVIS COUNTY
5,813-11 CLIFTON JONES HARRIS COUNTY
50,993-01 AARON RUTLEDGE DALLAS COUNTY
51,209-01 SIDNEY SAM ZENON HARRIS COUNTY
51,388-01 JOSE V. PEREZ HARRIS COUNTY
51,390-01 EDWARD B. LYON, JR. BOWIE COUNTY
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT
WRITTEN ORDER:
13,470-10 CARL WILLIAM JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY
13,514-10 MANDELL RHODES, JR. GREGG COUNTY
22,735-19 ALFRED LEE STONE DALLAS COUNTY
26,825-05 DAVID CHASE BOYD KNOX COUNTY
30,445-02 JOHN WAYNE BATES GALVESTON COUNTY
31,451-04 KEITH LAWRENCE SOMERVILLE DALLAS COUNTY
32,926-02 DARYL VAN MINOR BRAZOS COUNTY
33,643-13 RICKY G. MORENO TARRANT COUNTY
40,680-03 JOSEPH REED HARRIS COUNTY
41,539-05 TROY RICHARDSON DAWSON COUNTY
42,776-08 DONALD FOSTER ORANGE COUNTY
43,919-07 DONALD R. BURR TARRANT COUNTY
44,026-02 CHEYENNE PATE LIMESTONE COUNTY
44,949-02 JOSE ALFREDO CAMACHO EL PASO COUNTY
50,576-01 GARY ROXBURG WORRELL HARRIS COUNTY
51,476-01 SHAWN JETTER EL PASO COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:
18,465-06 DAVID LEYVAS HARRIS COUNTY
48,469-01 TYRONE EZELL YOUNG ECTOR COUNTY
49,805-02 SCOTTIE A. CETNAR DALLAS COUNTY
49,805-03 SCOTTIE A. CETNAR DALLAS COUNTY
51,077-01 CARRELL JUNIOR CONDOR HOOD COUNTY
51,113-01 ROBERT HERNANDEZ MCLENNAN COUNTY
51,195-01 KENNETH HOWARD HARRIS COUNTY
51,195-02 KENNETH HOWARD HARRIS COUNTY
51,195-03 KENNETH HOWARD HARRIS COUNTY
51,347-01 AUTRY VAUGHN JR. LUBBOCK COUNTY
51,372-01 DAVID ANDREW BASSETT DALLAS COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:
49,924-01 SHAWN ADAMS BRAZORIA COUNTY
49,924-02 SHAWN ADAMS BRAZORIA COUNTY
49,924-03 SHAWN ADAMS BRAZORIA COUNTY
49,924-04 SHAWN ADAMS BRAZORIA COUNTY
49,924-05 SHAWN ADAMS BRAZORIA COUNTY
49,924-06 SHAWN ADAMS BRAZORIA COUNTY
51,040-01 A.G. RADCLIFF HARRIS COUNTY
51,051-01 FRANK D. CROWLEY BELL COUNTY
51,144-01 RICHARD MARTINEZ BEXAR COUNTY
(JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)
ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:
48,825-01 RONALD RAY HOWARD JACKSON COUNTY
51,264-01 DERRICK SEAN O’BRIEN HARRIS COUNTY
ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:
45,156-02 LORENZO MORRIS HARRIS COUNTY
51,264-02 DERRICK SEAN O’BRIEN HARRIS COUNTY